7 ms·
The article says that Milo didn't deserve what he got, and I agree. You may not agree with his politics but people of all stripes have done worse. I guess we'l
by gadders 10y ago
The article says that Milo didn't deserve what he got, and I agree. You may not agree with his politics but people of all stripes have done worse.
I guess we'll end up with a conservative twitter clone, and a liberal twitter, and no-one will ever face the "danger" of seeing viewpoints they disagree with.
- snaky 10y agoConservatives are ok with freedom of speech, 'safe zones' are invented by progressives.
- ivraatiems 10y agoDefinitely not true of current neocons. They use freedom of speech as a cover for "let me say whatever I want to say" while ignoring it when it suits them. As a live-right-now example, the mods of /r/The_Donald on Reddit are preemtively banning users before Trump's AMA to prevent dissent, and have stated plainly they will delete any unflattering questions.
- MustardTiger 10y agoThat sub has never had anything to do with free speech. It is an incredibly restricted hubox/circlejerk, and is very clear about this. They don't use freedom of speech as a cover, they outright say they don't value it at all.
- michaelbuddy 10y agoyeah and that's a Trump specific forum and they have RULES on the side for what is banned. Contrast that with r/news where it's purported to be 'news' not some partisan subreddit. You will get banned for having an opinion mods don't like. Not only that but those same mods will simply ban you from other subreddits they are mods for. r/news and r/worldnews was hit with that the other day. You're example is false equivalency. And what you call a preemptive ban, you'll actually discover that they are quite used to being brigaded on that subreddit and they know who participates. And bans aren't necessarily permanent there.
- ivraatiems 10y agoNo, that's exactly my point. They have no desire to make a concession to free speech. They don't value free speech. Their ideology does not value free speech. My point is that modern neocons (who are really just neoprogressives progressing down a different line of reasoning) don't value free speech or reasonable discourse. Having rules that say "we don't value free speech or discourse" doesn't excuse them.
- snaky 10y agoThat's the difference between neoprogressives (Trump) and conservatives (Cruz).
- michaelbuddy 10y agoBeing banned from a particular subreddit with a particular set of rules by mods of that subreddit only on that subreddit is not banning from an entire platform (twitter) ALSO that sub in particular gets massively brigaded. BTW at Trump rallies, protesters didn't just get kicked out. MANY remained there, and he addressed certain ones with answers. Some were kicked out when it was clear they would not stop distracting those who were there to see TRUMP. Also, reddit allows you to subscribe, but twitter creates a stronger relationship between poster and followers. You'd be subscribed to a particular person but when they are banned, all their history is gone, you no longer see anything. It's like someone came into your house and took away one of your favorite TV channels, as well as anything you had recorded from that channel on your DVR. Who is this THEY you keep referring to anyway? You keep saying 'they' like readers are just supposed to know.
- jdpedrie 10y ago/r/The_Donald is like... the opposite of neocon.
- dragonwriter 10y agoRight-wing authoritarian populism of the kind Trump represents is pretty far from neoconservatism (both are right-of-center and, in the US, uneasily fall under the umbrella of the same major political party, but they are not the same, or even particularly all that similar.)
- Someone1234 10y agoThere's nothing inherently conservative or liberal about being offended and wanting an echochamber at times. Both want freedom of speech sometimes and both want to be able to block out dissenting voices at others. The trick is finding a balance. Too big of an echochamber can be unhealthy, too small of one and little discussion about core beliefs gets discussed (everything gets sidetracked by the dissenters). Young conservatives definitely seem to be outnumbered online, and I've seen them put up walls so they can discuss their beliefs without being constantly picked apart by people with alternative beliefs. So I think the divide on ideological lines is unrealistic. Just human nature (good and bad).
- drabiega 10y agoThe liberals are who take safe zones too far are the same type of people as the conservatives who view any disagreement with them as censorship.
- snaky 10y ago> conservatives who view any disagreement with them as censorship What are you talking about?
- munificent 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Horseshoe_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Horseshoe_theory
- exolymph 10y agoWhat other people choose do with their privately-owned platforms does not limit anyone's freedom of speech, as the law currently stands.
- MustardTiger 10y agoYou are confusing freedom of speech with "the right to freedom of speech". Me restricting your freedom of speech is still restricting your freedom of speech, it is just legal and does not violate the first amendment. The government restricting your freedom of speech is not legal, and violates the first amendment.
- abiox 10y agowhat is "freedom of speech" outside the context of law?
- snaky 10y agoFreedom is not about the law.
- abiox 10y agoconversely, it could be argued that freedom is only about the law.
- 10y ago
- adrianratnapala 10y agoIn the US, and in this particular decade it is true that the left is keenest on actual politicking to create censorship. But in terms of the human weakness of not wanting to hear arguments against your own POV, then the right is at least as bad. I think the difference behind the political fireworks is this: conservatives already revel in sub-communities like churches where they can protect themselves from unwanted speech. Progressives are starting to dominate open places like universities to the extent that they want the same privilege there.
- specialist 10y agoYup. Notorious progressives Bush and Cheney gave us "free speech zones": http://www.theamericanconservative.com/articles/free-speech-zone/ http://www.theamericanconservative.com/articles/free-speech-...
- snaky 10y agoBush and Cheney were much more progressives than conservatives.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> Bush and Cheney were much more progressives than conservatives. No, they weren't. They were authoritarian conservatives. (In the US, there's often a confusion between "conservative" and "libertarian", and if you confuse those and assume anything that isn't libertarian must be progressive, I can see how you'd make that mistake, but Bush/Cheney is about as far from progressive as you can get.)
- snaky 10y ago> Conservatives were dismayed as he proposed a traditional Keynesian stimulus which Democrats lauded. Above all, he made one of the most dramatic federal interventions in American history by his aid to the financial system > Conservatives and libertarians have criticized Bush for greatly increased domestic spending, creating a new entitlement program for prescription drugs, failing to veto a single bill, and expanding both the size and scope of government http://www.conservapedia.com/George_W._Bush http://www.conservapedia.com/George_W._Bush
- specialist 10y agoNow I'm curious. Who do you consider conservative, Conservative, or both?
- snaky 10y agohttps://www.conservativereview.com/scorecard https://www.conservativereview.com/scorecard
- st3v3r 10y ago"Conservatives are ok with freedom of speech" No, they're not. They're the ones saying that people shouldn't be allowed to protest many things like Chik-Fil-A's support of gay marriage bans, protesting police departments that act like black lives don't matter, etc.
- snaky 10y ago> They're the ones saying that people shouldn't be allowed to protest Citation needed.
- intended 10y agoWasn't the physical free speech zone created by the bush administration when they made protestors stay in designated zones