3 ms·
Very sad article, not even so much that this material is in the supply chain (official India mica production is just a fraction of total exports) but the indivi
by zaroth 10y ago
Very sad article, not even so much that this material is in the supply chain (official India mica production is just a fraction of total exports) but the individual stories of the families caught in bondage to do this mining work for $1/day paying off a "loan" at 200% interest.
Now if only the fine for allowing this material to reach your end product was treated as serious of a negative externality, as say, putting out a bit more sulphur in the exhaust than the latest EPA standard.
I mean, sorry, but what a horrid fucking double standard?! Cheaters causing pollution in my backyard that statistically will result in perhaps 100 deaths, fine the bastards $50 billion and shut the company down. Modern day slavery and child labor producing 75% of India's mica output into our car paint and cosmetics causing untold suffering of thousands? Oh, but the standard contract language says they shouldn't do that, so companies wash their hands of it.
If an equivalent agency to the EPA cared about this negative externality as relatively as much as the EPA cares about emissions, this would be a $1T fine which would completely shutter the companies profiting from the illegally mined mica.
- mikeash 10y agoIt seems reasonably consistent to me. This stuff stops at the borders. If they were employing slave labor in the US, they'd get hit hard. Likewise, when companies produce horrible pollution in foreign countries, we don't really care. I'm not saying this is necessarily a good way to do things, but I don't think it's quite a double standard.
- zaroth 10y agoWe fine companies millions of dollars for illegally dumping waste in international waters. EPA raided a company and jailed the executives for purporting to recycle but actually shipping the waste overseas. So it doesn't have to stop at the borders. US law can and does punish companies for damage even outside the US. I would have hoped for something like child slave labor, companies would be looking at potentially facing a full embargo on their goods. When you put the fear of God into a company for something like that, they will make damn sure their supply chain is clean. I see it as the best way to stomp out these horrific abuses.
- zaroth 10y agoSo what I want to know is, does such an agency / regulatory framework exist in the US to fine companies for child labor in their supply chain? If so, how do we lobby it to enforce such a fine? If not, who are the key senators / representatives who we could lobby to form a coalition to try to create such a regulatory framework? I assume that WTO must have a process to combat this. But also, just because it's not "polluting" our backyard doesn't mean US can't fine these companies dearly for using this illegal product in their supply chain. I can only hope that our WTO agreements don't actually shackle us from instituting not only massive tarrifs but also fines in these cases.
- SixSigma 10y agoWould that not result in a World Environmental Law ? There is quite a difference already even between the EU and US permitted chemicals.
- zaroth 10y agoI consider it something akin to trading in blood diamonds / conflict diamonds. I'll have to research the legal framework by which conflict diamonds were outlawed. I wonder if the same could be done for slave-mined mica? From a brief search, it looks like the most obvious convention against child labor and debt bondage which would apply in this case is C182 [1] to which 180 of 187 member countries have signed. Notably, India is the only large country which has not. [1] - https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Worst_Forms_of_Child_Labour_Convention https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Worst_Forms_of_Child_Labour_...
- SixSigma 10y agoThere are plenty of frameworks for supply chains e.g. ISO 26000 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ISO_26000 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ISO_26000 SA 8000 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SA8000 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SA8000 Shareholders should start applying pressure IKEA, for instance, got burned by prison labour and have been strong on CSR ever since. [1] They use the iWay framework [2] and other supplier certification [3] [1] http://www.independent.co.uk/news/business/news/ikea-used-forced-prison-labour-to-make-furniture-8324016.html http://www.independent.co.uk/news/business/news/ikea-used-fo... [2 pdf] http://www.ikea.com/ms/en_GB/pdf/reports-downloads/ikea-code-of-conduct-the-iway-standard.pdf http://www.ikea.com/ms/en_GB/pdf/reports-downloads/ikea-code... [3 pdf] http://supplierportal.ikea.com/doingbusinesswithIKEA/quality/Documents/ISQS%20Go%20No%20Go%20Material%20QIG.pdf http://supplierportal.ikea.com/doingbusinesswithIKEA/quality...