4 ms·
Interesting tidbit: Vannevar Bush, he of the frequently posted "As We May Think" essay [0], is quoted as being highly skeptical of ICBMs: > There has been a gr
by danso 10y ago
Interesting tidbit: Vannevar Bush, he of the frequently posted "As We May Think" essay [0], is quoted as being highly skeptical of ICBMs:
> There has been a great deal said about a 3,000 mile high-angle rocket. In my opinion such a thing is impossible and will be impossible for many years. The people who have been writing these things that annoy me have been talking about a 3,000 mile high-angle rocket shot from one continent to another carrying an atomic bomb, and so directed as to be a precise weapon which would land on a certain target such as this city. I say technically I don’t think anybody in the world knows how to do such a thing, and I feel confident it will not be done for a very long time to come.
The debate over ICBMs vs pilots reminds me a lot of the current tech/AI vs. human debates today:
> But it wasn’t just that the USAF was pro-bomber. They were distinctly anti-missile for a long time. Why? The late Thomas Hughes, in his history of Project Atlas, attributes a distinct “conservative momentum, or inertia” to the USAF’s approach to missiles. Long-range missiles would be disruptive to the hierarchy: engineers and scientists would be on top, with no role for pilots in sight. Officers would, in a sense, become de-skilled. And perhaps there was just something not very sporting about lobbing nukes at another country from the other side of the Earth.
[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4577865 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4577865
- hammock 10y agoIs it possible Bush was propagating disinformation for the benefit of US national security? "The U.S. initiated ICBM research in 1946 with the RTV-A-2 Hiroc project. This was a three-stage effort with the ICBM development not starting until the third stage. However, funding was cut after only three partially successful launches in 1948 of the second stage design" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intercontinental_ballistic_missile#World_War_II https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intercontinental_ballistic_mis...
- smacktoward 10y agoAnything's possible, but in 1945 skepticism wasn't a ridiculous position to hold. The most advanced rocket in the world at that time was the German V-2, which barely had enough range to reach targets in Britain from launch sites in the Netherlands and whose accuracy proved to be negligible at best. It would take fantastic sums of money to turn the rocket into a weapon with intercontinental range and reasonable accuracy, and while the Cold War made those sums available in 1945 it was still in the future.
- mikeash 10y agoI'd really like to know just what kind of timeframe he was thinking of when he said "many years" and "a very long time" there. Because that was 1945, and the first ICBM didn't become operational until 1959. With a 14-year interval, I'd be comfortable in saying he was right. Especially since those early ICBMs were so inaccurate that they would have been completely pointless if armed with 1945-era bombs. It took the development of multi-megaton thermonuclear weapons for those early ICBMs to be useful weapons. Those early ICBMs were also delicate and required a lot of preparation to launch, making them highly vulnerable to attack, and of course they would be prime targets in a war. Bombers could be kept ready to take off in just a few minutes from receiving an alarm, and some could be kept on airborne alert at all times, making part of the force effectively invulnerable to attack. The modern idea of an ICBM, able to launch on warning from hardened silos capable of withstanding a close hit from an enemy weapon, took many more years to come about.
- vonmoltke 10y ago> Especially since those early ICBMs were so inaccurate that they would have been completely pointless if armed with 1945-era bombs. It took the development of multi-megaton thermonuclear weapons for those early ICBMs to be useful weapons. The Atlas had a CEP of 1.4km, which was good enough for a kiloton-class warhead. Plus, its original warhead was only 1.44Mt. It was mostly lack of priority that delayed the first operational squadron to 1959.
- CapitalistCartr 10y ago20kt at 1400 meters won't yield 6 psi overpressure. And "only 1.4 megatons"??? That's two orders of magnitude larger than Hiroshima. It took many tests and advancements to go from a fission release to a fission-fusion weapon.
- vonmoltke 10y agoLittle Boy, with an effective yield of ~15kt, had a 5psi radius of 3500m. The "only" in my comment was a response to the assertion that it required "multi-megaton" warheads to make ICBMs practical.