5 ms·
None of the contemporary things you mention are examples of unchecked power. The fact that you can mention them in public without fear of being whisked away ton
by smacktoward 10y ago
None of the contemporary things you mention are examples of unchecked power. The fact that you can mention them in public without fear of being whisked away tonight by secret police illustrates this. Unchecked power does not permit criticism, or admit room for opposition.
- frabbit 10y agoI think the rules are that you're allowed to criticize things as long as it makes no actual difference.
- PavlovsCat 10y ago> None of the contemporary things you mention are examples of unchecked power. That's easy to say, it's proven by putting a whole lot of war criminals at least on trial. By actually having done that. > The fact that you can mention them in public without fear of being whisked away tonight by secret police illustrates this. How so? This just illustrates that you can say this because nobody cares all that much, because it will not do anything. It doesn't put power in check, it's just someone saying something on HN. Power remains unchecked, and the hundreds of thousands or even millions of people who got murdered and the families they left behind continue to get no justice.
- coldtea 10y agoThat's just because today mentioning them in public doesn't have much (if any) effect. Back in the day when there were powerful alternative fractions for the power (e.g. socialists, communists in Europe etc), mentioning such staff in public against the established powers brought support to them, and advanced their cause. Now people know all about them and still elect e.g. Bush Jr. a second term, Obama 2 terms, now Trump etc. It's not like there's any credible threat to anything. And when there's not, freedom of speech is free, because it's almost worthless. TL;DR; Modern-day unchecked power can permit criticism just fine: when the waters due to media pollution are so muddle that the signal is lost in the noise, and/or when few people care about it anyway.
- woodandsteel 10y agoI take it you believe that socialism and communism are better than liberalism.
- tunap 10y agoThat isn't remotely what the OP said. edit: - unnecessary 2nd sentence
- woodandsteel 10y agoBut coldtea confirmed I was right that he is a socialist. The reason I was able to correctly infer he is a socialist is he was following a familiar socialist-marxist position. This is that democracy in capitalist countries is a shame, everything that happens is decided in secret by the rich people, who control the media to trick the population to go along. According to this view, true freedom of speech and democracy are possible only under socialism.
- mannykannot 10y agoAttaching a label to someone is the most significant act in analysis.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- woodandsteel 10y agoLet me add that you seem to be taking the standard marxist position that fascism is capitalism taken to its logical conclusion, so every non-socialist country is fascist or on its way there.
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoLet me agree with tunap and say that that isn't remotely what coldtea said either.
- tunap 10y agoIf that criticism manifests itself into a real threat perhaps we would see if power is unchecked. Recall Saddam Hussein, our best buddy in the Middle East until he decided to go rogue... and tried to off Papa Bush. An illegal war got rid of him. PS: No WMDs? Yeah, well, that's what the News said. However, Rummsfeld has the receipts.
- eeZah7Ux 10y ago> The fact that you can mention them in public without fear of being whisked away tonight by secret police illustrates this. This is plain wrong historically. The nazists, fascists and the stasi all used more manipulative and less blatant methods than dragging away every dissenter.