5 ms·
Frequently, I'll be told after an appointment (doctor, accountant, etc.) to expect a call from someone, but won't be told what number they'll be calling from. S
by derefr 10y ago
Frequently, I'll be told after an appointment (doctor, accountant, etc.) to expect a call from someone, but won't be told what number they'll be calling from. Since whatever information they want to tell me is Confidential™, they won't bother to leave me a voicemail with a single distinguishing detail, either, instead just saying "Please call us back at [number], we have important information to discuss." Which is... exactly the same message the telemarketers leave.
- DrScump 10y agoSome medical providers, such as mental health clinics or reproductive health clinics, always shroud their numbers out of privacy concerns whether required by HIPPA or not.
- histley 10y agoI found that extremely annoying as a patient at Planned Parenthood, I was always sending their calls to voice-mail and then having to call back through their screening service. I still really appreciate that they do it, though, for those it makes a difference to.
- johnm1019 10y agoThis is important for some people in vulnerable situations who don't want someone else to know they're going to a doctor. "Significant others" screening calls and googling the numbers (even w/o answering the phone) could lead to a bad situation.
- cmiles74 10y agoThere must be a better solution, this can't be working well for most of their customers and sounds more the sort of nonfunctional process a lawyer would come up with. I understand that there are people in vulnerable situations, but that is not the norm. Perhaps a check-box on the HIPAA form that indicates they need "confidential voicemail and SMS messages" would be a better solution.
- wschroed 10y agoI wonder if they would agree to say a special word in the message. "Mention 'bananas' when you call."
- FungalRaincloud 10y agoAgreed upon code words in the message. I had a friend who was told that if she received a call regarding a particular sensitive matter, the person on the phone would start the call (whether she answered or not) with "Hey, it's Jenny" If someone was listening in to the call/message, it'd be easy to just say "Sorry, I think you have the wrong number." Trouble is, sometimes people feel uncomfortable bringing up the subject, so it takes the professional who is calling bringing it up to see any benefit. I do not think that a checkbox is appropriate - at any point, you might become concerned with the privacy of a matter, or you might not realize that privacy is a concern for you. For instance, consider someone who accidentally listens to a message stating that they are now pregnant, at work. Their employer now has advanced notice of a pregnancy, but no knowledge of the employee's intentions with regard to work. That is going to change the dynamic of the workplace, even if the employer does not intend anything nefarious. I really think the only graceful solution to this is agreed code words.
- cmiles74 10y agoWe can only expect so much from the people who work at these offices. It's probably a bad idea to listen to voicemail messages at work via speakerphone; if someone does do this I think it's on them to deal with the repercussions... It doesn't strike me as reasonable to put the onus on the person leaving the message. Voicemail is tied to a phone or requires a PIN number and this seems to meet the bare minimum security requirements. I agree that code words may be more effective than simply checking a box, but I maintain my position that it should be opt-in. I don't want to have to remember which code words mean what, or which office use code words, etc. I use my phone and email in a secure and responsible manner; explanatory text is my preference.
- FungalRaincloud 10y ago