2 ms·
I love this quote. I think most people apply the Sophisticate's error to China by supposing that since both the US and China are different shades of gray, they
by grandalf 17y ago
I love this quote. I think most people apply the Sophisticate's error to China by supposing that since both the US and China are different shades of gray, they may then decide arbitrarily to critique China... similarly:
We saw it manifested in yesterday's post - the one who believed that odds of two to the power of seven hundred and fifty millon to one, against, meant "there was still a chance". All probabilities, to him, were simply "uncertain" and that meant he was licensed to ignore them if he pleased.
If you care about censorship, you are not licensed to ignore censorship in the US just because both are gray. If you care about humanitarian abuses, you are not licensed to ignore them in the US just because China may commit worse ones.
- orangecat 17y agoIf you care about censorship, you are not licensed to ignore censorship in the US just because both are gray. If you care about humanitarian abuses, you are not licensed to ignore them in the US just because China may commit worse ones. You are however "licensed" to focus more on China, on the grounds that their abuses are orders of magnitude worse.
- grandalf 17y agoI challenge that assertion here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1217082 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1217082