3 ms·
I haven't been following this case particularly closely, but looking at the pictures it seems like a dangerous place to rely on autopilot with the intersections
by slg 10y ago
I haven't been following this case particularly closely, but looking at the pictures it seems like a dangerous place to rely on autopilot with the intersections. Whether Tesla's system can or will be improved from this accident doesn't appear clear at this point. But it does seem hard to argue that fault rests with Tesla considering autopilot was being used in a manor that goes against their instructions. It also makes me wonder if it Tesla might be better off with some sort of whitelisting system that prevents autopilot from being engaged on roads like this. That would certainly reduce the risk of accidents resulting from misuse, although I guess it might open them up to more blame in the event of a possible accident.
- enoch_r 10y ago> looking at the pictures it seems like a dangerous place to rely on autopilot with the intersections To some extent, I agree--uncontrolled intersections on highways are dangerous. On the other hand, in this particular case, a 14 foot tall, 75 foot long, 40-ton obstacle blocking the roadway is probably something any autopilot should be able to detect and attempt to avoid. This was not a case of the Tesla not being able to stop in time because someone pulled out in front of them. The Tesla did not slow down at all from its cruising speed of 74mph before impacting the trailer. It simply did not detect the obstacle.
- slg 10y agoThat obstacle was only on the road because it was an intersection. It is extremely unlikely that a truck would be in a similar position on a hypothetically Tesla approved autopilot road unless an accident occurred directly in front of you and Tesla likely has other ways of detecting such an accident. It is similar to if someone was using autopilot and drove through a red light and was t-boned. It isn't a good look for Tesla, but I can't fault them for not preventing the crash when the car was clearly being used under conditions they recommend against.
- kpil 10y agoApparently, the car is oblivious to trailers parked across the road, so it seems unlikely that there are "other ways."
- kpil 10y agoIt's clear to me that the auto steer technology is pretty far from an "auto pilot", but the drivers are not making the distinction. I think that semi-automatic systems like this are fundamentally broken due to unrealistic expectations in the man-machine interface. There is virtually no chance that the driver will be alert and able to detect and correct problems after hours of uneventful driving, including previous driving. Even if the auto assist feature signals that it is confused, there is probably very little the driver can do until it's too late. One example is the AF 443 crash where the auto pilot disengaged due to a significant but not immediately threatening mechanical problem, and the pilot (flying) got so distressed that instead of following the check lists (memory item even) he more or less just dropped out of the sky in a massive stall that took about 2 minutes. I digress but a speculation is that in that particular case, the pilot was not helped by the fact that the airplane changed the input mode (or "law") as the sensor data was not complete due to same problem - the pilot's input was nominally consistent with the normal flight law but was in reality inducing a fatal stall.
- grahamburger 10y agoI have also been surprised that streets/highways aren't being whitelisted, and I wouldn't be surprised if we start to see that as autonomous vehicles become more mainstream. I can imagine a system that does not allow autonomous driving on roads that have not been surveyed in, say, the last 24 hours by either another sensor equipped vehicle or perhaps a drone. When planning a route, the autonomous driver would either plan around a road that had not been surveyed within that time frame or plan a place to stop and ask the driver to take over well ahead of time.
- freehunter 10y agoIsn't it dangerous to rely on autopilot anyway? I don't drive a Tesla but I was under the impression that their instructions were "keep your hands on the wheel and feet ready to take manual control". It probably says something along the lines of "follow all applicable traffic laws" too, something which precludes doing 75 in a 65.