6 ms·
While interesting, this article seems to ignore the possibility that most people simply have a very strong desire to live. It assumes that if someone is sufferi
by mikeash 10y ago
While interesting, this article seems to ignore the possibility that most people simply have a very strong desire to live. It assumes that if someone is suffering, and death would end that suffering, then suicide makes sense, and something weird must be going on to make people keep going.
But this really doesn't make sense. The entire concept of suffering exists merely to keep us alive. We experience pain and despair and sadness not because it's some inherent part of being conscious, but because those sensations help us to avoid things which are detrimental to survival. When push comes to shove, the drive to survive is what's fundamental, and that will (usually) override the desire to avoid suffering.
As intelligent, conscious beings, we have the capability to understand when survival is no longer possible, making suffering a waste. Thus we can, sometimes, override our desire to live in the face of terminal illness. But what's weird is not the fact that we don't constantly kill ourselves at the first sign of trouble, what's weird is the fact that we do sometimes kill ourselves when things look completely hopeless. You might as well try to stay alive, after all.
- 55555 10y ago> But what's weird is not the fact that we don't constantly kill ourselves at the first sign of trouble, what's weird is the fact that we do sometimes kill ourselves when things look completely hopeless. I think hope plays a big part. We don't kill ourselves because we have hope. If we are suffering and have no hope, that's a recipe for suicide.
- Retric 10y agoBeing extremely depressed actually reduces short term risks of suicide because planning shuts down. It's the middle ground where things are bad, but people can still think that has the highest risks.* *Excluding hospital assisted suicide where someone OD's on pain medication under end of life pain.
- Bartweiss 10y agoBut "no hope" is not equivalent to "extremely depressed". Think of people who commit suicide over inescapable scandals, chronic pain, or terminal illness. Extremely depressed comes with 'no hope', but that's cancelled out by 'decreased agency' (which is one theory for why antidepressants carry suicide risk). Not every form of hopelessness shares that loss of agency.
- Retric 10y agoHuman evolution is very much a work in progress. Many things that hurt survival are around because other things are more important. Evaluate these 50,000 options as pass fail. Change a few randomly, shuffle with another set. Repeat. Sure, it works for minor things eventually. But, in the short term only the most major things have noticeable impact.
- spdustin 10y agoIt is said that pain is a fact, a by-product of life and the human condition. But suffering is a choice. Many simply choose not to suffer with their pain.
- antris 10y agoA depressed mind doesn't work like that. For a depressed person, their brain is constantly torturing them, and the depressed point of view seems much more real. "You can choose to pretend you're happy like the rest, but you know how life really goes."
- Ntrails 10y agoI think you missed the point, the way to "not suffer" is death. In general every morning we make a decision on whether the expected future happiness is going to outweigh the expected future suffering. When that fails (and it does) we find reasons of duty to keep going, for the people we love etc. You're right, depressed people have a skewed vision of the future and it destroys their expectations of happiness.
- idanoeman 10y agoI don't think that's obvious - spdustin could be speaking from a buddhist point of view: suffering is caused by desire, not pain. You can choose to remove desire and suffering from the mind through meditation.
- mikeash 10y agoWhat a terrifying sentiment. I'm astonished at how attracted people are to theories where problems are necessarily the fault of the person experiencing them. Hey, if you're suffering, there's an easy solution: just choose not to! Gee, why didn't I ever think of that.
- spdustin 10y agoI think I took something different from it than others are. Many people choose not to suffer, because "suicide is an option". Or pills. Or therapy. Or, the lucky ones, they can switch it off. Depression (noted in another comment) further limits the ways by which one can control the suffering brought on by pain. I know this well. Many of us do.
- Practicality 10y agoIn addition to a desire to live, not everyone views suffering as the worst possible thing. If I had to be in serious pain every day but could keep doing many things I would rather keep living with the pain. The loss in experience is worse than any level of pain. For the obvious counterpoint: I say that from experience not naivete. I've had a nerve in my hand accidentally sliced lengthwise (for a significant length) by a surgeon. The pain was so excruciating they had to put me under before I had a heart attack (heart rate+blood pressure both went off the charts, 290bpm) However, before that happened I was much more interested in what was going on and how unique this level of pain was. It was fascinating. Prior to that I didn't really know how much pain it was possible to feel. Anyway the point is, not everyone is afraid of pain and suffering. Especially not to the point that suicide would even be considered.
- kdamken 10y agoOut of curiosity - was the pain fixed when you woke back up? Because brief, intense pain like that is one thing, but experiencing pain all day, everyday is a very different beast. Even if it's a tenth of the pain that you felt, that kind of thing really wears on you, especially after years and years and no help from doctors.
- Bartweiss 10y agoThis, I think, is relevant to the idea that suicide is very strongly tied to exhaustion and hopelessness. Pain and grief, even when they are absolutely horrible, don't appear to be strongly correlated with suicide. Inescapable problems, even when they are not so severe, absolutely do. Broadly, people seem to turn to suicide either when their circumstances seem unimprovable (chronic pain, inescapable debt, irreparable loss) or when they lose the ability to imagine recovery (acute depression, various forms of psychosis). I think that when considering suicide, experiences like "I've been in that much pain" are basically irrelevant - the operant part is the permanence, not the severity.
- Practicality 10y agoI strongly agree! I think part of the reason I (and probably many others) don't see pain as something that would lead to suicide is because I would (and do) simply accept it as a fact and I no longer see it as a problem. Kind of like being short, or not as smart as the next guy. It's just the way it is. No point worrying about it. However, if you viewed it as a serious problem and when is it going to be fixed and then... never... yeah, that would be very different.
- Bartweiss 10y agoIt seems very likely that this is a context issue or typical mind fallacy. The View From Hell is written by an anti-natalist and, if I recall, 'nonpracticing suicide'. This, I think, is someone who has a radically different baseline for "desire to live" than a lot of the people responding to it. And, on the flip side, a statement like "the drive to survive is what's fundamental" might well sound completely bizarre to the writer. The idea that despair and sadness are about avoiding things detrimental to survival is at best situationally true, as evidenced by all the times when people find those feelings themselves detrimental to survival. But aside from all of that, I think this doesn't invalidate the basic claim that a lot of the things stopping somewhat-suicidal people are not the desire to live. At the point where someone is considering suicide, their "life drive" wiring is obviously not a whole answer - so it remains relevant to look at the large number of suicide ideators who are held back by fear, or motivation issues, or other indirect reservations.
- mikeash 10y agoI agree with your point at the end. The question of what keeps many suicidal people alive is quite interesting, and no doubt complex. I just feel like the introductory question of "Why do so few humans kill themselves?" is backwards: the basic strangeness of human suicide is why we do it at all. Beyond that, there is then the interesting sub-question of why some people feel a desire to do it, but refrain.
- Bartweiss 10y agoThis is a fair summary. I suspect that the author might disagree about how strange the basic urge to suicide is, but I completely agree that the really interesting category is "internally suicidal but not acting on it".
- josemrb 10y ago> what's weird is the fact that we do sometimes kill ourselves when things look completely hopeless. The hope is always there, just change the purpose. Instead of a life without suffering one expects to end the pain. That is the final hope that the suicidal people embrace.
- goatforce5 10y agoFor most of us, committing suicide is unimaginable. Sometimes people find themselves in situations where the unimaginable is a better option than whatever it is they're facing. The act is equally horrific, but preferable to the alternative. > At least 200 people are believed to have fallen or jumped to their deaths [from the World Trade Centre on 9/11] while other estimates say the number is half of that or fewer. [...] > The New York City medical examiner's office said it does not classify the people who fell to their deaths on September 11 as "jumpers": "A 'jumper' is somebody who goes to the office in the morning knowing that they will commit suicide. These people were forced out by the smoke and flames or blown out." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Falling_Man https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Falling_Man
- mikeash 10y agoI don't think the WTC jumpers are quite the same. They were faced with certain death or near certain death, and they naturally chose the latter. Falls from a great height are survivable, very very rarely. I see this an example of the human drive to survive: when faced with death, we'll try anything that offers any sort of hope, even just a slight delay.
- goatforce5 10y ago> when faced with death, we'll try anything that offers any sort of hope, even just a slight delay Many people opt-out of aggressive cancer treatments that may add months on to their lives, and increasingly euthanasia is a (legal) alternative to letting medical conditions run their course. There are situations where ending things early can be one of the valid choices made available to you. http://www.goodreads.com/quotes/200381-the-so-called-psychotically-depressed-person-who-tries-to-kill-herself http://www.goodreads.com/quotes/200381-the-so-called-psychot...
- dsp1234 10y agovery strong desire to live. Meh, I just fear hurting the ones I love.
- DefaultUserHN 10y agoSo... a very store desire to live (so that you don't hurt the ones you love).
- erikb 10y agoI agree with most of the assumptions. They are assumptions, though. We don't really know what makes us feel and act the way we do.
- Shivetya 10y agoI guess the title caught me off guard. Suicide rates are low as compared to what, does any other animal on earth kill itself? with regards to people I would not place on it on the desire to live, I figure it because there are so many distractions in life
- Sniffnoy 10y ago> While interesting, this article seems to ignore the possibility that most people simply have a very strong desire to live. Alternatively: People can have goals related to the actual outside state of the world, rather than their own internal state. If you can only conceptualize goals in terms of your own internal state, then sure, you might kill yourself to avoid pain, or wirehead yourself at the first opportunity. But if your actual goals are out there in the world, then it's essentially as you say above. Dying reduces your influence on the world. If you're not alive, it's much harder to steer the world to your desired state. Survival is a convergent instrumental goal, for people as much as for AIs.
- thaumasiotes 10y ago> The entire concept of suffering exists merely to keep us alive. We experience pain and despair and sadness not because it's some inherent part of being conscious, but because those sensations help us to avoid things which are detrimental to survival. Emotions are often themselves detrimental to survival. They are there to make sure you survive and reproduce, not that you survive without issue.
- nurettin 10y agoExactly. Our bodies go through great lengths reconstructing damaged flesh, holding together with the help of something as primitive as stitching, getting disinfected with something as common as ammonia that changes our perceptions of our bodies making survival a second nature and a habit to us.