3 ms·
I think ideally, karma should just be there for feedback for the poster and the reader. Paradoxically, the only reason karma is meaningful is that it is useless
by paulgb 19y ago
I think ideally, karma should just be there for feedback for the poster and the reader. Paradoxically, the only reason karma is meaningful is that it is useless - there is no incentive to game the system. If more karma means more power, there is an incentive to post to get karma instead of posting to help the community.
If you don't believe that incentivising karma is a bad thing, try this thought experiment: if you gave away $1.00 for each karma point earned, would the quality of the content go up or down? You can add some conditions if you think the experiment is unfair, but I think you would still find that the quality would be reduced with incentives.
Ultimately, 99% of the users are just like you and I and do not want to see news.yc turn into another digg/reddit. Why not take advantage of that, instead of treating it like a technical problem when it is really a community issue.
- rms 19y agoMan, I'd kill to get $1 per karma point... I wonder how much my account would go for on eBay.
- mightybyte 19y ago> If more karma means more power, there is an incentive to post to get karma instead of posting to help the community. One could argue that in the current community, posting to get karma and posting to help the community are one and the same. Reddit's downfall came more because of a change in the composition of the community than because of karma incentives. At the same time, you're right about the problems of people trying to get karma for karma's sake. I think the best way to reduce this problem is to make it harder to gain karma than just by posting popular links. > Ultimately, 99% of the users are just like you and I and do not want to see news.yc turn into another digg/reddit. Why not take advantage of that, instead of treating it like a technical problem when it is really a community issue. You're right. It is a community issue. But as soon as the "hordes of 14-year-olds" invade, the 99% you cite will drop. The current technical solution doesn't prevent that from happening. We're trying to find one that does.