3 ms·
Yes the judge ruled that even though knowingly accessing a service in violation of it's TOS is not a crime, accessing it after being sent a cease and desist is.
by simonh 10y ago
Yes the judge ruled that even though knowingly accessing a service in violation of it's TOS is not a crime, accessing it after being sent a cease and desist is. So it appears that the way in which you are asked not to do something has a bearing on whether it's ok for you to do it or not. That seems pretty crazy.
Facebook as a way to prevent this access that's guaranteed to work. They could block the user's account.
Furthermore the Judge's argument regarding a bank barring someone from entering if they are carrying a shotgun is bogus. They could just as well use an example of banning someone if they are carrying a cuddly toy. Using a gun in the example is a transparent attempt to appeal to emotion. There's nothing in Power Ventures activities that could be reasonably equated to openly toting a deadly weapon in a bank.
- franciscop 10y agoWhat if I know I'm doing something that Facebook doesn't like, see an email from them and ignore/delete it? Where does a "Please stop using our web" become a Cease and Desist order?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- coldtea 10y ago>So it appears that the way in which you are asked not to do something has a bearing on whether it's ok for you to do it or not. That seems pretty crazy. How's that even remotely "crazy"? If I merely ask you "I don't want to see you here again", and you come back, you don't get much problems with the law. If I get a restricting order on you, and you came back, I can have you arrested. There are different levels of being "told not to do something", and some popup has less power than a TOS, which has less power than a cease and desist, which has less power than a full court order, etc...