6 ms·
The other bubble that driverless cars are going to pop is ticket revenue. There are a lot of police departments and cities who have structured a lot of their b
by paulmd 10y ago
The other bubble that driverless cars are going to pop is ticket revenue. There are a lot of police departments and cities who have structured a lot of their budget on heavy-handed enforcement of motorists.
That's going to decline significantly once driverless cars are scrupulously following the rules of the road. And any tickets that get written will be going against a giant corporation like Google, with detailed information about what the car was doing at the time of the supposed infraction, a lot more financial ability to fight the ticket, and a lot more incentive to protect their reputation.
- zyxley 10y ago"The car was obeying the rules of the road too well. It was suspicious."
- toomuchtodo 10y ago"Your honor, witness testimony is notoriously inaccurate. Will you believe the officer? Or the cryptographically signed and verified vehicle logs?"
- dexwiz 10y agoTraffic laws are notoriously regional in the United States. The fines will adapt. There some potential infractions. Such as keeping your car in a minimum condition. Or having legacy system support. It needs to get patches to update to newer network types. Completely unattended driving (enter destination and taking a nap) is still up for debate. Requiring a machine to be watched seems like a pretty easy-to-pass regulation. Current traffic laws are written for human drivers. If there are robotic drivers on the road other traffic laws will be passed for those.
- JoshTriplett 10y ago> Completely unattended driving (enter destination and taking a nap) is still up for debate. Requiring a machine to be watched seems like a pretty easy-to-pass regulation. Requiring a human to watch implies a means for the human to intervene and take over. Having a human second-guess the machine will increase accidents. And having the controls available for the human to do so will increase complexity and decrease reliability.
- dexwiz 10y agoMany regulations are of questionable validity, but do you really want to be in a machine that you have no control over? Would robotic drivers be better at things like merging, keeping distance, not over correcting? Yes. But people will still want to intervene when it doing something dumb like driving into a pond, or gets stuck on a median and cannot figure out how to get off. Driverless cars will probably not be magic pods that whisk you around. It's still a vehicle that needs to navigate terrain. And roads are not perfect everywhere.
- JoshTriplett 10y ago> do you really want to be in a machine that you have no control over Yes. I regularly fly in planes, which I have no control over, and which spend most of their time on autopilot. I also regularly deal with machines that do their jobs far better than I could, and I feel no desire to take over and do those jobs worse. Why should that answer change when the stakes get higher and the cost of a mistake goes up? (That doesn't mean I want to beta-test an experimental driverless car; it does mean I'm eager for a non-experimental one.) > But people will still want to intervene when it doing something dumb like driving into a pond, or gets stuck on a median and cannot figure out how to get off. A vehicle that did any of those things would be considered broken in a deadly way. The solution isn't to hand people broken vehicles that they sometimes need to take over from; the solution is to not call a car driverless until it handles those situations (generally by not getting into such situations in the first place). > Driverless cars will probably not be magic pods that whisk you around. Yet.
- pyre 10y ago> Yes. I regularly fly in planes, which I have no control over, and which spend most of their time on autopilot. Those planes with their auto-pilot system still have a means for the pilots to intervene. That's not quite the same as being in a vehicle for which no human has the possibility of intervening. (It's also a bit disingenuous to imply that it is.)
- 10y ago
- paulmd 10y agoThis is purely opinion-based, but I think the problem is primarily local/city-level. That's where most of the current problem with ticket farming happens, and once driverless cars are commercially available I think it will be relatively unpalatable to ban them at a state level or higher.
- dexwiz 10y agoYou can pass traffic laws that target driverless cars without outright banning them. The cronies at a local/city-level that pass laws to turn traffic into a source of income have friends in state and federal. Or move to the state/federal level. Is the Federal government immune from passing similar laws?
- pyre 10y agoIf this sort of thing becomes common enough at the local-/start-level, I can see it becoming a legal battlefield for the companies that stand to benefit from driverless cars.
- ryandrake 10y agoWhat makes you think Google will fight my ticket on my behalf? Surely, it would benefit them to have traffic laws written to clarify that the occupant is still liable for any laws his self-driving car breaks. Also, as the other commenter said, the laws will adapt. The purpose of traffic laws is to maintain $X level of revenue, so if revenue starts to drop, local governments will increase the number and complexity of traffic laws until revenue is back to the expected level.
- seizethecheese 10y agoThe end state for driverless cars is most likely not individual ownership. Large companies will probably own fleets of cars available for hail. In this world, the fleet owners would probably develop a rigorous process to cost effectively fight traffic tickets. Even if local governments tried to increase the complexity of traffic laws, the fleet owners would increase spending on fighting tickets; this would result in an arms race which would be costly for the local government. It's much easier to extract rent from the little guys. The worry I have is of increased enforcement of local non-traffic laws to make up revenue.
- ryandrake 10y agoI'd expect it would be cheaper in the long run for those large companies to influence laws to move ticket liability over to their customers rather than take on the expense of fighting traffic tickets themselves.
- seizethecheese 10y agoPossibly, but that's assuming no aspect of consumer choice in the survival of ride hailing systems. If customers had to worry about tickets, they would quickly migrate to a competitor which assumed liability.
- pyre 10y agoThe same way that competition ensures things like Net Neutrality because consumers vote with their wallets?
- arikrak 10y agoThey'll also be able to automatically track cars speeding so maybe they'll just be the equivalent of a tax if you want to go faster.
- cmurf 10y agoPay per use becomes practical with the greater tracking granularity available. Driving on rainy days, hot days, cold days, heavier cars (trucks), all increase road wear. If we all paid the actual direct cost of driving, public transit and bikes would be a lot more popular in the U.S. (maybe everywhere).
- labster 10y agoLuckily the poors won't be able to afford to the new cars, so we can continue our campaign of oppression via infraction ticketing against them for quite some time.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- chjohasbrouck 10y agoThe cost of owning a car (maintenance, financing, registration, license, insurance, tickets, parking, cleaning) will totally eclipse the cost of Lyft/Ubering a self-driving car, even (especially?) for the poor. We're already to the point where if your commute is less than 8 miles or so, using Uber daily is cheaper than the cost of ownership on a $30k vehicle. Just imagine what self-driving cars will do to that equation.
- beachstartup 10y agoit's a good point, but just a reminder that for most people the price for comparison would be public transit, bicycle, or scooter, not a $30k car.
- chjohasbrouck 10y agoI guess that's true. I'm not saying an 8-mile commute and a $30k car is where the line is either, though. That was just my situation roughly, and Uber wasn't a little less expensive, it was a LOT less expensive. Like, roughly 60% less expensive than owning the car when you factor in things like tread wear, depreciation, and the value of your time. And that's with no lease, no loan, and minimal insurance. The true line right now (where car ownership becomes more expensive than Uber) based on my experience is probably closer to an 8-mile commute and a $15k car. That line gets much lower when you add in things like financing, overpriced insurance, and leasing, which do affect a majority of the population. I should actually do a writeup about this. I have access to all my numbers on it but I've only ever done rough estimates (which were clear enough that choosing Uber/Lyft was obvious). Now I'm curious to see exactly how the costs compared.
- mark-r 10y agoIt just means that the bulk of the revenue will come from people too poor to afford self-driving cars. Ratcheting up the injustice once again.
- whyenot 10y agoDriverless cars are excellent witnesses of the behavior of other drivers. Speed, initiate an illegal lane change, roll through a stop sign, etc, and it wouldn't be a technological stretch for a driverless car to send a report to the police on your behavior. Police could even pay the owners of driverless cars that report bad behavior a reward, if one of their reports results in a ticket.
- imglorp 10y agoAnd two more bubbles: long haul trucking and taxis. Getting rid of drivers is a high priority for that industry. Human drivers are expensive and they can only drive 70 hours a week. [1] Oh, and Uber is dying to get rid of all its drivers too. [2] 1. https://www.transportation.gov/briefing-room/new-hours-service-safety-regulations-reduce-truck-driver-fatigue-begin-today https://www.transportation.gov/briefing-room/new-hours-servi... 2. http://sanfrancisco.cbslocal.com/2015/01/27/how-ubers-autonomous-cars-will-destroy-10-million-jobs-and-reshape-the-economy-by-2025-lyft-google-zack-kanter/ http://sanfrancisco.cbslocal.com/2015/01/27/how-ubers-autono...
- city41 10y agoIn a sense, the damage Uber and Lyft have already done to Taxis was a boon for them. They get some extra heads up that their industry is probably going to become defunct.
- ValleyOfTheMtns 10y agoAND public transport, particularly buses, but I'm sure trams/trains will eventually be automated too.
- larvyde 10y agoA lot of trains already are...
- iaw 10y agoMaritime shipping...
- imglorp 10y agoYeah, good point, ships are pretty automated. But ships really do need crews for constant maintenance and supervision. You can put the helm on autopilot but that's about all it can do. Now, let's talk about this again when someone makes a decent R2 unit.
- dredmorbius 10y ago
- mc32 10y agoLocal authorities will have to recoup costs via registration fees or maybe usage tax (miles driven times some decimal times an income bracket). Unless GM, Ford, Tesla, Google are going to maintain roads and pay for policing --although FB and co. could assess who have more perp risk and assess taxes accordingly...