7 ms·
Marissa Mayer’s Payday
- hullo 10y agoThe level of attention that these stories about Mayer attract is kind of sad, and really not fair. The big jump in the "payday" that the article teases is the possibility that Mayer will sell already-granted stock. i.e. Not new comp at all. Yawn.
- mtgx 10y agoRelevant recent story: http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/highest-paid-ceos-worst-performing-companies-research-a7156486.html http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/highest-pai...
- overcast 10y agoI think I'm going to be sick. Compensation for executives should be directly tied to company performance. You want to be at the top, then you should take the risk.
- vorotato 10y agoCompany performance has improved since she got there, check out the stock.
- chki 10y agoIf you read the complete article, it is explained why that is the case and why Meyer presumably is not the one who should get the credit.
- an_account 10y agoYes, but the comment he was replying to said it should be _directly_ tied to company performance. Normally that means stock price, which the compensation was tied to.
- dominotw 10y agowhy are you littering every comment with the same comment response. Also, the stock has nothing to do with Mayer's performance.
- overcast 10y agoRight, because of Alibaba and Yahoo Japan. The company is down 2.4 billion without those two.
- FroshKiller 10y agoAnd the day is dark but for the sun. What a useless thing to say!
- overcast 10y agoThe point here, is that her compensation should be based on changes she made in her tenure. Not what two other companies are doing, where she happened to be conveniently in the CEO role at the time they did.
- MSM 10y agoMayer had absolutely nothing to do with Alibaba or Yahoo Japan though. What she is directly in control of has been hemorrhaging money.
- dangrossman 10y agoHer compensation was directly tied to company performance. 96% of her compensation was in ownership share in the company. That ownership share is worth $117M because the stock went from $15 to $39 per share while she was the CEO. If the company had tanked instead, her compensation would be less. Considering the outlook for Yahoo!'s core business was so bleak at the time she was hired, who's to say this wasn't one of the better outcomes for the board that hired her? Yahoo! returning to its glory days as a tech giant was pretty unlikely.
- overcast 10y agoThe stock prices are directly related to the awesome performance of Alibaba, and lesser Yahoo Japan, both of which they own stakes. Both which were investments prior to Mayer starting. Reading the article, without those two calculated in, the company is actually down $2.4 billion. Paying her salary for two years AFTER she leaves, including her health insurance, AND office space for her to find a new job. Is completely ludicrous.
- dangrossman 10y agoWhy is it ludicrous? Would someone have managed to better preserve the value of those investments than her? Would someone capable of doing that have been willing to take on the job for lesser compensation? Yes, the company is down $2.4 billion because the core Yahoo! business was spending $400MM/quarter more than it was taking in -- on the backs of those investments. After 4 years of trying to turn that around, they sold off that money pit for $5B cash, which is more than that $2.4 billion the company is down. Sounds like a pretty good outcome for YHOO's board and owners. Dealing with that board and owners, attempting to maximize the shareholder return on those investments you mentioned, was as large a part of her job as trying to maximize the return from the bleeding tech business. She spent much of late 2014 and early 2015 trying to spin off the investments into a separate company to minimize tax liability, ensuring Yahoo!'s shareholders get as much value as possible if Yahoo! eventually sells some of those shares for cash. You can't write off her stewardship of the value of the BABA and YJP holdings, and their contribution to YHOO, just because they were initially purchased before she took the job.
- walshemj 10y agoWould you take a job at a company in trouble and not want some compensation for the risk? I was asked to look at a role at Hibu (ex Yell) in the Uk and I told the recruiter id want a serious premium and some very good share options to even consider it.
- FroshKiller 10y agoIf an executive has a solid plan for long-term benefit that will require three or four excruciatingly bad years to achieve, should the executive be compensated poorly in the lean years for sticking with the company to achieve the long-term goal? Because you're talking about a recipe for optimizing short-term gains at the expense of the company's prospects, and I doubt the work force of most companies would be very happy to have their futures handled that way.
- overcast 10y agoWhat exactly are you considering being compensated "poorly". ONLY a million instead of tens of millions? If an exec is confident enough to think they can turn a business around in four years, then they shouldn't get the massive payouts until they do so. She hasn't done so. Why do execs still get huge bonus/stock allocations for an under performing company? http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/highest-paid-ceos-worst-performing-companies-research-a7156486.html http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/highest-pai...
- CodeSheikh 10y agoThis is unacceptable. She sold off a big chunk of Yahoo (that she could not resurrect) to Verizon where most of the staff is eventually going to get axed and she walks off with $122 Million. There has to be checks and balances somewhere. Tech industry is turning into dirty Wall Street.
- vorotato 10y agoHave you seen the stock? Wallstreet should be grateful.
- ucaetano 10y agoWell, if you're a Yahoo shareholder, you could have voted against the deal. If you're not, it's not your money, so why would you accept it or not?
- maxerickson 10y agoI wonder how strong the connection is between lightly managed retirement funds and poor corporate governance. Pretty much anybody with retirement savings is a likely partial owner of Yahoo (via some broad market index fund), but those funds tend to be managed in a way that they do what the relatively insular boards recommend. So there is a legitimate question to be answered about poor corporate governance when you tell people that they need to invest their money in stocks to ensure their comfort in later life.
- 10y ago
- pcunite 10y agoHuman nature whether it be man or woman.
- matt_wulfeck 10y agoThen I looked, and I saw there was nothing new under the sun.
- notacoward 10y agoYep, the saddest thing about this whole thread is that yours is the only comment to even hint at what's unique about this particular golden parachute. CEOs have been reaping outsize rewards for failure since forever. Some have destroyed bigger companies than Yahoo, and reaped bigger rewards than Mayer. Yes, even some in tech. Even in search. Before Yahoo there was Excite. There's plenty of reason to be outraged, but put a slight pink edge on that golden parachute and suddenly the sleepers awake.
- rdtsc 10y agoSo she does know how to negotiate, it just has to be for her personal gain. > Yahoo is also paying to help Mayer land a new job. During her period of transition, Mayer will presumably need office space, and someone needs to pay for it. The company will put up $15,000 for 24 months of outplacement services for Mayer. > Mayer is entitled to receive her base salary, which in 2015 was $1 million, for two years after she leaves the company. Clearly she set the same "you get your salary for 2 years after leaving" + office space package up for all the developers in the company...
- vorotato 10y agoWhen you get hired to save a dying company, you shouldn't be slammed for the stock doubling.
- Redoubts 10y ago> Despite generating roughly $5 billion in annual revenue and drawing 1 billion monthly users, Yahoo's core internet business is valued at less than zero by the public market. > Instead, most of its value is ascribed to its ownership stakes in Alibaba and Yahoo Japan, which together outstrip the value of Yahoo's $35 billion market cap. http://www.businessinsider.com/yahoo-value-almost-entirely-tied-to-alibaba-stake-2016-5 http://www.businessinsider.com/yahoo-value-almost-entirely-t...
- subway 10y agoWhen you fuck over your employees to do so, yes, yes you should be slammed.
- peeters 10y agoThe reactions in this thread are bizarre to me. Is it a new revelation that CEOs are compensated to deliver the best return for shareholders, and not the employees? Why is Mayer being singled out when this is what pretty much every CEO in the history of capitalism has been hired to do?
- atonse 10y agoI have to say my favorite part is how they have to pay her health insurance premiums ($2k/month) for 2 years. I need to up my negotiation game. :) Plus, 2k a month? I can't even imagine what amazing Super Platinum plan she must have.
- ido 10y agoIs $2k that excessive? I pay the equivalent of about $800/m for 'normal' health insurance in Germany. Surely you can get much higher than $2k/m in silicon valley.
- kayoone 10y ago$800 sounds like a lot, state or private insurance? I earn a decent salary for germany and my health insurance pay is about half that.
- mgkimsal 10y agoa mid-range plan for a family of 5 here in NC can easily be $1500/month - assuming CA is higher, and she's got a family plan, I can't imagine it's "super platinum" but average. somewhat OT, but ... is there any value in billionaire's having 'health insurance'? When you are worth more than some smaller insurance companies... what value is there in buying insurance? Aren't you already self-insured? There may be procedures that the insurance company wouldn't fund anyway, but you can just pay for it yourself? EDIT: Just looked up family of 3 - higher end "blue cross" in CA may be $1200/month. Other companies are cheaper (wow, must be nice to have so many options! in NC, I have 2 options, and only 1 the year before, that's it). Throw in a dental plan, and that might bring you to ~$1300/month. Add in expected increases over the next 2 years and.. $2k/month is probably still on the high side, but perhaps not by too much? http://www.coveredca.com/news/PDFs/CoveredCA-2017-rate-booklet.pdf http://www.coveredca.com/news/PDFs/CoveredCA-2017-rate-bookl... shows that there's an expected 13% average increase in 2017.
- bjterry 10y agoBecause of the way insurance prices are structured post-ACA, if you are old you are getting a big underwriting subsidy. If you are a typical billionaire, it is cheaper to purchase insurance than it is to self-insure, because part of your costs are being borne by younger premium holders. If you are a billionaire in your 20s you should probably self-insure for the same reason. Under the ACA the maximum ratio between insurance rates for old and young is 3:1, but the Society of Actuaries estimates that healthcare costs for the elderly are roughly 4.8 times as expensive[1]. 1: Referenced here on page 22: https://www.cbo.gov/sites/default/files/114th-congress-2015-2016/reports/51130-Health_Insurance_Premiums.pdf https://www.cbo.gov/sites/default/files/114th-congress-2015-...
- GreaterFool 10y agoSigh. There was a story just yesterday or maybe slightly older in WSJ about "short list of well paying jobs" and the only thing I remember was that every second word was "manager".
- just_observing 10y agoI wonder which lucky company will hook her up now....
- draw_down 10y agoRight, CEOs in corporate America make stupid amounts of money. That's how it is. I would question the motives of anyone describing this as unusual or especially egregious. Are you upset about how business is structured now, or do you have a specific vendetta against Mayer?
- grandalf 10y agoThis is not something to be upset about. Shareholders want near zero executive risk, and so they are willing to pay top dollar for proven executives... That way, if things do fail, they can be confident that scrimping to save a few million in comp wasn't the reason they lost billions. We overpay for quality in many areas of the economy. Neurosurgeons are one example. Roughly 0.5 people from each of the the graduating classes of the top 10 medical schools becomes a neurosurgeon. Supply is very, very small because the bar is so so high. Why? Because when someone is doing surgery on our brains we are completely fine with having a 10x overqualified doc doing the surgery. This is similar to how the price of achieving each additional "9" of reliability is exponentially greater than the last one. Yet systems with 99.99999% reliability still fail, some neurological procedures fail, and some highly paid CEOs do not lead their companies to glory. Yahoo's shareholders decided to hire Marissa instead of many other, cheaper options. Nobody was duped, fooled, or scammed. Kobe misses the winning three pointer to lose a game now and then. Mayer is the closest thing the valley had to a sure bet for a company in need of product execution, so it's hard to fault Yahoo for wanting to recruit her. It's too bad it didn't turn out, but let's hope she does something risky with all the money :)
- gvb 10y agoThere are two ways to look at Mayer's payday: 1. She is getting rewarded even though her performance as CEO of Yahoo! was way less than expectations. Expectations being the salvation of Yahoo! as an independent company. 2. She is being rewarded for selling Yahoo! People are focusing on #1, but that is really past performance and past stock grants. She has plenty of previously granted stock based on previous performance, but she did not achieve everything she could have: This past year, Mayer had to forfeit just over 400,000 of those performance shares. Once the "for sale" sign went up, her incentive became "sell Yahoo!", not "save Yahoo!" because that is what her incentive (severance package) aligned with the moment the "for sale" sign went up. I expect that the Board understood this very well when they created her severance package.
- rabboRubble 10y agoGood for her. The only thing wrong is that I haven't managed to secure that sort of package for myself!