4 ms·
Human brains are also very inefficient at computation (per unit energy, time, mass, volume, or some combination of the four), unless it's a problem they were tu
by SilasX 10y ago
Human brains are also very inefficient at computation (per unit energy, time, mass, volume, or some combination of the four), unless it's a problem they were tuned for over a really long evolutionary time (e.g. facial recognition, bipedal locomotion, etc).
Sure, if you find a problem that a NN algorithm is really good at, then mapping the hardware to the NN algorithm will get an efficiency speedup, but that's because of the application-specific hardware, not because the vNA is a bad general computation model in terms of what we can physically instantiate.
- p1esk 10y agoYou can say the same thing about our computers: they are very inefficient at tasks they were not designed to do. Actually they are very inefficient even at tasks they were designed to do, but since they do them very fast, we've been ignoring it (at least until Moore's law started to slow down). Just think about all layers of abstraction present in current computing platforms, and how much computation really happens when you type 2+2 in a Python console. Also, there are a lot more problems a brain solves better than computers. Software NNs slowly learn to solve more and more of those, primarily by better copying how brain does it. So, in summary, vNA might not be a "bad" general computational model, but it surely is very inefficient compared to human brain, when it comes to "computing" vast majority of tasks.
- taneq 10y ago> Just think about all layers of abstraction present in current computing platforms, and how much computation really happens when you type 2+2 in a Python console. That's not a limitation of von Neumann architecture. That's a consequence of us using the vast and cheap computational resources available to us to make things easy.
- sushirain 10y agoYour arguments are compelling. I hope others will embrace them more.
- SilasX 10y ago>You can say the same thing about our computers: they are very inefficient at tasks they were not designed to do. Hold on -- we need to be consistent about what part of them was designed for what purpose. In the context of the discussion, it's the hardware. Computer hardware is only "designed" to be able to maintain a small state while performing a huge number of Boolean circuits (from some large set of possible circuits) per second, writing to external stores. They were not designed to e.g. make graphs, host discussion forums, etc, and yet do that very well --because we can apply software that converts those problems into "do these Boolean circuits/writes really fast". Considering how handily they beat the alternatives at those tasks, I think it would be fair to say that they're good at things they're not designed for! It's just that there remain a few problems that aren't tractable to this approach so far; but focusing on those problems is a misleading picture. >Actually they are very inefficient even at tasks they were designed to do, but since they do them very fast, we've been ignoring it (at least until Moore's law started to slow down) As above, they were only designed to do those circuits and they're good at that.
- p1esk 10y agoI have no idea what you mean by "perform Boolean circuits" in the context of this discussion. Bottom line: vNA based computers are inefficient, regardless of what they are trying to compute. But they do most of the tasks fast enough for us not to care. When it's not fast enough, people build ASICs.
- SilasX 10y agoA Boolean circuit is a circuit that implements a Boolean expression (given input signals set to 1/0, output the 1/0 value corresponding to the result of substituting them into that expression.) Computers at their core are machines designed to implement many such circuits, of many varieties, per second, and send their signals to output devices or their own internal state. When CPU makers design them, they are optimizing for the efficiency (with respect to cost, space, mass, energy consumption, et/vel cetera) with which they perform that task. They do not specifically optimize them for hosting forum discussions; instead, the software or OS designer chooses instructions for the CPU that allow it to accomplish that efficiently. All of the above was in response to your claim that computers are only (somewhat) efficient at what they're designed to do. But they're designed to implement boolean circuits (and write to peripherals), they're not designed to host discussion forums, et cetera, and yet they're still good at the latter. What do you disagree with there? >Bottom line: vNA based computers are inefficient, regardless of what they are trying to compute If modern computers are "inefficient" at summing numbers (or hosting discussion forums, for that matter), then may I forever be dredged in Soviet bureaucracy!
- Certhas 10y agoLast I saw, a custom built computer is many many orders of magnitude worse than the brain at playing Go per unit energy. And its not like we evolved to play Go.
- SilasX 10y agoFair enough, my claim was overbroad. I would still say it's true for most computation tasks: a vNA computer on typical hardware is still going to be more efficient as a general-use computer than something on a neural architecture. Humans do currently have an advantage on certain tasks that require detection of overall global patterns adn symmetries. (But even then, only a subset of those tasks for which someone hasn't been able to specify a good algorithm for finding that structure.) Even so, the core point remains: it's not that vNA is a bad architecture or that neural computers are more efficient in general, and the latter are probably much harder to reason about.
- bitL 10y agoNN != brain. Not by a long shot. We still have no clue how it operates, don't kid yourself. There are some processes happening in the brain that aren't supposed to happen, like the massive amount of ions passing through membranes, causing some think there is some time-bending quantum effect making it happen. We simply have no clue.