5 ms·
To me there is an unquestioned premise to the article: why should the state [as in "government"] conduct elections on behalf of political parties. Enrolling vot
by brudgers 10y ago
To me there is an unquestioned premise to the article: why should the state [as in "government"] conduct elections on behalf of political parties. Enrolling voters as Democrat or Republican or whatever and then restricting the voter's access to ballot items based upon that enrollment [or non-enrollment] does not seem to be the business of the government.
A political party is free to change the rules for nominating candidates however and whenever it chooses. It is free to nullify the decision of those voting in a particular primary. A political party is free to nominate whomever it chooses [and almost certainly multiple candidates for the same office it wishes should it choose].
Ultimately the party, not a judge, chooses whose vote matters and whose doesn't. Placing the imprimatur of the state upon a political party's process doesn't change that or make the process of candidate nomination little 'd' democratic. The people within a political party charged with making the rules for candidate selection are not elected or selected little 'd' democratically. The process of nominating candidates is not little 'd' democratic in any meaningful sense.
- maxerickson 10y agoA political party is free to change the rules for nominating candidates however and whenever it chooses. This is something we should take away from them. The outcomes of private party activities shouldn't have any impact on the names that appear on ballots. They can maybe mark the names they choose to endorse as an organization, but we should throw away the system where the parties are directly involved in putting names on the ballot (of course they'd be indirectly involved, as an organized group is, uh, organized and thus more ready to act together, so would have an easy time dealing with ballot petitions).
- white-flame 10y agoThere are many barriers to entry to get a name on the ballot, and political parties will rally together to help jump through those hoops to get specific names on. If there were lower barriers to entry, the ballots would be flooded. I think the barriers to entry should likely remain high, but we need an overhaul of the voting system itself to break the two-party system, which itself is just a side-effect of the mechanics of our voting process, not anything mandated. If I remember correctly, early on in the country's history the founders noticed that the mechanics of voting were trending towards a limited two-party system, and that consternated them. Most every (if not actually every) democracy established after the USA has a voting style and representative bodies that allows more parties to coexist, or creative destruction within the set of active parties to thrive.
- maxerickson 10y agoWhy is having lots of names on the ballot a bad thing? I'd rather have some system of arbitrarily limiting the number of names on the ballot than a system that privileges parties. For instance, for statewide elections you could choose the 5 (or 10!) names that had satisfied the ballot requirements in the most voting districts (so it doesn't matter that Uncle Larry likes to "run" for state senate in his home county, he doesn't kick someone with a better/actual shot at winning off).
- madgar 10y agoThere are 1,862 candidates for President right now [0]. The 5 or 10 candidates you will see on the ballot in your statewide election for President are those that have satisfied the ballot requirements in the state. It turns out that satisfying the ballot requirements is already a challenge requiring organization, and that organization is called a political party. [0] http://www.fec.gov/data/CandidateSummary.do http://www.fec.gov/data/CandidateSummary.do
- maxerickson 10y agoYes, but in many jurisdictions the rules are simpler for the parties than for some rando. That's my objection. The rando shouldn't have a higher bar than the established organization, they should have the same bar. Partly for the reason you highlight, backing of a party already makes it significantly more likely that someone will succeed in getting on many ballots.
- jessedhillon 10y agoWhat problem is lowering the barrier to entry for the balloting process solving? If someone has broad and genuine support, they will be able to either apply their own resources or raise funds to completing the paperwork necessary to get on the ballot. Party-supported or not, registration is a relatively small investment of time, compared to what it will take to mount a successful campaign. The public has a vested interest in having a ballot present only those candidates who can demonstrate a minimum-level of popular support. Otherwise why have a qualification process at all -- we can give voters phonebooks to take with them into the booth, and they can find the name of whichever citizen they feel should be elected.
- russell_h 10y agoWhat you are describing is already more-or-less the system we have. You don't need to be nominated by any political party to run for office or have your name printed on a ballot.
- maxerickson 10y agoThe rules for parties are often easier. My argument is that they shouldn't be. I also don't like that a party could literally pick a name out of hat to designate their presidential candidate. Of course it would be terrible for a party itself to do that, but the system is setup so that name would end up on an awful lot of ballots.
- jdavis703 10y agoWhich is why in California certain races are top-two win. For example in the "primaries" two democrats were the top-two vote getters, so the general election ballot will only have democrats on it.
- nitrogen 10y agoWhy does it seem that we in America can only count to two during election season? Or, less facetiously, what keeps us fixated on the polarizing, binary approach to elections, even in cases where first-past-the-post isn't strictly followed (as in California's first-two-past-the-post case)? Whenever people talk about alternative voting systems, the consensus seems to be that it would be impossible to implement in the US. But why? What drives this obsession with choosing between two evils rather than choosing among several, where one's own views might stand a better chance?
- logfromblammo 10y agoThe state I'm in can only count to one for some offices. I spend a lot of time writing people in for the uncontested races. But with regard to your question, the obvious explanation is that the voting method itself acts as a game theory attractor for a certain number of "viable" candidates, until a Nash equilibrium is reached. First-past-the-post thus eventually results in an entrenched two-party system. This alone is ample reason for those two parties to resist any change to the voting method. Anything else might undermine their duopoly.
- tgb 10y agoJust FYI, but your local vote counters hate you. I've done it before and write ins are a pain. If you know people who want to hold office, why are you writing then in instead of getting them on the ballot?
- nitrogen 10y agoI think the implication is that getting them on the ballot might not be possible due to the local ballot requirements. The hope might be that the pain suffered by vote counters like yourself sends a clearer message to the local establishment than an abstention.
- matt4077 10y agoConsidering the structural barriers preventing third parties from ever gaining a foothold, it's probably a good idea to legislate a basic standard of democracy for what happens inside the parties – kinda like antitrust rules.
- DamienSF 10y agoPolitical parties are free to make their own rules to the extent that they comply with election law and the National Voters Right Act. The report points out many instances in which election officials broke the law. Now a party may still decide to run its internal elections like a banana republic but in that case, this party should certainly not be named the Democratic party...