7 ms·
Survey Suggests a Public Wariness of Enhanced Humans
- dkarapetyan 10y agoSurvey suggests fear of anything new. Don't really need a survey for that. It's human nature. For most of human history new things were more likely to kill you than old things. I'd even go as far as saying it's an instinctive reaction.
- derekp7 10y agoThe thing that is weird about the survey answers, is that we've been using technology to enhance humans for quite a while. This includes vaccinations, eyeglasses, cochlear implants, pacemakers, crutches, nutrition, the list goes on. None of these things are too far removed from the suggestions in the survey such as boosting the immune system through gene editing, or neural implants (how is that much different than a cochlear implant?).
- morninj 10y ago> neural implants (how is that much different than a cochlear implant?). To me, sensory enhancements are different--less creepy--than cognitive enhancements.
- dkarapetyan 10y agoHow do you make a distinction? Sensory enhancement is cognitive enhancement.
- morninj 10y agoYeah, I know it's a blurry distinction, but I think there's a difference between hearing better and cogitating better. It's like the difference between upgrading the microphone versus upgrading the CPU.
- xlayn 10y agoSometime ago was posted here (I think) a pdf with the state of the art on psychology and one of the topics were the qualia and senses. They seemed to agree that they were interpreted as an electrical signal and didn't have anything to do with the organ itself, as when you see in your dreams. Based on that I disagree with you anything as being processed by the brain affected by tech outside our natural capabilities should qualify as sensory and not cognitive enhancement.... will search for the pdf... right now this just qualify as "expert logic fallacy" update: even when I'm extremely tempted to agree with you... edit2: pdf here http://open-mind.net/collection.pdf http://open-mind.net/collection.pdf
- dkarapetyan 10y agoMy point was it is impossible to separate the two in practice. Enhanced sensory input will affect cognition and enhanced cognition will affect sensory inputs. Depending on the kind of sensory enhancement it might lead to impaired cognition but I'm using the colloquial sense of enhancement to mean "making better". You can certainly "enhance" a signal with noise and make it worse.
- xlayn 10y agoEnhance sensory: You can use glasses to enhance your eyes but still take wrong decisions on the data they present to you. Regarding cognition I would say there are only hacks and are as messy as spaghetti over an open heart surgery; the thing is the brain is the result of the two opposing forces that are "more intelligence better tools" and "more intelligence more energy". Check https://www.gwern.net/Drug%20heuristics https://www.gwern.net/Drug%20heuristics incredible post.
- PhasmaFelis 10y agoOnly in the most pedantic sense. No one's afraid of someone with the equivalent of built-in glasses or hearing aids. What worries them is the prospect of someone with superhuman mental ability. The potential to create a permanent underclass is obvious.
- akvadrako 10y agoSo obvious it already exists
- pharrington 10y agoAs others in the thread have pointed out, the original superhuman cognitive augmentation was called literacy. Literacy indeed was restricted in an attempt to create a permanent underclass. Unfortunately I don't know enough history to have a satisfying understanding of how literacy became ubiquitous in most of the world, or how that interacted with the spread of wealth derived from automation, but intuitively it seems hard to maintain the restriction of augments, especially when the augments specifically increase general intelligence.
- PhasmaFelis 10y agoThere is a huge social and logistical difference between education and implanting computer chips in people's brains. We already have a semi-permanent underclass based on (among other things) poor access to decent education, something which is supposedly guaranteed by law in the US. Imagine how much worse that will get if we don't even pretend that augmentation is a universal right, but let the free market charge for it instead.
- internaut 10y agoEvery time you jot down a note on the back of an post-it note or use the back of an envelope as spare memory for calculations you're cognitively enhancing your short term memory. Suppose we developed a brain-thought-stream to digital record and back again machine. A computer chip with a neural lace covering the brain. Then when you wanted extremely accurate recall you could have it. Would this be acceptable to you instead of genetic enhancement which improved native memory?
- xlayn 10y agoAfter checking points to my post I saw yours above... funny thing my post it's almost carbon of yours... 20 min later (sorry I didn't read before posting)... The thing is... if you think alike checking your responses history I could grab an idea on how I "theoretically" behave under those scenarios..... interesting...
- jacquesm 10y agoThose are mostly things to offset damage rather than to enhance beyond the norm.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Retric 10y agoPost 50 reading glasses push people past the norm for their age. Coffee is a very common enhancement beyond the norm for any age. PS: Even more broadly tools are enhancement beyond the norm. IE: It's much easier to win a fight while holding a stick vs. bare handed.
- mikeash 10y agoDiseases and bad nutrition are the norm, historically speaking. We only see them as subnormal today because we have the luxury of using technology to overcome them.
- xori 10y agoMy issue with gene editing is the problems you could be creating at the end of the lifetime of the person. What happens when you've ensured no heart disease, but have guaranteed them alzheimers. Who is to blame? The now dead scientist who discovered the gene modification? The now dead parents who wanted it done to their child? Testing a large enough population would take generations.
- xlayn 10y agoNot taking an option because it's not perfect is called fallacy of perfection. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nirvana_fallacy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nirvana_fallacy
- bordercases 10y agoWould you on principle release unmaintainable code? If you do so because you're rushed, would you want the same situation to be applied to say, genetic engineering?
- xlayn 10y ago"Would you on principle release unmaintainable code? If you do so because you're rushed" The term for this is "technical debt", you deliver when it works but have a debt for fix until it's good enough. "would you want the same situation to be applied to say, genetic engineering?" World works on this premise, every drug for every ailment has a secondary effect.
- bordercases 10y agoBut these are inefficiencies that you don't explicitly want; instead you manage them. In some systems these inefficiencies cost lives and instead of managing them you decide to prove them out of existence, or avoid ruinous failure altogether. Truth be told now that you bring in the drug metaphor I'm torn, because I've been recently convinced that there are opportunity costs and institutional inefficiencies that come from being too risk averse on the drug market. So I would believe that tolerating some error, i.e. some casualty or someone's death, could on average be OK if more people were saved. This is a part of what we mean when we say we're OK with secondary effects in drugs. Usually the prescription ensures that the worst won't happen. There might be differences to tease out between this example and genetic engineering, however. If a drug fails, you kill off a couple of people and make recalls. But these deaths happen more-or-less independently. The same goes with some software systems that tolerate error: so what if your shitty exercise app goes dark? Or, so what if a single consumer doesn't get served? You lose some money but life goes on. No one dies or no one gets cancer. The reason why dealing with genetics is more scary, and this applies to manufacturing retroviruses, is that the error can spread or be transferred more effectively than in the case of drugs, whose sale is tightly controlled and whose information doesn't propagate. A virus spreads or a seed scatters or a person breeds and you end up exploring new unexpected territory. This isn't bad per se. But it's harder to control. If I were to deal with that kind of thing I would attempt to see what was invariant with scale and see if I could test on that case, so that if a spread did occur, the "patterning of the network" would be sound (like designing a component of a fractal).
- xlayn 10y agoScience has been enhancing humans for a very long time. Cellphones extend my ability to research before taking a decision. Current drugs has addressed a lot of human ailments; from pain to AIDS. Vaccines have took away a lot of deadly diseases. Last but not least we have a 35+ years life expectancy. Edit: As bogus as it is, also IQ has been increased.
- bordercases 10y agoSo IQ is not bogus when it proves your point, but is bogus when it doesn't. Got it. (Bite the IQ bullet or don't; going half way and then flip-flopping back and forth is intellectually dishonest.) Additionally: "enhancement" seems like a bit of a bucket word. There are only a surface similarities between cellphones and AIDS cures, in that they help people. I mean, vaguely speaking, you're pushing the bounds of what humans are able to do; recall information more effectively, live longer, maybe fight disease. But then you end up broadening the category to "all technologies serve as enhancements" and vice versa, which stops describing the specific information that causes some people to be uncomfortable when they hear "enhancement". I would want to know what connotations about the word enhancement produce a split between the religious vs non-religious, and the spiritual vs the non-spiritual (the two are independent but correlated dimensions, believe me.) In this article the argument has been framed around "meddling with nature" which itself is kind of limiting the discourse. There's probably more to it.
- sp332 10y agoIQ isn't as good a measure of "general intelligence" as it claims to be, but it still measures some aspect of cognitive ability.
- Retra 10y agoThat life expectancy boost is largely due to infant survival rates. (That's the problem with measuring averages.) Most people who've lived to be 25+ have continued to live long lives.
- dexwiz 10y agoFoods are now advertised as GMO free. A large portion of people don't even want to eat anything they associate with genetic tampering. Why would they want to use that technology on their kids? We need a popular food or pet with genetic modifications before the general public accepts genetic tech on themselves. So many successful animal trials, as morally sour as that sounds.
- sp332 10y agoThe GMO aversion is more complex. Many GMOs are deployed to increase the amount of pesticide that can be used. And Monsanto uses their GMO IP to control a significant fraction of the market. So people who don't like large amounts of pesticides and people who don't like IP being used to control food markets have been campaigning to demonize GMOs in the public mind. Without the negative campaigning, I think people would be a lot more welcoming of it.
- Zigurd 10y agoI wonder how many people who harbor hidden racial prejudice are worried that enhanced humans means the end of any real or perceived or mismeasured racial advantages. There are other advantages, too: If the safety of Roundup is called into question, just make humans Roundup-Ready(tm).
- fl0wenol 10y agoFor me, an interesting take-away from this survey is that people assumed that _scientists_ would jump the gun, that "...scientists would rush to offer each of the technologies before they had adequately tested or even understood them." In their minds, it is the doctors/scientists that are most excited about the possibilities / opportunities afforded by offering something as soon as possible to the public, as if we could all be further guinea pigs for them, or as if it would make them rich personally, or that they are motivated primarily by the satisfaction of knowing the fruits of their labor were put to use. Those are certainly some of many valid motivations for people working in intellectual fields. But it is interesting the public does not understand that doctors/scientists are more likely to be reluctant to turn findings into products, instead preferring to follow the new research opportunities and/or building a community or consensus. It is a different kind of professional that turns scientific innovation into potential products (engineers, entrepreneurs, marketers, bad journalists), and along that spectrum is the increased rushed, cavalier attitude. This distinction is lost on those surveyed.
- elihu 10y agoIt would have been interesting if they had substituted "business people" or "corporations" for "scientists" is some of the surveys to see if makes a substantial difference in the perceived level of trust.
- reptation 10y agoI remember working in a university physics lab and let me assure you when the patentable discoveries are made they are surely patented.
- bllguo 10y agoThat's not really related to his point. Unless you are implying patenting a "patentable" discovery reflects how "scientists would rush to offer each of the technologies before they had adequately tested or even understood them." Which it really doesn't.
- Retra 10y agoAnd a great number of patents never make anyone any money.
- loup-vaillant 10y agoInteresting how de-converting people will make them more amenable to transhumanist ideas. Not surprising though, considering the common ground: both fundamentalist Christans and transhumanists want to live forever, happy, etc… We just think prayers ain't gonna cut it.
- Animats 10y agoRemember the reaction to Google Glass? That was just a heads-up display for a smartphone. On the other hand, Apple managed to make wearing iDweebs (their headphones) cool through advertising and branding.
- PhasmaFelis 10y agoAre we really so tribalistic now that we need to make up childish nicknames for the wrong brand of earbuds?
- MattGrommes 10y ago> the public finds it slightly more acceptable to change a baby’s genes than to enhance human abilities. This is weird. Making a permanent non-consensual change versus something like an implant. I have to chalk that up to not really thinking about the question that hard. Is there some angle I'm missing here why the first would be better?
- JauntTrooper 10y agoThe first prevents or cures a disease. We vaccinate children without their consent, causing permanent changes to their immune system, because we know it reduces their chances of suffering illness and death. Curing Huntington's or sickle cell anemia, or removing high-risk cancer genes, seem like logical next steps. Implants that change the way we think and interpret the world are a much bigger leap. They challenge our sense of self and identity. Am I still "me" if my cognitive abilities are modified? I totally get why that's a much more uncomfortable topic.
- shanacarp 10y agoThe public is against protecting babies from diseases? grrrrrr
- whack 10y agoLet's be honest - people were even more freaked out by the idea of "test tube babies" a few decades ago. Then, when the world didn't end, and they started meeting people who were actually conceived in-vitro and seemed perfectly normal, they changed their minds. This is exactly the same way "Enhanced Humans" are going to play out as well. The public is going to be freaked out, but some people will do it anyway. Either locally, or in some foreign country. With time, people will realized that these "Enhanced Humans" are their friends, neighbors, co-workers, and perfectly good people, and their barriers will start dropping. And when the time comes when they have the opportunity to enhance their baby's health/intelligence/fitness, they'll think it's plain irresponsible of them not to do so. Unless you're worried about regulatory bans, "public fears" are pretty much meaningless. If you can build it, show that it's safe, and demonstrate compelling benefits, the public will change their minds soon enough.
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoI'm not so optimistic about a positive or even neutral response. I say this as a rabid transhumanist who desperately wants to see BCI and WBE come to reality. My fear is that, an "enhanced" human will significantly outperform it's peers and thus will gain advantage in all aspects of life, that is the point after all. Those advantages will be seen as unearned and thus the "losers" will become jaded and blame the technology - or rather the person's access to it. Someone who was conceived in vitro doesn't pose a threat to it's peers from the perspective of abilities by virtue of being in vitro. Just like you see jealously now for disparities in abilities, I worry it will be magnified once people start upgrading. That's without even getting into the "who can afford to upgrade" part of it.
- whack 10y agoI agree. You're going to see a lot of jealousy/envy when this technology is first rolled out. But what are people really going to do? Even if you ban the technology locally, people will just go overseas and get it done. And if you're going to make that an illegal offense and screen for all babies at airport terminals, what about immigration? Is the country really going to ban all immigrants from countries where the procedure is legal? Once the genie is out of the bottle, people will realize they can only fight it for so long. At some point, people will realize that if you can't beat 'em, they might as well join 'em.
- rasz_pl 10y agoSubmarine for Deus Ex: Mankind Divided?