7 ms·
Hard Forks
- jblock 10y agoI have no idea how Etherium or the blockchain works. I'm sure that it's all incredibly important and technically impressive, but these all sound like fake words that your parents would use to describe what happens when they try to update iTunes.
- lowglow 10y agoI don't understand why you were downvoted. I think you bring up very valid points about the state of education that is required for wide spread adoption.
- jblock 10y agoHahaha, thank you. I was also trying to be curt and funny, but I guess the HN community takes their Ethereum seriously :D
- sanxiyn 10y ago> It's a very interesting time in the public blockchain sector right now. Stuff is happening. Lot's of stuff. I'd like to learn some of these stuffs. Where should I start? What are some stuffs happening?
- chollida1 10y agoDid Ethereum ever come out and try and create a process to dictate what will happen when something like this happens again? This case was a perfect storm of: - very bad publicity with most people's first introduction to Ethereum, the DAO, being hacked - Ethereum core team members and miners being affected by the hack - a large hack, monetarily speaking, in relation to the ecosystem. - the ecosystem still in its infancy so the system is much open to even considering a hard fork option at all I mean you can't just outlaw programming mistakes. This is going to happen again What happens next time when the hack is smaller, say 1 million, and doesn't affect anyone on the core Ethereum team or any miners, ie it just affects regular Ethereum investors. Does everyone vote again with the expected outcome of the miners not worrying about hte little people? Does it not even get a vote? Or have they set the precedent that they always roll back hacks now? I think Ethereum has some good leadership, but I think this is something that they really need to get a policy on now. What can be done here?
- drcode 10y agoWell, these are difficult questions, but I kind of like Vlad Zanfir's recent comments on this issue which is that it's best for everyone if the "out of the ordinary" nature of hard forks is maintained as much as possible: If there is a pre-established policy on how to handle these situations it could backfire in many ways- It may be better to just require the merit of any hard fork to be considered on a case-by-case basis.
- roymurdock 10y agoNothing. Ethereum/DAO/blockchain's main differentiator is its purported immutability. Tired of traditional actors setting the rules of your financial system? Let some "smarter" more "neutral" hackers set those rules for you in stone cold code. Discard the DAO and start anew from first principles, but make it clear and transparent that the code is written by humans that can also change that code, and that it's not a magic immutable "distributed autonomous organization" but a collection of dudes on their computers who tinker with the rules of one big excel spreadsheet. Different dudes than the ones who currently control the markets. Tell me why I should trust these new dudes to have enough gravitas to run a more efficient market.
- cel1ne 10y ago> who tinker with the rules of one big excel spreadsheet Thank you for that comparison. The whole issue is much more palpable if you forget about the magic blockchain for a second and see Ethereum as what it is: A giant complex calculation that nobody comprehends to it's full extent. Just like most computer-programs out there. And just like the financial market. We engineers have learned that we can't rely on complex apparatuses always behaving according to our intentions. So the way to go is to ensure they fail gracefully. When it comes to law, the real world did this, not by trying to find the perfect, unambiguous, immutable language for contracts and law. (Ever heard about the 'Tower of Babel'? The idea of a common language is as old as humanity). They did it by implementing safe-guards, namely the juridicial system. When it comes to the financial market, we too have safeguards, but not that many. There is no judge who is able to rule that an individual was not supposed to make billions of dollars by destroying the environment and evading taxes. A humanitarian society doesn't work out by just following a set of more and more complex rules. You always need humans to interpret and adapt them.
- snitko 10y agoWithout going into a lengthy discussion, I respectfully disagree with the author: adaptability is NOT more important than immutability. If you don't have immutability, it means there is a potential to avoid consequences for your actions, which, in turn, means the evolution goes in the wrong direction. In fact, even in nature, you cannot evolve back: creatures evolve, try new things, if they don't stick - the branch dies off. What is being suggested by Ethereum is that you can try an evolution path, see it's not actually working and then rollback - it seems like a good idea at first because you can supposedly iterate fast. But I think Ethereum would lose confidence of investors either way: 1) if you hardfork, you set a precedent and now no one is sure what can be rolled back, when and for what reason 2) if you don't fork - then money is stolen. I seriously see no way out of this. It probably was a good decision to fork, because that at least allowed to save the face and the investment short-term.
- drcode 10y agoI view ethereum as a tool for automation: It lets us automate legal contracts, currencies, synthetic assets, etc. All forms of automation in our world go wrong sometimes: This is why we have car repair shops and appliance repair technicians, for instance. Saying that ethereum is only useful if the automation holds 100% of the time is like saying cars are useless if you have to occasionally take them to the shop for a tune-up. I agree that having a car that never needs a repair would be AWESOME but it would probably be unrealistic to try and build one. That said, ethereum is still extremely good for writing immutable computer code involving financial assets, it's just that there is now some philosophical (and practical) controversy as to whether it is 100% good or just 99.9999% good (depending on whether you view the code or the community as the ultimate arbiter of "good".)
- Tinyyy 10y agoYou can already create legal contracts easily - sign on a piece of paper. This piece of paper is interpreted by a relatively robust legal system with a long history. How is Ethereum going to do better than that if a disagreement is settled not by inspecting the code, but by the opinion of an arbitrary community of miners?
- olh 10y ago> In my mind, adaptability is more important than immutability. Important for what? Is there adaptability without mutability? Programmers know that if you implement something with the premise of immutability then if mutability occurs the state of your application changes arbitrarily. Mutability is good for the ones who can rely on an existing provider of centralized governance to make decisions that benefit them. For everyone else it's just plain corruption. Ethereum pivoted from decentralized governance to centralized governance across borders. They are now solving different problems and I hope they see it.
- Lazare 10y ago> I have no idea how Etherium or the blockchain works. Your ignorance is readily fixable; luckily for you you're already on the internet. Google is just a click away. That being said, you don't need to know how they work. A blockchain is a decentralised database where no single authority can edit it, and thus you don't need to trust any one entity to host it or vouch for it. 1) It's useful in situations where you can't trust someone to look after the database because they may edit it maliciously. 2) It's not useful in situations where you can trust someone to look after it, and you'd like them to have the ability to edit it beneficially (by, eg, reversing a fraudulent transaction). > these all sound like fake words Your apparently shockingly sheltered upbringing is leading you astray. You should probably fix that before it causes you some serious embarrassment.
- Animats 10y agoIf you don't know how Etherium works in great detail, you probably shouldn't be using it. As the DAO just discovered the hard way. You can use Bitcoin without understanding it, but Etherium can bite you in unexpected ways.
- dang 10y agoPersonal attacks, which this crosses into, are not allowed on HN. Please edit such stuff out of your comments here. We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12151921 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12151921 and marked it off-topic.
- niftich 10y agoThe threat of hard forks undermines not only confidence in the governance of the cryptocurrency, but also of any application (in the 'make-use-of' sense) of the blockchain. Specifically, Ethereum was designed with the explicit purpose of running distributed applications that commit their applicaton state into the blockchain. If this state can be subject to a rollback, in the form of forking from a block in the past -- community consensus notwithstanding -- then then you can never rely on the blockchain as storage. Now, of course, cryptocurrencies only have value if participants believe in them; and these supposed 'smart contracts' of 'state-in-the-blockchain' work the same way. Since we lack the technological means to prevent forks, we need human stewardship to avoid them, and that's clearly not what Ethereum has done.
- grandalf 10y agoAnyone who works with code will know that bugs happen all the time. Semantic bugs can be hard to anticipate, and are sometimes not obvious even to highly knowledgeable reviewers. The big fallacy underlying the hard fork is the idea that bugs like this will only happen this one time and so the benefit of stealing the money back and giving it to community early adopters outweighs the costs to the institutional credibility of Ethereum. In reality, there will be many, many more bugs in smart contracts where the intent of the coder does not completely match the behavior of the smart contract in the real world. The Ethereum community, and notably its core team who wrote the code for the hard fork while claiming to be neutral in the matter, has sent a strong message that it will meddle in the outcome of contracts in which there was no VM bug. Human institutions are relatively vulnerable to corruption. There is all sorts of graft, favoritism, etc., throughout most human institutions. Ethereum, because of the concentration of power among early adopters, is still vulnerable to this sort of corruption. We've seen it happen with the hard fork. Is it a big deal? Well, the invisible hand should have awarded the spoils of the theft to the talented hacker who exploited the contract. Those who lost money in the DAO are people who followed a herd mentality and did not insist that the smart contract they trusted be vetted. Formal verification will help somewhat, as will the improvement of coding practice. I saw some code written by someone involved in the DAO that was written in a way that made it hard to understand the side-effects of various calls. I'd highlight this if doing code review for a simple e-commerce cart, and it suggests that semantic clarity and readability were ranked low on the list of priorities, favoring a denser style that is much more demanding of the reader's understanding of the subtleties of the language. What is missing is the simple idea of insurance. Suppose investors in the DAO had been allowed to buy insurance against the DAO malfunctioning... This could have been written as a simple smart contract "future" and could have been offered by anyone. So long as there was demand for both sides of the outcome, a price would have emerged to insure one's investment. So I think we're on a slippery slope, most notably because of the silly idea that this was the last smart contract bug that will be highly significant or controversial. Cryptocurrencies bootstrap by appealing to speculators who don't really care about the principle of how it's supposed to work, they just want to buy it early and wait for it to get big (as many did with BTC but many more wished they had). This is fine, but we saw the same sort of greed infect a lot more people, and a hard fork (bailout) occur soon after. You can call it adaptability, you can call it a bailout, it doesn't matter. The bottom line is that at present Ethereum is still vulnerable to it and will be for a while. Let's hope Ethereum grows to the point where a small cabal of people who made a bad investment (or hold a particular political view) can't undermine the system.
- Animats 10y agoIf the loss had happened to anyone else other than the people behind Etherium, the fork would never have happened. A fundamental problem with Etherium is contracts between anonymous parties. If the other party in the DAO hack was discoverable, the hack would not have been a major problem. Executable, rather than declarative contracts, are probably a bad idea. Putting in a virtual machine is a cop-out - it means you don't know how to solve the problem of expressing contracts formally, and are pushing it off on someone else. That someone else will probably botch it, as the DAO did. I've previously suggested that decision tables [1] would be a better basis for a contract system. This decision table tutorial [2] is something of an ad for a tool, but it uses as an example the sort of things one would want in a contract. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Decision_table https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Decision_table [2] http://reqtest.com/requirements-blog/a-guide-to-using-decision-tables/ http://reqtest.com/requirements-blog/a-guide-to-using-decisi...
- grandalf 10y agoDo you know if there is anyone working on declarative contracts? I was thinking that at least some sort of declarative way of bounding the contract's behavior might be useful.
- Animats 10y agoLots of people are working on declarative contracts. Here's an overview.[1] That paper has a set of desirable properties for a contract language, and analyzes some of the existing ones against those properties. Here's a contract language from 2002.[2] The author expresses various common contracts, and some not so common, in it. This is reasonably readable. If you like logic formalism, there's this.[3] Financial companies would like to have their contracts, especially derivatives, in a form suitable for running risk analyses and various scenarios. You'd like to be able to form queries like "Suppose X misses their payments for the next quarter? What does that trigger?" Some of the 2008 financial debacle came from the inability to ask questions like that. [1] https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/A-Survey-of-Formal-Languages-for-Contracts-Hvitved/500276c957028a65503c4b13214515c07abd5d93/pdf https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/A-Survey-of-Formal-Lan... [2] http://szabo.best.vwh.net/contractlanguage.html http://szabo.best.vwh.net/contractlanguage.html [3] http://www.cse.chalmers.se/~gersch/slides-talks/slides-CL-ModelChecking.pdf http://www.cse.chalmers.se/~gersch/slides-talks/slides-CL-Mo...
- killbrad 10y agoThis is a death kneel to Etherium. Immutability is literally the only thing that made it stand out from any other form of currency. Now it's no better or worse than any other form of currency. Someone can decide they don't like it and reverse a contract? Done.
- drcode 10y agoI'm really surprised at how negative the comments are here... but at least they are reasonably well informed and respectful. Oh well, guess I'll just keep trying to build useful stuff on top of ethereum and hope the opinions change (or that this thread is not representative :-)
- kerkeslager 10y agoWhy bother writing stuff on top of Ethereum? If the devs can hardfork whenever something happens they don't like, Ethereum is no less centralized than a bank. You'd probably make more consistent money by working for a bank.
- drcode 10y agoYou mean, why don't I just sit around and spend my time trolling people like you do?
- kerkeslager 10y agoNo, it's a serious question. What does Ethereum offer that isn't handled by existing banks and legal structures? As far as I can tell, the entire point of Ethereum was to decentralize contracts. Now they're no longer decentralized, so what benefit do you see in Ethereum that I don't?
- angry-hacker 10y agoYou might as well build on top of old school banks and central govs :)) Why waste time if we already have what erherum will become after the fork? There is a platform already and all the people are using it. It's called lawyers and banks.
- randomnames 10y agoIf you follow USV a little bit, they are clearly in talks investing in slock.it - probably they already did it at the DAO. So no neutral thinking here. And an example for the general problem of the fork and etherum as crypto currency - people won't trust such insider ruled 'club'
- LAMike 10y agohttp://lmgtfy.com/?q=how+does+bitcoin+work http://lmgtfy.com/?q=how+does+bitcoin+work
- dang 10y agoPlease don't post uncivil and/or unsubstantive comments to Hacker News. We detached this comment from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12151921 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12151921 and marked it off-topic.
- greenspot 10y ago@Fred, would you mind disclosing all your Blockchain related investments? On USV's portfolio site I just found Blockstack Labs (2014), Coinbase (2013). Are there more or recently closed ones?
- blhack 10y agoHere's my problem with the hardfork (unless I totally misunderstand it): I had some ETH stored on the "old" blockchain. I bought them during all the DAO publicity, but never actually bought any part of the DAO contract. The client, if you are un-ware, is a massive disk space hog. Because of this, I stopped running it. Now, because of the hardfork, in order to get my value back out of the old chain and into the new one, I have to attach an external disk to my computer, and use it to store the chain. Can I transfer out of the old and into the new chain indefinitely? I have no idea (maybe I'm just bad at google). Can I even transfer now today (once the client finishes syncing [it has been going literally all day today])? Don't know. I get the why of the hardfork, and I'm not saying that I'm going to stop supporting ethereum, just venting a little bit. Turns out new technology is new! And sometimes corner cases like mine haven't been accounted for!
- stale2002 10y agoDo you have the password to your wallet? There shouldn't be anything that you have to DO. Your money is already on the new chain. Just use any updated client.
- Zagitta 10y agoYou don't need to transfer between forks or anything of the like, the only difference for you is that you now have two types of coins. Eg if you had 21 ETH before the fork you now have 21 ETH on the hardfork chain and 21 ETC (ethereum classic is what they call it) on the hardfork opposing chain. Besides there are light clients that don't require the entire chain to be stored on disk, there are even some that run entirely in your browser like https://www.myetherwallet.com https://www.myetherwallet.com Now if you want to interact with the hardfork opposing chain things gets a bit more difficult because it doesn't have much dev support and as far as I know there are no light clients supporting it.
- antonios 10y agoThe author of the article should bother to read the first two lines of the official Ethereum page: > Build unstoppable applications > Ethereum is a decentralized platform that runs smart contracts: applications that run exactly as programmed without any possibility of downtime, censorship, fraud or third party interference. One should add at the end: "...unless the developers are heavily invested in a contract, in which case they can perform an Ethereum hard fork to take back their investment in case it goes awry. You know, conflict of interest and all that." Because that is exactly what happened here.
- compil3r 10y agoNot immutable but mutable.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- bonobo3000 10y agoI'm not totally sure how a blockchain works so please correct me if im wrong - for a hard fork to happen in Ethereum or Bitcoin, the majority of users have to "agree" by switching to thew new blockchain right? In that case, the Ethereum hard fork doesn't sound very controversial - even if the devs decided to hard fork for bad reasons later on, no one would be forced to adopt it. They would be "voting with their feet" by sticking to the old chain.
- anonx 10y agoThat's the case if there are dozens of different client implementations each maintained by a separate independent team. If there is just one client and no people qualified enough to fork it and maintain we end up with a centralization. The only team can make whatever changes they wish.
- DennisP 10y agoEthereum currently has eight implementations, each in a different language, some independent of the Foundation. At least the Go (official), C++, Rust, Python, Java, and Javascript clients are full implementations. The Rust version is especially nice; it's the fastest, and produced by an independent company run by one of Ethereum's early developers, who no longer works for the Foundation. (The Haskell implementation has fallen behind, and the Ruby one is pretty new, I'm not sure of its status.) It's relatively easy to make an independent client because there's an actual spec and a test suite.
- HairyGing3r 10y agoWhile the author is on the right track explaining what has become out of Ethereum, the Ethereum guys raised money to build a system by crowdfunding a trustless global immutable computer. Not a USD public blockchain.
- compil3r 10y agoin a system where the mining business is private and speculative, it might not be alright to hold mining farms/pools morally or legally accountable.
- arisAlexis 10y agoIn this case adaptability equals centralization
- skylan_q 10y agoAdaptability? If "adaptability" comes down to a popularity contest, this probably isn't a viable/stable/ethical currency. Gold has had a long history of success and it wasn't able to undergo a hard fork. The fiat currency that we live with now has legitimacy due to the fact that you can generally expect its value tomorrow to be the same as today. Imagine a fiat currency hard-fork and what that would do to the credibility of it?
- return0 10y agoBitcoiners are libertarian-minded while ethereumists are more democratically-minded. Same old debate under new disguise.
- elmigranto 10y agoAh… Classic case of decentralized system with no authority.
- bernardlunn 10y agoAt a business level, the mistake seems to have been not capping the amount to raise. $160m for a seed raise makes no sense. If they had capped at 10x less it would have been less of a magnet for thieves. As Willy Sutton said when asked why re robbed banks...