2 ms·
> This sort of attack on the Tor network by large groups of malicious nodes is inevitable in a borderless community where there is no procedure for vetting or I
by pdimitar 10y ago
> This sort of attack on the Tor network by large groups of malicious nodes is inevitable in a borderless community where there is no procedure for vetting or ID verifying new node operators. Tor assumes ideological loyalty from its node operators, that's a fundamental security assumption, but at the same time, a part of the Tor ideology is that there's no vetting procedure for nodes, nor are there any real rules for running them beyond a few trivial ones, and anyway without the former there's no way to enforce the latter. Tor is built on a giant contradiction, essentially.
Yep, exactly. How exactly do you build a strong anonymizing service all the while assuming benevolent nodes? Doesn't make any sense to me.
Too much naivete in the programming profession, I feel. It makes for pretty hilarious fails periodically.
EDIT: For the downvoters: I apologize if the language is too blunt. But those of us who aren't actively developing Tor have the benefit of being slightly more objective towards it -- that's how I feel. I might be harsh by expressing it, in which case I am sorry; I don't aim to be ungrateful, only skeptical of its current technical design philosophy.