3 ms·
The problem with the No True Scotsman fallacy is that it's impossible to apply to the internet, where there is always someone out there who will claim anything
by the_af 10y ago
The problem with the No True Scotsman fallacy is that it's impossible to apply to the internet, where there is always someone out there who will claim anything about anything.
Therefore, in order to have a rational discussion about this, we must apply some sort of filter.
I propose this filter: no-one who is an actual practitioner of FP (someone who uses it to build software, not someone who just talks about it in the internet) will not make the claim you mentioned, i.e. "FP guarantees good code" (I'm quoting you verbatim).
I hope it stands to reason that it doesn't matter what people who've never used FP claim about FP.
- twblalock 10y agoIt's still a fallacy. Being on the internet doesn't change that. > I hope it stands to reason that it doesn't matter what people who've never used FP claim about FP. That doesn't matter. An argument is not a strawman if it has been made by anyone, anywhere, anytime, for any reason. You can't just filter out the people you think don't count. An argument is only a strawman if it is a false argument, e.g. one that has been invented by the person who is arguing against it. If you want to have a discussion about the merits of FP, feel free to filter out whoever you like. But you said the argument mentioned in the article is a strawman, and it isn't.