4 ms·
Is the author obligated to fix the broken code? If they aren't willing to fix it, would you prefer they said nothing and left everyone using insecure crypto?
by StavrosK 10y ago
Is the author obligated to fix the broken code? If they aren't willing to fix it, would you prefer they said nothing and left everyone using insecure crypto?
- kdbuck 10y agoDefinitely not. That's why I said it I think it's great that this stuff is brought to the surface. I can see how what I wrote isn't entirely clear though. What I am trying to say is that it would be nice if the message also aimed at encouraging contribution to open source software as well. It seems healthier to OSS as a whole to encourage improvement rather than abandonment.
- StavrosK 10y agoOh, yes, I agree with you. My sibling comment seems to suggest that Magento isn't actually OSS, so maybe that's the reason?
- kdbuck 10y agoIt definitely is open source insofar as it being a public repository that accepts contributions. However, the disclaimer at the top of the repo does seem to suggest that free offerings might be scooped up and put to other uses... I can see where the degree of "open sourceness" might be questioned in a case like this. I will re-iterate that I am willing to accept that there might be other politics at play here.
- StavrosK 10y agoOpen source has a specific definition, though. I think what Magento does is called "source available" or similar.
- aioprisan 10y agoThere is simply no way that realistically a third party contributor will rewrite a core part of a platform product for a company that generally does not accept such work, and has an enterprise version of the software that really gets all the goodies instead, which is where their focus is.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]