4 ms·
Wow. It's amazing, she looks just like every women engineer I've ever worked with. Especially the Bluetooth headset. Seriously, does this do anything to advan
by jgrahamc 17y ago
Wow. It's amazing, she looks just like every women engineer I've ever worked with. Especially the Bluetooth headset.
Seriously, does this do anything to advance the position of women in software engineering?
- ugh 17y agoI wouldn’t worry, other careers aren’t doing that much better :) http://shop.mattel.com/product/index.jsp?productId=3882807 http://shop.mattel.com/product/index.jsp?productId=3882807
- wynand 17y agoNothing would do more for women in engineering than having more well known female engineers. Social proof is a strong thing. But until we have more of that, cultural items like Barbie might help to bootstrap the process. I agree that it's a distant second, but it's better than nothing at all.
- jgrahamc 17y agoI agree that it's a distant second, but it's better than nothing at all. I'm not sure. Suppose the situation was reversed and there were few men software engineers. I'm not sure having a super handsome, muscle ripped man wearing designer clothing would have been an inspiration to me.
- dgabriel 17y agoRight, but a cartoon about an action hero nurse who goes on exciting adventures might open you to the possibility that this was a career for men, too.
- roundsquare 17y agoAt the risk of sounding sexist, different things would appeal to little girls and little boys. Your analogy is too exact, which is what is causing the difficulty. Not to say this will inspire little girls, I have no idea at all.
- jamii 17y ago> I'm not sure having a super handsome, muscle ripped man wearing designer clothing would have been an inspiration to me. I don't know about you but I wanted to be Action Man as a young child.
- pchristensen 17y agoI wanted to be a lumberjack.
- protomyth 17y agoHow many men went into engineering because of the well known male engineers? I'm thinking the number is low and most went in because they had the knack or interest. Heck, you have to actually brave all the crap stereotypes Hollywood creates about engineers.
- astrec 17y agoI think so. This talk by Pamela Fox should offer some insight: http://igniteshow.com/videos/im-barbie-girl-cs-world http://igniteshow.com/videos/im-barbie-girl-cs-world
- rbanffy 17y agoWhy do we need to insist that every profession should be evenly divided between men and women? Wouldn't it be denial of differences that we know exist? How much of my wife's decision to become a psychologist comes from a perception that she couldn't be a mathematician or a physicist and how much comes from her intellectual pursuits? How much from my decision to become an engineer stem from culture and how much comes from "the knack"? When I graduated (almost 20 years ago) there were about 10% women in my class. When my wife graduated, there were 5% men in her class. Assuming there are no cultural barriers against men, wouldn't that indicate professional choices stem, at least a little, from gender? I am not saying there are no cultural barriers, but I am asking when and where it is too much. I am not sure what purpose a computer engineer Barbie serves beyond selling a few more dolls to girls who would be more interested in Legos than dolls.
- aphyr 17y agoThree things suggest to me that gender differences are not as intrinsic as we might assume, given the current disparity: 1. Social groups tend to select for like individuals. Many women (and other under-represented people) find it surprisingly difficult to make it in the scientific, academic, and engineering communities when their advisors, peers, and bosses are overwhelmingly white males. Expectations that women "simply don't" do field X are shockingly present to this day. This suggests that we have not yet reached an equilibrium point where women are fairly represented with respect to their full potential. 2. Other countries have significantly varying gender ratios in these fields. That suggests that the difference is partly cultural. 3. In the US, we lose an astonishing number of young women from academic and engineering tracks. Standardized test performance (as well as metrics like "confidence in math ability") fall off dramatically in seventh grade--a time period where girls are under tremendous social pressure. By the time undergrad rolls around, few are still trying to become scientists, mathematicians, and engineers. One of my former professors, Melissa Eblen-Zayas, has a good summary of links about women and minority participation in physics: http://people.carleton.edu/~meblenza/Resources.html http://people.carleton.edu/~meblenza/Resources.html
- rbanffy 17y agoThanks for the article. I'll read it in a moment. It's obvious to me a lot of the disparity can be attributed to culture. What is unclear is how much. What I am trying to ask is what happens if we remove all barriers that prevent, say, men from becoming psychologists (important disclaimer: the guy sitting to my right is a psychologist and a very good programmer) and girls from becoming physicists, and they still are not much interested, what will we do and how will we recognize we have done enough? How much disparity is right?
- ErrantX 17y ago> Wow. It's amazing, she looks just like every women engineer I've ever worked with What in particular is atypical? Is it the designer clothes and glamour?