3 ms·
You've done a great job at pointing out the weaknesses of the arguments -- bodies do get repaired, people manage to find things to do, and accidental death is a
by DanielBMarkham 17y ago
You've done a great job at pointing out the weaknesses of the arguments -- bodies do get repaired, people manage to find things to do, and accidental death is a much easier risk to deal with than certain death.
However bodies are not even in the same few orders of magnitude of complexity as an old car, spending 200 years plugged into Facebook probably isn't the most productive thing for the rest of society, and your brain still can only hold so much and you still be you.
So -- points for pointing out the flaws, but no credit for failing to see the larger truth. Yes, being alive forever beats dying. Now on to step 2, where you start critically thinking about the odds of you personally living forever and the real trade-offs with not dying. Which is Jacques point.
The main point where Jacques blew it? He used our current definition of human as a working definition for the future. This species is evolving, and evolving at a super-fast rate. I don't think we would recognize our descendants ten thousand years from now as being human in any way.
- sailormoon 17y agoWho's spending 200 years plugged into Facebook? I don't use it now and I doubt I'd suddenly start. I've got things to do! your brain still can only hold so much and you still be you Well by that logic I've died several times already. I'm very far from the same person I was at age 5 or even 15. I don't mind changing and evolving, even if you want to call that a kind of death. It's so gradual that I doubt I'd even notice. on to step 2, where you start critically thinking about the odds of you personally living forever I do not pretend that the odds are favourable, but that is orthogonal to all this justification about why dying is good and healthy. Dying sucks, man, no matter how much you try to dress it up as a good, socially beneficial natural part of life. the real trade-offs with not dying. Which is Jacques point. Well, I guess my point is that I could not care less what the trade-off is, anything is better than dying, because any problem can be solved, but you can never come back from death.