3 ms·
The problem with Dred Scott wasn't the ruling that SCOTUS was asked to rule on, namely, what the status of a slave was when an owner moved from a slave state to
by jcranmer 10y ago
The problem with Dred Scott wasn't the ruling that SCOTUS was asked to rule on, namely, what the status of a slave was when an owner moved from a slave state to a free state. That aspect of the decision is fairly defensible under the given law (basically, you can argue that automatically emancipating the slave equated to an illegal, uncompensated taking of property). Odious, but defensible.
The problem of Dred Scott was that SCOTUS basically went on to argue that blacks, even freed slaves, weren't citizens and could never be citizens, and also argued that slavery could not be banned in any manner whatsoever by any level of government. It was a pretty naked attempt to tell the abolitionists "Slavery exists, and there's nothing you can do about it. Deal with it."