4 ms·
The article misses the mark IMHO by focusing on skeuomorphic(sp?) icons. Yes, usability has degraded during the recent 'flat design' craze, but not so much bec
by flohofwoe 10y ago
The article misses the mark IMHO by focusing on skeuomorphic(sp?) icons.
Yes, usability has degraded during the recent 'flat design' craze, but not so much because skeuomorphism was tossed out, but because the many little visual design changes that kill discoverability.
The mobile operating systems started this trend where a lot of advanced functionality was hidden behind 'magic' touch and swipe gestures that go way beyond the simple and intuitive tap, zoom and rotate gestures, like 2-, 3- and 4-finger swipes, long and short touches, etc..., important features cannot be visually discovered (how do I close an application again, on iOS, Android and Windows8? how do I flip between applications? how do I take a screenshot?).
It's the many small things that kill usability for the sake of visual design:
- the famous shift-key on iOS, what the hell were they thinking?
- buttons are often indistinguishable from non-interactive label, leading to idiotic trial and error clicking to find out which UI elements do something
- scroll-bars that are hidden by default, loosing the information how far I am into a document (OSX)
- changing and moving things around just for the sake of confusing existing users, not making anything more intuitive (especially Windows is guilty of this)
And so on and on... the icon design is the least of the problems (and every OS worth its salt should allow to replace the icon theme anyway).
One important reason I'm going back to the command line more and more is because UIs have become so unusable for anything that goes beyond browsing an image collection. Change itself is only good if it results in improvements, but in the area of UI design, things that have been working just fine for 20 years have been broken for superficial visual effects.
It's like 90's web designers took over and are building operating system UIs now (and may be there's a bit of truth in it).
It's not like the past was perfect of course, I mean... Alt-F4, Alt-TAB, ... but that was on Windows which was always laughed at for its poor usability (at least from view of AmigaOS and MacOS users).
- danellis 10y agoAlso, hiding some menu actions behind an Alt-click, which is terrible for discoverability.
- josho 10y agoI don't like change for the sake of change either, as that is just setting trends to help sell more product (e.g. the bi-annual iPhone case redesign). But, the OS changes you highlighted all have real benefits that move the focus from screen widgets to the actual content. > - buttons are often indistinguishable from non-interactive label, leading to idiotic trial and error clicking to find out which UI elements do something How come everyone understands hyperlinks on the web, but when the OS follows the same pattern you can't figure it out? I know a few apps have gotten this wrong on occasion, but as long as the text for an action is coloured differently than regular text then it's pretty obvious. > scroll-bars that are hidden by default, loosing the information how far I am into a document (OSX) On small screens (remember macbook airs are only 11" screens which I consider small) this saves precious screen space. If you really need to know where you are in a doc, resting your fingers on the trackpad and moving slightly brings the bar back. I thought this was a brilliant design to reduce clutter on the screen, not unlike how our browsers have been reducing their chrome to give the content more room. I'm all for removing clutter from my screen if it helps me focus on the content.
- Sylos 10y ago> how do I close an application again, on iOS, Android and Windows8? Christ, yeah, I still remember before Microsoft attempted to patch Windows 8 into a somewhat less unusable OS, I had opened one of those Metro apps to see what it was like. And then exactly that, I sat there for probably at least ten minutes not knowing how to close it, again. Eventually, through pure chance, I moved the mouse to the top of the screen, and that then unhid what was essentially a window titlebar with a close-button on it. But no indicator for it, no tutorial shouting at me how to do it, there was simply no reason for me to ever move my mouse to the top of the screen.