9 ms·
Water Out of the Tailpipe: A New Class of Electric Car Gains Traction
- IanDrake 10y agoI thought hydrogen had been debunked by now. Tesla had a great 'well to wheel' efficiency analysis post on their blog a few years back that killed any notion of a hydrogen economy.
- protomyth 10y agoThey quote Mr. Musk in the article, but it seems Toyota and Honda feel differently.
- ams6110 10y agoSurely Mr. Musk would not be biased in any way?
- rmason 10y agoHere in Michigan the Big 3 have promoted hydrogen for a long time. But other than small level fleet tests its never been a real option. The stories cycle back every couple of years. In fact it reminds me of PG's old submarine essay: http://www.paulgraham.com/submarine.html http://www.paulgraham.com/submarine.html
- jessriedel 10y agoGo easy on using "debunked" and "killed". "Discredited", "flawed", or "unpopular" would be less inflammatory and more accurate. http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/12/13/debunked-and-well-refuted/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/12/13/debunked-and-well-refut...
- hyperbovine 10y agoOf course, Tesla is totally impartial in this matter.
- transfire 10y agoElan might be biased, but so are the Big Energy companies who don't want to give up the control that a physical commodity grants them.
- analog31 10y agoHave they solved the problem of where hydrogen comes from? Last time I looked this up, the main process for making hydrogen is the shift reaction, which is hardly carbon neutral.
- ams6110 10y agoJust as electricity for EVs produced by coal or natural gas power plants is not carbon neutral.
- Terribledactyl 10y agoBut with both cases, something clean is at least possible. Solar/wind/stuff not invented yet, could be the source. Phase out the coal and you're done. When petroleum-based combustion happens in the car, you probably wont ever get carbon neutrality.
- whatshisface 10y agoWell, if we are talking about not-yet-invented stuff, we might also someday have feasible artificial hydrocarbons or corn-fuel farms run with electric combines. Nether one of those would require a fundamental change in car design.
- Terribledactyl 10y agoAll I meant there was that it can be changed and blended instantly, electricity is electricity. Look how long it's taken to change sulphur, lead, ethanol, etc in the us gas supply. And this still requires work for the existing fleet of cars.
- dredmorbius 10y agoSolar, wind, hydro, geothermal, biomass. Maybe nuclear. That's it. Don't go hunting for your something else, it's just wasting time. Nuclear, given lead times and more, is also quite possibly wasting time, though I'll allow some possibility it isn't. Long-term though, it's almost certainly highly problematic.
- sdkjfwiluf 10y agoHydrogen and hydrocarbon fuels are just sources of electrons. The beauty of a real electric car is the efficiency of going directly from stored electrons to power.
- jerkstate 10y agoRefueling time and storage equipment seems like major differences between hydrogen and battery. They both have slightly different use-cases that make different bets on future technology. Maybe one will win out or maybe both will play a role. I'm personally waiting for the Nucleon to come back.
- icebraining 10y agoRefueling time (...) seems like major differences between hydrogen and battery. Unless you do battery swapping, in which case they don't seem all that different: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H5V0vL3nnHY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H5V0vL3nnHY
- sdkjfwiluf 10y agoand transportation. Hydrogen is a very inefficient way to transport electrons compared to wires.
- jerkstate 10y agoI'm not an expert at any of this stuff and this math could very easily be wrong, but I just spent some time with Wolfram Alpha validating that claim. a 40,000 liter hydrogen truck can carry 425 gigajoules of liquid hydrogen; if it drives 500 miles, a diesel tractor trailer getting 5mpg would burn 100 gallons of diesel, that's 14 gigajoules of energy (now keep in mind that much hydrogen only weighs 3000kg - a typical load for a tractor trailer is 10000-20000kg) - if it was a fuel cell truck, it could be twice as efficient as an ICE so would only need 7 gigajoules. 7 gigajoules is 1.6% of the transported 425 gigajoules of energy. A state of the art HVDC transmission line loses 3.5% per 1000 km, so it seems like a hydrogen truck might actually be more efficient than wires.
- _ph_ 10y agoThe big piece left out of the discussion about hydrogen often is the energy costs for producing hydrogen. It is either produced by extracting hydrogen from natural gas which produces CO2, or by electrolysis from water. In both cases, the hydrogen has to be compressed up to 700 bars for transportation. In the hydrogen car, the fuel cell produces electricity to drive the car. The net result is, that the hydrogen car has perhaps a 30% efficiency of the electricity reaching the motor. A battery powered electrical car has about 90%. The bottom line is, for the same amount of primary energy, a pure electrical car gets 2-3x the range of a hydrogen car. And of course, that directly translates into the costs of driving. The article also gives some off number about electrical cars: they are not limited to 200 miles of driving - a Tesla does up to 300, and recharging at a supercharger station takes about 30-45 minutes. And, of course, in contrast to a hydrogen car, an electrical car can be recharged over night at home, so most trips do not require any recharging at all.
- walrus01 10y agoElectrolyzing water is so inefficient in terms of Watt hours consumed that it is really only practical (unsubsidized) if your electricity is 2 cents/kWh or less, which is cheaper than even the very lowest cost hydroelectric used by huge data centers in the dalles, OR and Grant and Douglas counties in WA, which have the record lowest industrial kWh rates.
- patall 10y agoNot entirely true. I am not sure about the US but in Germany we have in times of very strong wind negative electricity prices. And that is to some degree the beauty of hydrogen: you can store it relatively well for some time, so you do not need to produce it right when you are charging your battery but when electricity is the cheapest. It's not hydrogen is all better as some people here on HN seem to think the argument is, it's just that both battery powered vehicles and hydrogen powered vehicles both have some advantages over the other that might be very beneficial if used together.
- Roritharr 10y ago
- dredmorbius 10y agoThe two Achilles heels of fuel-cell automobiles have been the cost of the fuel cell itself, and sourcing the hydrogen needed to fuel it. Fuel cells typically use a lot of highly-expensive catalyst, with full costs on the order of a million dollars each. Odds are good the sales price of these vehicles (just under $60k) represents a small fraction of the manufactuer's actual costs. This is a test pilot for real-world experience. Hydrogen is the other problem, both in sourcing it and in distributing and dispensing it. Hydrogen is an energy carrier, not an energy source[1], but an energy carrier. You need some other source of energy to provide hydrogen, usually via hydrolysis, or from some hydrogen feedstock, usually natural gas. In the case of hydrolysis, your problem is the energy cost of electrolysis, which costs you about 40% of the input energy. The bad news is you get much less hydrogen energy out than electrical energy in, the good news is that you can store the hydrogen, while electricity doesn't bank well. In the case of natural gas, you've got the sitation that your vehicle is still ultimately consuming fossil fuels, though methane (CH4) emits far less CO2 than petrol (about a C8H18) -- roughly half as much. Since you're pre-processing the methane into hydrogen, there's the option of sequestering the carbon for other uses. Hydrogen also has extensive problems with storage and handling -- it doesn't like to be contained, will literally leak out between the atoms of containers, embrittles metals, etc., etc. Another alternative, one I'm interested in, though 50 years of serious research[2] has yet to result in a working large-scale prototype, is Fischer-Tropsch fuel synthesis. Effectively it creates hydrocarbon fuels using electricity. The most promising model I'm aware of sources both hydrogen and carbon from seawater, hence seawater-based Fischer-Tropsch fuel synthesis. Penciling out the studies I'm aware of, it actually could scale up to current US and forseable global levels of production, without literally paving the world with solar panels and/or synthesis plants[3]. E.g., not patentently impossible. The fact that the research hasn't proceeded further makes me question its ultimate practicality. If, however, it is possible, then we end up with a fuel that is an exact chemical analog of existing hydrocarbon fuels, is infinitely miscable with them in the fuel processing, dispensing, and utilisation chain, and is carbon neutral. And if you're generating hydrogen, you're already about 90% of the way to creating synthetic hydrocarbon fuels which avoid most or all of hydrogen's storage, transport, dispensing, handling, embrittlement, and energy conversion issues. As I mentioned, I've looked into this in several posts, you might want to start with the historical overview here: https://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/28nqoz/electrical_fuel_synthesis_from_seawater_older/ https://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/28nqoz/electri... ________________________________ Notes: 1. Technically, so are petroleum, coal, and natural gas. Though the source energy was supplied hundreds of millions of years ago, on average, in the form of sunlight converted to plant matter. Given this, at the rate of roughly 5 million years of ancient primary production per year of current consumption, you could make a reasonable argument that the fully realised solar energy cost (what's called "emergy") of petroleum is about 5 million per single unit of energy delivered. At the very least, we're spending 5 million years of accumulation per year. Something you might want to reflect on. 2. Brookhaven National Lab, M.I.T., and the US Naval Research Lab. Generally serious outfits. 3. For a counterexample, see schemes for biofuels. At best, present US fuel consumption would require plausibility-stretching levels of development, if not quite literally multiples of total US landmass. E.g., quite patently and evidently batshit impossible.
- samcheng 10y agoOnce you start filling your electric car every night from a plug in your garage, the idea of (weekly?) driving to one of a handful of special hydrogen fueling stations is seriously unattractive. In fact, filling up the old gasoline car becomes annoying. This article definitely reads like a PR piece from an oil company (which is, after all, where the hydrogen comes from). The New York Times has a history of biased journalism against electric cars...
- semi-extrinsic 10y agoAs I've said before, going all-in on EVs are a non-starter in some areas (esp. Japan) because they can't produce enough electricity locally, and they can't import it from a trusted ally. Hydrogen, OTOH, can be shipped over long distances.
- samcheng 10y agoI've never seen a hydrogen tanker. Have you? At that point, you might as well ship LNG or refined gasoline.
- patall 10y agoI honestly think you should rethink this, I do not think the article is biased and clearly states that hydrogen is not cheap. And as soon as we are getting fully self-driving cars, the hydrogen vehicle can drive to the fuelling station on its own and refill themself, so where is your problem there? They do not solve all the problems but so do electric vehicles. A combination of both might be far better. Or in your words: Your comment definitely reads like a opinion piece from someone who has invested to much in Tesla stocks and now fears of losing some of his investment. People on HN have a history of hyping electric cars ... ;)
- hueving 10y agoYour comment describes an environment that doesn't exist (unmanned self-driving cars, self-refueling, cheaper hydrogen) all to get to parity with the convenience of plugging in your car at night when you get home. It's very reasonable to say in the current technology state, they are much worse.
- JumpCrisscross 10y ago> Battery electric vehicles are still limited to a maximum of about 200 miles of driving before a recharge is required, and charging up can take time — four hours or more in some cases. Batteries are also heavy, which presents challenges for powering larger vehicles like trucks or SUVs. I had not considered the weight disadvantage of Li-on. Perhaps we'll have two technologies side by side: batteries for smaller, more centrally-located vehicles and hydrogen for larger and more remote ones. The energy-intensity of enriching, packaging and distributing hydrogen looks less daunting in a duck-curve [1] characterised solar future. One could simply generate hydrogen when rates drop below a threshold. [1] https://www.caiso.com/Documents/FlexibleResourcesHelpRenewables_FastFacts.pdf https://www.caiso.com/Documents/FlexibleResourcesHelpRenewab...
- _ph_ 10y agoFirst of all, one needs to see how much weight a hydrogen based solution could save at all. With a fuel cell vehicle, you still need a battery to power the car (the fuel cell cannot handle the peak powers, it can only recharge the battery at a constat rate), you need a high pressure container for the hydrogen and of course the fuel cell itself. So this does not leave much weight advantage vs. a pure battery vehicle. And just a couple of days ago Elon Musk announced that Tesla would introduce battery powered Trucks and Semis even. Seems he thinks that the weight is not a big problem.
- spditner 10y agoUsing Aluminum-air batteries as a secondary source in lithium ion cars for longer range would likely be a good alternative. Swap out at your convenience. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aluminium–air_battery https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aluminium–air_battery
- brightball 10y agoI've read that compressed natural gas is a good alternative for trucks.
- revelation 10y agoWeight is practically immaterial, the majority of energy required to drive is in pushing air out of the way, drag.
- zokier 10y agoOne of the issues with hydrogen power that you can't use regenerative braking as easily. Of course you could run a hydrogen/battery hybrid system, but its not obvious that hydrogen would really be that beneficial in that configuration.
- greedo 10y agoAren't most of the planned hydrogen vehicles hybrids? Combusting hydrogen won't be a lot of fun...
- jessaustin 10y agoMr. Manning now has enough fueling options in Southern California to cover his 45-mile commute to Playa Vista with little anxiety. Wow!
- transfire 10y agoI have always hated parking meters and felt in most cases it was just another way for cities to milk the tax payers for more money. But parking meters start to make real sense in an EV world. Instead of just buying time, the meters could have a plug so you can buy electricity and recharge the car too.