2 ms·
I disagree - Yeah the latest iPhone app adds zero quality of life, but look at technology over decades - start with penicillin 70 years ago, or heart pacemaker
by lifeisstillgood 10y ago
I disagree - Yeah the latest iPhone app adds zero quality of life, but look at technology over decades - start with penicillin 70 years ago, or heart pacemakers, or simple mobile communications (that changed life enormously - and has huge role in expanding business and relieving poverty not just making it possible for rich westerners to arrange evenings out)
Yeah there are a million ways we as humankind can stuff this up, but technology has and does make life qualitatively and quantatively better for millions. It has been doing this at a accelerating rate for two centuries.
- duaneb 10y ago"look at" isn't an argument—I would willingly trade a lower life expectancy for a higher quality of life. Epicurean argued—very successfully, I might add—that a longer life is not a better life. Rather, it is only in addressing our fears for the future it provides any benefit at all, and it's not clear the industrial overhead of pacemakers are worth the reduced anxiety of sudden death, especially when the quality of life has already greatly diminished due to age.
- tim333 10y agoOn pretty most quantifiable measures quality of life is better. I guess you can say in the old days there was terrible infant mortality, slavery, starvation and so on but I would have prefered that but I think most would not.
- duaneb 10y agoSure, there was also the possibility of much more enjoyable lifestyles than urbanization can offer. The idea that a 40 hour work week is desirable to anyone is absurdity.
- ci5er 10y agoA 40 hour work-week is quite leisurely compared to the sun-up to sun-down 7-days/week of most rural folks I knew growing up. I couldn't wait to grow up and escape to the city where they had these things called weekends.
- duaneb 10y agoI grew up in the country, too. The only place I've ever encountered full working during daylight every day is on a farm—another technology that is unnatural. Truly, humans cannot comprehend freedom from society. However, our flight-or-fight responses give us some insight, and I'd put money on our stress rates being higher now than ever before. Regardless of whether there are threats, we perceive them everywhere.
- Teever 10y agoIf you genuinely felt this way what is stopping you from leaving society and living off the land?
- duaneb 10y agoWell, a lot stops me. Social life, love of culture, a lack of skills, and a taste for modern cooking. But I'm not advocating that; I'm advocating a look at progress based around sustainable, high quality of life. This involves actually making arguments for high quality of life, which is a very rare practice beyond mentioning technology. I think there's a lot to be said for non-materialist culture, if you can find a good way to encourage that, and families planned as well as we are able to.
- Teever 10y agoSo in other words the high quality of life which you have due to living in society is what stops you from leaving society for the higher quality of life outside of -- er wait, what?
- duaneb 10y agoI wouldn't call it a high quality of life, just a life I understand how to appreciate. That doesn't mean we should blindly push forward.
- 10y ago
- lifeisstillgood 10y agoPre-industrialisation I fear you would have not had the leisure time to read Epicurean, and even if you had, you would not have been able to afford the book and frankly even if you got a copy no-one would have bothered to teach you to read. The vast wealth generated by harnessing steam, oil and electricity has meant universal education is possible - I doubt that 95% of HN or Silicon Valley would be literate without it. I just cannot see your argument as anything but a retread of "only those with money, think money is not important"