4 ms·
If that's how you feel about it, I really think you should just enforce a blanket ban on political discussion on HN. My understanding was that political topics
by foldr 10y ago
If that's how you feel about it, I really think you should just enforce a blanket ban on political discussion on HN. My understanding was that political topics typically aren't permitted, and I suppose it's only because of Thiel that this one got to the front page.
The reason I say this is that political discussion has a moral urgency that technical and philosophical discussion typically lack. Civility in a political context implicitly says "I disagree with your view but it's one that should be taken seriously". I won't stir the pot by mentioning any extreme examples, but there are some political ideologies that do not deserve that level of respect. Of course, one may agree or disagree that this principle applies in the case of Trump -- I don't expect HN to take a position. But asking for maximal civility in this context is making a demand that's far less reasonable than it is outside a political context. Someone who sincerely believes that Trump is a dangerous bigot can't be expected to talk about him as if he's a serious candidate. And yet to refrain from commenting would leave his bigotry unchallenged.
So I'd say relax the interpretation of the rule slightly (it's not as if I was going completely off the rails), or make a firm decision about whether or not politics is off topic on HN. As it is, you're tending to give too much space to polite racist nonsense.
- dang 10y agoThat's very well put and a good example of the substantive kind of comment we're hoping for. I don't know that we have the ability to do what you're suggesting. First, it gets awfully tricky to define "politics". Second, people wouldn't listen. Third, there's a legitimate intersection between the core mandate of HN and some political stories, even if they nearly always bleed over. That's why the site guidelines have always declared most stories about politics to be off-topic, instead of all. In the end there are judgment calls to be made and no easy way to avoid them.
- meritt 10y agoThiel has substantial leverage over YC, and Thiel clearly is a very strong Trump supporter. So I'm not sure why you're surprised that anything which can be construed as anti-trump is being censored: YC supports Trump and will silence anyone who disagrees.
- dang 10y agoThat is so remarkably far from the truth that it feels like the work of an optimization algorithm. I don't know if Thiel has any leverage over YC, but if he does it must decay awfully quickly with distance, since I've never noticed any with respect to HN and I'm pretty sensitive about that. In fact the very notion strikes me as absurd, which I mention just as a data point. As for YC supporting Trump (or rather YC people; I don't imagine YC as an org would support anybody), the data is both prolific and exactly the opposite.
- meritt 10y agoI'd suggest pushing it up internally that Thiel should be removed as a partner. There's going to be a massive boycott/retaliation against Thiel and all of his investments. YC would do well to lead the way and disassociate themselves.
- dang 10y agoEven if I agreed with you and had any influence over it, it would not be in HN's interests to do that. The reason is that such forms of influence are reciprocal à la Newton's third law. To attempt to exercise such influence would be to invite it in return. I think everyone at/on HN and at YC would agree that it's best for HN to remain free of that.
- foldr 10y agoI share your frustration, but it's not that simple. Paul Graham does not support Trump. https://twitter.com/paulg/status/727902623597105153 https://twitter.com/paulg/status/727902623597105153
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]