3 ms·
Is there an alternative to national government intervention? Local intervention can't work - heavy industry will just move to a local jurisdiction that doesn't
by nl 10y ago
Is there an alternative to national government intervention?
Local intervention can't work - heavy industry will just move to a local jurisdiction that doesn't have those interventions.
Even if you accept that nuclear is safe (which isn't as settled as many on HN seem to think!) there is still a pretty significant problem with nuclear proliferation.
The only alternative I can see is massive technological change to develop much, much more energy efficient industrial systems which are much, much cheaper than the existing systems. That would mean it was uneconomic to compete with them. But.. hoping for magic is a problematic solution.
While we are hoping for magic, maybe someone will develop a cheap, small, workable fusion reactor. That would be nice.
- jwatte 10y agoWe already have the more efficient technologies; the main resistance is those benefiting from the status quo, who have the most money/power.
- nl 10y agoWe already have the more efficient technologies; the main resistance is those benefiting from the status quo, who have the most money/power. This is wrong on many levels. Firstly, I said "much, much more efficient AND much, much cheaper". Both need to be true in order to combat the high costs of setting up an industrial production facility. Secondly, I don't think either of these things are met. What are these more efficient and cheaper technologies for - say - producing cars, or plastic toys, or glass, or.. something. Thirdly, these people benefiting from the status quo in industrial production.. which status quo is that exactly? The one where production moved to Mexico from the US 15 years ago? Or the one where it moved to factories in China? Or the current one where Chinese factory workers are losing jobs to increased automation? Note that I'm not saying that the same people aren't keeping the money and power. I'm saying that they don't care about the place or means of production. They'll be just as happy to make money from cheap, efficient production as from expensive, polluting production.