2 ms·
I wonder if the ruling would be different if Power had done the scraping client-side instead of using its servers. For example, if they had distributed a tweake
by chatmasta 10y ago
I wonder if the ruling would be different if Power had done the scraping client-side instead of using its servers. For example, if they had distributed a tweaked Facebook app for jailbroken devices that allowed users to "log into" Facebook and scrape data using their own device and Internet connection.
Or, more simply, a third party app that users install on their phone and calls the "private" Facebook API directly.
Would the same arguments hold?
- cs2818 10y agoI have the same question. In this case Facebook was able to identify Power acting on behalf of users because requests came from a common set of IP addresses. If Power had instead provided users with software to run from their own devices would that change anything? In both situations this is user authorized behavior and the ability of Facebook to identify an involved service as assisting users should be irrelevant.
- mikhailt 10y agoYes, they're still in charge of the said app that they are "distributing". Authorization is what matters, it doesn't matter how they're doing it. In this case, the users are using an "unauthorized" app and Facebook can block the app if they figure out how to ban them. Facebook can also block the users for using it as well.