2 ms·
> you can always dive into it; the black hole will then certainly exist for you, and in a finite time. Will it? All the other matter that is falling in also ti
by ars 10y ago
> you can always dive into it; the black hole will then certainly exist for you, and in a finite time.
Will it? All the other matter that is falling in also time dilated (relative to you) to infinity. So basically you will fall in alone, with nothing accompanying you, and no black hole will form.
> Consider the Bullet Cluster, which is two colliding galactic clusters.
I'm aware of that, but it's not conclusive. Imagine you never heard of dark matter - would that be the first place you jump to? Or would you imagine some very large object emitting hot gas, and moving, and not being slowed by the incoming gas.
Such an object could not be seen because of the intensely hot gas between it and us, but the gravity would show up in the gravity map. And there's your "dark", but ordinary, matter.
> If this redshift were gravitational, it would imply that our galaxy is at the top of a gravitational potential hill. This means that our place in the universe is very privileged, which is unlikely.
When we see a distant "star", it's actually an entire galaxy, or even galaxy cluster. So the gravitational mass of that entire object is redshifting the light, but only our little sun is blueshifting it on the other end.
The net result is redshift, as we see it.
It's not a coincidence that objects close to us are actually blueshifted.