4 ms·
I'd really like to know just what kind of timeframe he was thinking of when he said "many years" and "a very long time" there. Because that was 1945, and the fi
by mikeash 10y ago
I'd really like to know just what kind of timeframe he was thinking of when he said "many years" and "a very long time" there. Because that was 1945, and the first ICBM didn't become operational until 1959. With a 14-year interval, I'd be comfortable in saying he was right. Especially since those early ICBMs were so inaccurate that they would have been completely pointless if armed with 1945-era bombs. It took the development of multi-megaton thermonuclear weapons for those early ICBMs to be useful weapons.
Those early ICBMs were also delicate and required a lot of preparation to launch, making them highly vulnerable to attack, and of course they would be prime targets in a war. Bombers could be kept ready to take off in just a few minutes from receiving an alarm, and some could be kept on airborne alert at all times, making part of the force effectively invulnerable to attack. The modern idea of an ICBM, able to launch on warning from hardened silos capable of withstanding a close hit from an enemy weapon, took many more years to come about.
- vonmoltke 10y ago> Especially since those early ICBMs were so inaccurate that they would have been completely pointless if armed with 1945-era bombs. It took the development of multi-megaton thermonuclear weapons for those early ICBMs to be useful weapons. The Atlas had a CEP of 1.4km, which was good enough for a kiloton-class warhead. Plus, its original warhead was only 1.44Mt. It was mostly lack of priority that delayed the first operational squadron to 1959.
- CapitalistCartr 10y ago20kt at 1400 meters won't yield 6 psi overpressure. And "only 1.4 megatons"??? That's two orders of magnitude larger than Hiroshima. It took many tests and advancements to go from a fission release to a fission-fusion weapon.
- vonmoltke 10y agoLittle Boy, with an effective yield of ~15kt, had a 5psi radius of 3500m. The "only" in my comment was a response to the assertion that it required "multi-megaton" warheads to make ICBMs practical.
- CapitalistCartr 10y agoWe never had many megaton weapons. Two megaton was about the limit, and most weapons were under 500 kilotons. Accuracy is better. Huge bombs was a dick-waving contest, and after Tsar Bomba, we gave up that game and went for sophistication.
- mikeash 10y agoThe W38 used on Atlas and Titan 1 was 3.75 megatons. If we consider bomber weapons, the B41 was a 25 megaton weapon with about 500 built. The B53/W53 was a 9 megaton bomb for both bombers and missiles, with around 100 built. There are more beyond 2 megatons; these are examples, not a comprehensive list. Huge bombs weren't a dick-waving contest, they were partly to maximize the value of an ICBM carrying one warhead, and partly to mitigate inaccuracy. As MIRV became practical and accuracy increased, yields decreased on both sides of the Cold War, because smaller bombs are just plain more efficient if you can put them where they need to go.
- arethuza 10y agoThe Soviets and then the Russians deployed variants of the SS-18 with very large warheads (20-25Mt) until fairly recently - either for EMP purposes or to attack Cheyenne Mountain, Raven Rock Mountain etc. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/R-36_(missile) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/R-36_(missile)
- hga 10y agoThey're useful for very hard targets, like dropping two 20Mt or so at the same time at each end of the access tunnel for the Cheyenne Mountain Complex (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cheyenne_Mountain_Complex https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cheyenne_Mountain_Complex). Otherwise, at something in the 1 Mt plus or minus level, I forget, a lot of the energy is wasted by being thermally re-radiated out into space.
- mikeash 10y agoAre you sure about that? The NUKEMAP[0] shows a 15kt airburst with a 5psi radius of 1.67km. And "most residential buildings collapse" isn't going to be very useful against military targets, there I think you're looking more at the 20psi level, which is only 340 meters. [0] http://nuclearsecrecy.com/nukemap/ http://nuclearsecrecy.com/nukemap/
- hga 10y agoNot if your doctrine is counter-force, which was our doctrine until the utterly evil Robert Strange McNamera (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_McNamara https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_McNamara see also what he did with Vietnam and then destroying 3rd World agriculture while heading the World Bank (the Edsel, on the other hand, may be something he did the right thing in canning)) changed it to counter-value (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Countervalue https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Countervalue). After that, it wasn't difficult for the Soviets to convince themselves and their military, people, etc. that we were evil, for we very much were.