3 ms·
If you're thinking about desktop apps, then one way to do it is simply ship a Java app that embeds WebKit (if you insist on using HTML even when a real widget t
by mike_hearn 10y ago
If you're thinking about desktop apps, then one way to do it is simply ship a Java app that embeds WebKit (if you insist on using HTML even when a real widget toolkit is available). There is a Java Tor client available that can be embedded called Orchid, and then binding Orchid through to the Javascript world is not very difficult. It'd be a weird way to do things though. May as well just ship all needed data files and resources in the app itself.
On the wider issue, I don't know if Tor is really doing such a great job of helping people in censoring states. Whenever I hear about Chinese people crossing the firewall it's always with VPNs and never Tor, which is thoroughly blocked for a long time now. One of the theories of Tor was that if there was lots of legitimate usage, it'd be harder to filter out Tor traffic ("anonymity loves company" they call it), but that goal was clearly better achieved using VPNs which impose minimal performance costs and has left Tor itself largely isolated.
This sort of attack on the Tor network by large groups of malicious nodes is inevitable in a borderless community where there is no procedure for vetting or ID verifying new node operators. Tor assumes ideological loyalty from its node operators, that's a fundamental security assumption, but at the same time, a part of the Tor ideology is that there's no vetting procedure for nodes, nor are there any real rules for running them beyond a few trivial ones, and anyway without the former there's no way to enforce the latter. Tor is built on a giant contradiction, essentially.
Of course that's not a problem unique to Tor. All communities that make majority trust assumptions without any way to control group membership have that problem. Bitcoin has suffered from this too, as has the British Labour party (which recently changed its rules to allow anyone to become a member by paying just £3, a move which immediately led to Corbyn and may yet lead to ~all existing MPs being fired and replaced by hard-left zealots).
- pdimitar 10y ago> This sort of attack on the Tor network by large groups of malicious nodes is inevitable in a borderless community where there is no procedure for vetting or ID verifying new node operators. Tor assumes ideological loyalty from its node operators, that's a fundamental security assumption, but at the same time, a part of the Tor ideology is that there's no vetting procedure for nodes, nor are there any real rules for running them beyond a few trivial ones, and anyway without the former there's no way to enforce the latter. Tor is built on a giant contradiction, essentially. Yep, exactly. How exactly do you build a strong anonymizing service all the while assuming benevolent nodes? Doesn't make any sense to me. Too much naivete in the programming profession, I feel. It makes for pretty hilarious fails periodically. EDIT: For the downvoters: I apologize if the language is too blunt. But those of us who aren't actively developing Tor have the benefit of being slightly more objective towards it -- that's how I feel. I might be harsh by expressing it, in which case I am sorry; I don't aim to be ungrateful, only skeptical of its current technical design philosophy.