3 ms·
What they know is their own history. Within the memory of China's current leadership, they've had a personality-cult-dictatorship and famines and purges-of-int
by gojomo 17y ago
What they know is their own history.
Within the memory of China's current leadership, they've had a personality-cult-dictatorship and famines and purges-of-intellectuals (the 60s and 70s). Going back to the early-to-mid-20th century, China faced invading armies, a bitter civil war, and a communist revolution -- together killing tens of millions. In the 19th century, China was dominated by western foreign powers, and had another civil war -- the Taiping rebellion -- that featured a self-proclaimed "brother of Jesus" leading a "heavenly army" in a conflict that killed 25 million -- proportionately more than the US lost in its civil war of the same period (which had fewer cult/messianical undertones).
US domestic policy is still informed (and twisted) by our far-more-mild experiences over the same periods. So it's understandable that the technocratic Chinese leadership thinks that their own population, without strong central control, is prone to be caught up in giant ideological swings and civil wars.
While not excusing human rights violations, this insight should at least make their mindset a little less mysterious. America has had the luxury of seeing openness work for two centuries at the same time China was suffering religious, imperialist, and ideological misery.
- cglee 17y agoVery good point. Another perspective that shapes China is its long term view of things. If you take a hard, LONG look at China's history, it's shaped by the peasant class. The dynastic cycles have been the result of peasant uprisings, so while everyone in the West likes to focus on the developing cities, hot technologies, etc, it's really how well the peasant class does that will shape China.
- est 17y ago> So it's understandable that the technocratic Chinese leadership thinks that their own population, without strong central control, is prone to be caught up in giant ideological swings and civil wars. This is very debatable. In history, China's top two dynasties. Han and Tang, both emphasis a Taoism Wu wei rule. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wu_wei http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wu_wei Yet both empires are the most powerful, liberate and culture rich dynasties of China. Han and Tang are technically every Chinese's dream country.