5 ms·
Don't fuck with the free market. I know the intentions are good, but this will just create 100 loopholes and complexity up the ass. Fail.
by hbosvismylife 10y ago
Don't fuck with the free market.
I know the intentions are good, but this will just create 100 loopholes and complexity up the ass. Fail.
- vkou 10y agoYou obviously don't live in Vancouver. The free market has completely failed the city. The median Vancouver house now sells for 1.4 million CAD, while the median family income is $76,000 CAD. These prices are not sustainable at local salaries. This isn't Silicon Valley, where a large part of the population is raking in cash hand over fist. This is a playground for the foreign rich. Supply and demand only works when supply isn't fixed.
- davidw 10y agoWhy is the supply fixed when there is a huge incentive to add to it?
- querulous 10y agothe supply in question is single family homes, particularly detached homes vancouver is bordered to the north by mountains, the south by the us border and the west by the ocean. there's already suburban sprawl 2+ hours to the east. there is simply no room for more single family housing there is a large amount of agricultural land, but it's part of a strategic reserve as it's some of the most productive agricultural land in canada and developing it is extremely controversial
- davidw 10y agoSo... build up? That's more expensive, tech wise, than single family detached homes, but at least it adds to the supply and constrains prices to some degree. You don't have to do skyscrapers, you can do 3/4 stories like most European cities. Not everyone can live in a single-family detached home with a big yard in a place with constrained land supply.
- serge2k 10y agoand then foreign investors will buy up those units instead and people will make up more excuses.
- davidw 10y agoIf you build enough, they'll stop buying because they will realize there are better places to invest in. Actually... you probably don't even need to do that. Just credibly threaten to allow the market to work, and enough to be built, and it'll likely start to cool things down.
- mthoms 10y agoIt's not nearly as simple as you're implying. The most obvious reasons have already been discussed, but I'll add that the construction industry in Vancouver is operating at full employment and has been for a long time. So where do these workers come from? Who will employ them, and better yet… where do you house them? Chicken meet egg.
- Tiktaalik 10y agoThe frustrating thing about the supply side solution is that the answer to every argument is always "add more supply!" even if the city is obviously already doing so at an aggressive pace. The reality is that there are real world physical limits to adding supply. There are a limited amount of trades for example. There is a limited capacity to review and process development applications. It takes time to complete buildings. Unlike Silicon Valley Metro Vancouver has steadily built condos for decades and the region currently has more housing starts than at any other time ever. Vancouver's issues are deeper and more urgent than a one dimensional supply side solution can solve.
- bzbarsky 10y agoThe problem is that the "foreign investors" are not _investors_. They are more like money launderers in terms of what they're looking for out of their "investment". That is, for these people it's totally ok to pay X now and only get 0.9X out of the property later, because their other option is not having the use of the money at all. It may well be OK for many of them to pay X now and only get 0.5X out later, and for some of them it's ok to pay X now and only get 0.1X out later. They would obviously prefer a better deal, but unlike a normal home-buyer or real-estate investor expecting a huge loss on later sale of the property is not necessarily something that will stop them from buying. There may be better places to "invest" in, but finding them may be more trouble than they are willing to take.
- forrestthewoods 10y agoI'm generally with you. But dirty, corrupt money flooding out of China is problematic. What would you propose to stop those ill gotten foreign goods?