7 ms·
The biggest downside to the NSA revelations is how quickly people accept conspiracy theories. Wikileaks just released a big email dump. People looked at it wit
by nl 10y ago
The biggest downside to the NSA revelations is how quickly people accept conspiracy theories.
Wikileaks just released a big email dump. People looked at it with Google Chrome, and it detected malware in the archive. That blacklisted the site it was downloaded from.
There is no big "Google is protecting the Democrats and hates Wikileaks". Wikileaks was serving malware, and Google detected it.
- gkoberger 10y agoReally? The takeaway I got from the NSA revelations was that it's now completely reasonable to assume that Google/FB/Twitter/etc are working directly with the government or politicians. Twitter removed #DNCLeaks right while it was the top trending topic today. Reddit paid staff has been suspending people who talk about Correct The Record or the DNC leaks. Facebook admitted to filtering certain topics due to political bias. Google just took down Wikileaks links. And while all of this is happening, there's not a single mention of the DNC leaks on CNN, MSNBC, Politico, etc. You're right, this probably was just a mistake... but is it wrong to question it? Everything I've learned from the NSA leaks and the DNC leaks shows that the media, politicians, the intelligence community, banks, large tech companies, etc are all working together against the public.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- nl 10y agoThe alternative interpretation is that the #DNCLeaks don't seem very interesting. I don't know why Twitter removed it (assuming that did happen), but to me it looks like most of the same people tweeting about are also tweeting about #Munich and or Tim Kaine, both of which are trending. If I was building a trends algorithm I'd try to aim for diversity of sources of trends. I have no idea about Reddit. The first search result I got for "Correct the Record Reddit" was a Reddit post about some paid social media campaign by a Clinton Super PAC. The explanation for Wikileaks is pretty clearly correct, and Google no longer is marking it as dangerous. Not saying that's happening here Well then what on earth are you saying? Vaguely insinuating bad behaviour is pretty easy, especially if you then say that isn't what you are doing. Like I said - it is easy to accept conspiracy theories. They are easy explanations, but usually the truth is complex and involves multiple subtle explanations which are much harder to think about.
- gkoberger 10y agoI'm not saying this particular theory is true. It's probably a mistake. I'm just saying that it's completely reasonable to be suspicious and ask questions, however, given that we have definitive proof that Google is known to work with the government.
- nl 10y ago"Work with government" means lots of things. The NSA leaks proved that the NSA hacked Google's network infrastructure. That isn't exactly "working with the government". There are other things where Google does work with the US and other governments. I believe they pass Flu Trends data to the CDC for example.... And which government branch do you think that Google is working with here? The #DNCLeaks thing is a anti-Hillary story, promoted mostly by bitter Bernie Sanders promoters. There are some Trump supporters jumping on too, but they seem a minority. It's inside-baseball for DNC wonks. I could see an argument that someone at Google is a Hillary Clinton supporter and therefore took it on themselves to take it down. That would be a dumb thing to do, but at least would make sense. But which government branch would try to get Google to do it? The White House wouldn't be so stupid - it would leak in an instant. Some secret three-letter agency? Why would they care? Some other department?
- gkoberger 10y agoYou can't call something an "anti-Hillary story" if it's an uneditorialized dump of emails. Of course it's mostly Bernie supporters pushing it: the leaks show the DNC worked against Bernie while colluding with Hillary's camp. Hillary and her supporters won't talk about it because it favors them, the DNC won't because they violated bylaws requiring impartiality, and the media won't report because the leak shows they've been taking orders from the DNC.
- nl 10y agoYou can't call something an "anti-Hillary story" if it's an uneditorialized dump of emails. Of course it's mostly Bernie supporters pushing it: the leaks show the DNC worked against Bernie while colluding with Hillary's camp. I think we mostly agree here? By the "#DNCLeak story" I mean the analysis of the emails as well as the leak itself - that's what is happening under that hashtag. the media won't report because the leak shows they've been taking orders from the DNC. The only thing I've seen on this is the "Chuck, this must stop" email. It's pretty clear that was a wish, not an order (otherwise why the follow up call). Anyone who's watched any political drama on TV has seen how often politicians offices call journalists to complain - I don't see much different here? Also, the media is reporting the leaks, pretty heavily. The NY Times[1] and CNN[2] amongst plenty of others both have major stories. I think I agree with everything else you say. (If it matters, I don't think Hillary is a great candidate, and wouldn't class myself as a supporter. I would have liked to see a much broader set of candidates in the Democratic race.) [1] http://www.nytimes.com/2016/07/23/us/politics/dnc-emails-sanders-clinton.html http://www.nytimes.com/2016/07/23/us/politics/dnc-emails-san... [2] http://edition.cnn.com/2016/07/22/politics/dnc-wikileaks-emails/ http://edition.cnn.com/2016/07/22/politics/dnc-wikileaks-ema...
- Natsu 10y agoAnd on HN, the stories about it that were on the front page vanished pretty quickly. Of course, I think that might be due to political-story related 'gravity' at work. I didn't see dang or anyone else comment, though, and they normally do if they've done any sort of moderation.
- ihsw 10y agoHN mods will remove anything that isn't tangentially related to tech. In this case, since it's Google, it can stay.
- DanBC 10y agoThat's absolutely untrue. HN mods (dang especially) frequently talk about how HN is not just for tech. HN users flag political posts.
- headShrinker 10y agoFrom what I see on a daily basis, mods do a really good job of curating articles focused on so many different topics with an even slight tie-in to the tech industry. This is one of the more interesting link aggragate sites or even original content sites. As a vehement bernier I'm thankful that HN didn't turn in a Bernie or Clinton voice box. During some really heated but frivolous political debates, HN was my sanctuary.
- dang 10y agoIt's nice to see an HN user commenting about moderation transparency (also https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12148846 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12148846), but I feel obliged to let you know that the way it works is more complicated than this. We don't post comments about every sort of moderation—it would lead to too many comments and many more meta-style arguments, which would make HN worse. If you want more information you're welcome to ask us at hn@ycombinator.com.
- SixSigma 10y agoGoogle is a $0.5-$1m donator to the Clinton Foundation http://www.politico.com/blogs/media/2015/05/clinton-foundation-donors-include-dozens-of-media-organizations-individuals-207228 http://www.politico.com/blogs/media/2015/05/clinton-foundati...
- jug 10y agoI don't think Google are using this as part of a conspiracy. IIRC they have even labelled their own sites, and at some point they blocked The Pirate Bay but cleared it once bad ads were removed.
- ihsw 10y ago> Reddit paid staff has been suspending people who talk about Correct The Record or the DNC leaks. Only on default subs (which is essentially "the front page" of Reddit, a site which touts itself as "the front page of the internet") is this occurring. There is heated and lengthy discussion on Reddit but limited to pro-Trump and pro-Sanders areas.
- Canada 10y agoAny raw dump of email that includes publicly available mailboxes will contain malware. Lots of it. If you download the whole archive on a system running anti-virus it will be detected. The virus scanner would complain just the same if fed the GOP's emails. Why would any virus scanner not raise the alarm? How would it determine that this time the malware should get a pass because of the political nature of nearby data? The mailbox could contain the cure for cancer, the AV will still behave the same. The virus scanner isn't making a mistake. Wikileaks made the mistake by not scrubbing the irrelevant malware from the archive before posting it.
- cokernel 10y agoHere's a single mention of the DNC leaks on CNN: http://www.cnn.com/2016/07/22/politics/dnc-wikileaks-emails/ http://www.cnn.com/2016/07/22/politics/dnc-wikileaks-emails/ Here's a single mention of the DNC leaks on Politico: http://www.politico.com/story/2016/07/debbie-wasserman-schultz-jeff-weaver-226032 http://www.politico.com/story/2016/07/debbie-wasserman-schul... I couldn't in a brief search find a single mention of the DNC leaks on MSNBC specifically, but there's this from NBC: http://www.nbcnews.com/politics/2016-election/hacked-documents-allege-dnc-attack-plan-donald-trump-n593301 http://www.nbcnews.com/politics/2016-election/hacked-documen...
- colordrops 10y ago> There is no big "Google is protecting the Democrats and hates Wikileaks" . Yes there is, and it's not a conspiracy theory. It's fact: http://qz.com/520652/groundwork-eric-schmidt-startup-working-for-hillary-clinton-campaign/ http://qz.com/520652/groundwork-eric-schmidt-startup-working... http://www.newsweek.com/assange-google-not-what-it-seems-279447 http://www.newsweek.com/assange-google-not-what-it-seems-279...
- nl 10y agoOf course many at Google support the Democrat party. That's pretty well known. I assume there are plenty of Republicans too. Peter Thiel is an early investor in Facebook, and he spoke at the Trump convention. Marc Andreessen is well known as a (non-Trump!) conservative supporter. I don't see that any of these things prove anything except that people are political. Show me some evidence that "Google is protecting the Democrats and hates Wikileaks" - not just that people at Google are supporters of one of the two US political parties. That just means they live in the US. The Assange thing is different. He's saying that Google acts as an unofficial representative of the US Government, not as a Democratic party entity. I don't think he makes that case very well, but even if it is true it isn't the same thing.
- colordrops 10y agoDid you not read the first link? Eric Schmidt is not just "some people at google". edit: you should watch this as well: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PFxFRqNmXKg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PFxFRqNmXKg
- meowface 10y agoThe Democrat/Hillary thing is non-news in and of itself. I wouldn't bat an eye if a CEO of any other company did the exact same thing (as long as there weren't signs they were somehow exploiting the company's own reach to affect politics; there's no evidence of that for Schmidt). The actual cause for concern here is Schmidt's strange willingness to effectively act as some kind of sleeper agent for the State Department (per Assange's writings and the interview transcript). Or perhaps an intelligence agency; it seems fairly plausible he was asked to speak to Assange as a way of gathering intelligence. That's deeply concerning, and suggests Schmidt has a rather special relationship with the government. If he were no longer affiliated with Google/Alphabet, it'd still be shady yet not really violating any standards. But as CEO/chairman, it's a massive conflict of interest and suggests that the government likely was or is trying to exploit Google's leadership in some way. Not that I blame the government here. If I were the CIA or NSA or State Department, I'd be trying to get my tentacles around massively influential companies, too. I only blame Schmidt for going along with it to such a degree. After this knowledge is taken into account, Schmidt's involvement with the election seems a little weirder. There are 3 factors here: * An influential non-government civilian willing to do the State Department's dirty work, possibly at the behest of an intelligence agency * An influential non-government civilian willing to devote a lot of time, resources, and technology to getting the State Department head elected President * The chief executive of one of the world's largest companies Any combination of 2 of these things isn't that odd. But the fact that someone was 1) acting covertly for a government agency, 2) working hard to get an important person in that agency elected, also attempting to be covert in the process, 3) is the executive chairman of Alphabet... Even if the government isn't really doing anything malicious here, and Schmidt's involvement in these matters are all coincidental and his own ideas and purely due to his personal patriotism or love of the State Department and Hillary or whatever, it doesn't make it any less irresponsible to do all that while still acting as a powerful corporate executive. And even if that weren't so bad, it seems like something he is trying to really sweep under the rug as much as he can, which itself is very suspicious. In short, regardless of the motives or conspiracies or lack thereof, all of these revelations make Schmidt seem very untrustworthy. It doesn't necessarily make Google as a whole less trustworthy, but it absolutely could if more leaks come out, and it also casts suspicion on other Google execs.
- benevol 10y ago> The biggest downside to the NSA revelations is how quickly people accept conspiracy theories. Because what Snowden revealed IS a plot against the citizen.
- imaginenore 10y agoSo if I email malware with Gmail, should Google label Gmail as dangerous?
- nl 10y agoNo, but if you downloaded it from the Gmail website it would be possible. (Of course Gmail has the same malware detection so it wouldn't happen, but in theory..) Here's the design document[1]. I think the area you are interested in is "Threat Details Collection". [1] https://www.chromium.org/developers/design-documents/safebrowsing https://www.chromium.org/developers/design-documents/safebro...
- mamon 10y agoWikileaks itself is no angel. Have you ever wondered how they get the information they publish? The simple and most probable answer is: Julian Assagne is a Russian agent, working with GRU. That's also the reason why he helped Snowden get assylium in Russia after the whole NSA surveilance thing.
- kushti 10y agoAny proofs you can provide links to?
- mamon 10y agoI based my claims mostly on this: https://20committee.com/2015/08/31/wikileaks-is-a-front-for-russian-intelligence/ https://20committee.com/2015/08/31/wikileaks-is-a-front-for-... https://20committee.com/2013/07/06/wikileaks-snowden-and-the-belarus-connection/ https://20committee.com/2013/07/06/wikileaks-snowden-and-the... As a former counteritelligence officer this guy seems to know what he's talking about. Unless of course he has his own agenda, but the facts presented are verifiable and pretty convincing.
- appleflaxen 10y agoWhich means, at worst, that the ad homonym attacks are factually correct. They are still irrelevant.
- appleflaxen 10y agoAll you have are allegations. All Assange has is evidence (in the form of leaked documents) Even if he were a proven state agent, I am happy to have information about how my representatives are working against my interests in a systematic way.
- artichokeheart 10y agoGot any links to the malware? Or are you just employing a classic subversion tactic
- phelix001 10y agoAnd the big upside to the NSA revelations is that people are starting to question their government and the corporatocracy that runs it. If you think Google is a 100% beneficent corporation, you gonna have a bad time.
- brute 10y agoRemember when over night VISA, MasterCard, PayPal, the Bank of America and Western Union refused to transfer money to Wikileaks? When Wikileaks mirrors were thrown off of Amazon servers? That was 2010/2011, 2½ years before Snowden. Not saying your explanation is wrong but it did not take Snowden to make such theories plausible.
- throw2016 10y agoThe biggest downside to the NSA revelations is how quickly people accept conspiracy theories. Where everyone else see upsides in public interest and greater transparency from leaks by Snowden, Manning, Drake and others at great personal cost to themselves you apparently are able to overlook all of that to see a downside. There is no big "Google is protecting the Democrats and hates Wikileaks". Wikileaks was serving malware, and Google detected it. And you are able to make this blanket statement with this incredible amount of confidence because? I am guessing only an official authorized response from Google can take this tone and be credible. Given what we know wouldn't the default logical position be one of scepticism and engaging credibly with the facts at hand or a blanket dismissal of scepticism as conpiracy theorists? As far as surveillance is concerned we are well beyond that stage and these kneejerk references to conspiracy theories and theorists seem tired, disingenious and incredibly out of touch.
- ksk 10y agoGoogle's properties like DoubleClick have served malware in the past. Could you point out times when they have been blocked? :)