4 ms·
Smolin's career seems to basically be entirely comprised of telling the only people who are creating successful theories that their theories can't be right, bec
by empath75 10y ago
Smolin's career seems to basically be entirely comprised of telling the only people who are creating successful theories that their theories can't be right, because he doesn't like the way they make him feel.
- dmreedy 10y agoA hunch can be a powerful thing; sometimes, it's the symptom of a nascent theory that hasn't hit the requisite critical model mass to attain that self-sustaining "eureka" moment in the brain yet. Of course, this validates truthers as well...
- mark_edward 10y agoOr it's just nonsense like most hunches. I hope Smolin keeps on trucking but hunch based contrarianism isn't actually a good indicator of truth.
- maxharris 10y agoHave you read Smolin's Time Reborn? I've just finished it, and while I don't agree with certain aspects of some of his ideas, I found it quite interesting and valuable.
- johncolanduoni 10y agoThe parts of Smolin's career that are easily integrated into a pop science article are entirely comprised of that, but his actual work in physics that doesn't fit into a soundbite does not. He didn't get his position at the Perimeter Institute by talking about how theories make him feel. Just like pop physics tends to distort people's perception of the field as a whole (e.g. giving the impression that 90% of theoretical physics is string theory) it also makes researchers' body of work look very different than it is.