7 ms·
My biology paper in Science
- anc84 10y agoIf papers themselves were written like that, "science" would be so much more approachable!
- johncolanduoni 10y agoUnfortunately this is hard to do because (a) insufficient time (b) insufficient number of Scott Aaronsons. I struggle to think of anyone else who can write about science in such an accessible way (without convenient misconceptions and falsehoods).
- beambot 10y agoNot sure that's true... It takes a lot of effort to translate text into concise science speak ("I'd have written a shorter letter if only I had more time"). This would have a huge added benefit of making per review easier, making science more approachable, and making it all less pedantic.
- the_duke 10y agoDomain specific language and formalisms exist for a reason. They enable efficient communication for people who know the field. Scientific papers are not written for the layman with an interest, but to communicate the results of your research to others in the field. Admittedly a lot of papers are also just written to keep your University from giving your job to someone else. But publish or perish is another issue. I agree that there should be more scientists writing articles / blogs that make their research approachable and engaging for the layman, but that does not extend to papers, in my opinion.
- Arnt 10y agoOr, perhaps: They enable grants. I've only ever helped write a single grant application. My parts of that had to be rewritten with more use of passive verbs and general neutral-sounding but largely vacuous prose. I thought it's like those chick jokes. You don't offer comments about random women's gorgeous breasts because you really want to, it's just expected in some contexts. It tells the audience you're one of the guys. Overlong sentences where all that's done is passively done inform the grant reviewers that the author a proper scientist who should be enabled to continue with valuable research.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- wingcommander 10y ago"As we all learn in kindergarten, DNA is a finite string ..." Did this guy go to a really brainy kindergarten for gifted children?
- James001 10y agotbh, I found this much more confusing to read than normal biology papers.
- maxander 10y agoI would take a guess that anc84 is accustomed to CS, and James001 is accustomed to bio. "Papers" in each of these fields are entirely different animals, and require a different mental skillset to quickly grok.
- vobios 10y agoThis is written for random internet people. Science papers are written for other scientists working in that particular niche. They are not trying to be approachable to the general public.
- guard-of-terra 10y agoThat's nice! Turns out, biologists (many kinds of scientists probably) are in need of computer modelling, information retrieval and so on. Naturally it gives opportunity to us IT folks, even without terribly much scientific background. I've co-authored a biology paper too. Here is the resulting code: https://github.com/alamar/microbe https://github.com/alamar/microbe
- biounit 10y agoA better title for your link would be - "OUR biology paper in Science." Big congratulations on the paper. Impressive.
- Rainymood 10y ago>ZYXY = GATTACA TAG AGT CTA. Subtle ;) I like it.
- myrloc 10y agoLooks fascinating. Does anyone want to summarize?