4 ms·
Well, I have a collision warning system in my Mercedes, and recently I drove through a narrow road which had loads of grass just hanging onto the road - the col
by gambiting 10y ago
Well, I have a collision warning system in my Mercedes, and recently I drove through a narrow road which had loads of grass just hanging onto the road - the collision warning system was going nuts, beeping constantly, and had I not been applying throttle myself it would have braked the car on its own. I definitely remember reading that Teslas generally disregard anything at roof level to avoid tree branches interfering with the autopilot in the similar way the grass was interfering with my Mercedes - I can only imagine Tesla engineers asking themselves "how often, exactly, are you going to have a stationary metal object at exactly roof height, on a highway? If it's at that height on a public road, it can't be a solid/permanent object" - turns out, it can be, as rare as it is.
- happyslobro 10y agoClearly, any kind of always-on automation that is responsible for braking, must be able to gauge the strength and importance of obstacles. For example, driving through that grass slowly and carefully, is ok. If there is a wire hanging across a road, then that is definitely something to stop for. I'm thinking that a very good visual AI would be necessary to make distinctions like this; radar won't even see a wire, I don't think, and to lidar, it would look a lot like the grass. A touch-sensitive coating on the car would probably be a good idea too, so that the car can tell when if it is starting to scratch its paint on what it thought was an insignificant obstacle, like a branch. Simply not looking at obstacles in one area because of the difficulty of rejecting false positives is a terrible idea, and demonstrates that that AI is not ready to drive.