3 ms·
> Isn't the problem here that she donated all her photos to the Library of Congress without clarifying what that meant? No, because > why the hell is Getty ch
by pavel_lishin 10y ago
> Isn't the problem here that she donated all her photos to the Library of Congress without clarifying what that meant?
No, because
> why the hell is Getty charging for public domain photos?
There is no amount of clarification there that allows Getty to charge for something. Either it's in the public domain, in which case they have no right to charge for use of the photos, or it's not, in which case they have no right to charge for the photos.
I'd wager that this is some sort of colossal business fuck-up that's not anyone's fault. Mostly because I can't imagine anyone so baldly stealing money.
- donatj 10y agoPeople charge for public domain things all the time. I've bought plenty of books from the 17 and 18 hundreds on my kindle. Pay for the convenience and for them putting together a nice version.
- kuschku 10y agoBut the publishers of those nicer versions don't go around and threaten anyone who got them for free with lawyers. Getty actively threatened anyone using the public domain images.
- onli 10y agoActually, the copyright those nicer versions sometimes claim already lead to this exact situation, with publishers making the case that the derivative work should be awarded new copyright. Here however it is clear-cut, the photos are not modified.
- anc84 10y agoOh but surely the images were optimised for computer display in a non-trivial process!
- chillydawg 10y agoThat's actually not totally unreasonable. Also maybe getty ran some clever image recognition to auto tag them up and organise them all? That's all a useful charge-able service. Going after existing usage is clearly BS, though.
- artursapek 10y agoShe just had her photo up on her website. They clearly went after her without any reason to believe she used their "clever organization" image searching service. These scumbags were probably using an image recognition bot to scrape the web for all usage and spraying everyone with legal letters.
- anarres 10y agoCertainly, not probably. Getty purchased picscout in the past few years, a company making and using such bot, and sending automated demand letter.
- sleepychu 10y agoWhat you're buying there is a copy. That's not the same thing as someone coming after you and saying that you need to pay them for the copy you have acquired.
- gvb 10y agoBooks in the 1700s and 1800s are no longer under copyright, they are now in the public domain. Anybody can sell them for whatever the market will bear. Since they are not longer under copyright, there is no longer a copyright holder whose rights they are infringing and thus nobody that can charge them for violating copyright law. The question with Highsmith is whether she still holds the copyright or whether she put the pictures in the public domain. Answering this could be very interesting. The other angle that I would expect to see come up is whether Getty can sue (or threaten to sue) over pictures that they clearly do not hold the copyright to. That seems to be a clear violation of racketeering laws. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Racketeering https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Racketeering Ref: * http://www.copyright.gov/help/faq/faq-duration.html#duration http://www.copyright.gov/help/faq/faq-duration.html#duration * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_domain https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_domain "Works in the public domain are those whose exclusive intellectual property rights have expired, have been forfeited, or are inapplicable."
- forrestthewoods 10y agoAnyone is perfectly free to charge for content that is in the public domain. Getty still provides a service. For example the ability to search, preview, or download images. Bandwidth does still have a cost. Of course it's also fine for someone to use Getty to locate a public domain image, and then acquire it for free from another source. Getty sending copyright notices on works they know (or should know) to be in the public domain is a real problem. Ulysses is in the public domain. You can buy it for $2. https://www.amazon.com/Ulysses-Wordsworth-Classics-James-Joyce/dp/1840226358 https://www.amazon.com/Ulysses-Wordsworth-Classics-James-Joy...
- dublinben 10y agoThat $2 pays for the physical paper copy of the book. You aren't buying a license though, because they can't legally sell you one. It's pretty clear here that Getty was selling something (licenses) they had no right to sell. Trying to enforce these fraudulent "licenses" was just the icing on the cake.
- colomon 10y agoThe Kindle edition is 99 cents.
- wvenable 10y agoThis misses the point. If you have the public domain ebook already, Amazon isn't knocking on your door asking for their cut. Getty literally told the photographer she had to pay a license for her own work posted on her website. She didn't acquire it from Getty. You can acquire a public domain ebook from somewhere else for free or you can pay 99c to acquire it from Amazon. But either way, you're not paying for a license to copy it.
- 6stringmerc 10y agoThat's the rub in this case it seems, that if Getty never took this action against the creator herself, who understood the situation and, I'm not sure they'd run into much stink about selling Public Domain images as a business component (they provide a service). Her catching them in the act is stunning.
- LoSboccacc 10y agoit's perfectly fine charging public domain stuff(in the same way you can charge for distributing gpl'd stuff form third parties), call it a 'download fee' if that makes you uneasy