12 ms·
Shows you just how much pent up demand there was for Nintendo to release games on mobile. Getting a huge first week download count is a lot easier when you hav
by jandrese 10y ago
Shows you just how much pent up demand there was for Nintendo to release games on mobile.
Getting a huge first week download count is a lot easier when you have literally decades of brand recognition. Being a free download certainly didn't hurt either.
It remains to be seen what the customer retention numbers look like. I saw some absolutely insane projections earlier this week about how Apple and Nintendo were going to make billions off of Pokemon Go. I don't see how they're going to sustain the current game as it gets fairly grindy and there isn't much to do once you've caught them all. Maybe some compelling new features will be added to keep players from getting bored? Direct peer to peer battles and possibly trading for example.
- mtrpcic 10y agoHonestly, those compelling new features need to come soon. I've only caught maybe 50% of the catalog, and it's already getting really grindy. It's a LOT harder to pull users back onto the platform once they've left than it is to keep them enticed while they're already on. I predict something like a 70% dropoff rate for users over the next 30 days unless they release something shiny and new[0] [0] Purely anecdotal, but based on multiple contacts already getting bored enough to uninstall
- losteric 10y agoI've already stopped playing... I was at level 23 and with well over 50% caught, and I still had no chance of winning local gyms. It's not engaging unless I can compete, and I wasn't willing to heavily grind on a casual game just to fight random people. I realized Pokemon Go was just a "background activity" for hanging out with friends... and I'd rather focus on the people. I'll jump back in as soon as they added trading and player vs player.
- sotojuan 10y agoIn my experience, people who hold down gyms are high schoolers or college students out for the summer. Hard to compete with them when they have free summers!
- AznHisoka 10y agoI loved the card game.. because it didn't matter if you had the most expensive cards, or grinded through levels. It all depended on strategy. The card game was what Pokemen Go should have emulated, not the Gameboy one.
- crazypyro 10y agoTo be fair, it didn't really emulate the gameboy one either. Very different gameplay.
- marcelluspye 10y agoWell, it doesn't really emulate the gameboy game either, so noone wins.
- Yhippa 10y agoI got discouraged by the inability to load the app and it crashing while I was trying to capture Pokemon I didn't have in my collection so I just uninstalled the game.
- Thlom 10y agoThis happened constantly to me as well, but not the last couple of days, but now it seems to crash when I "sleep" it by holding my phone upside down. Sometimes it doesn't wake up again and sometimes touch doesn't work after I wake it up. But it's not a huge inconvenience.
- 1439205948 10y agoDid you figure out how to dodge? The battling system is designed to make it fairly easy for a lower level set of pokemon to take over a gym, especially in a group. But you have to understand the dodging mechanic (swiping when an attack is signaled by a yellow flash).
- ultramancool 10y agoYeah, I've had little problem taking gyms by just doing repeated attacks - you just have to get the prestige down to zero, so 1 or 2 weaker people with enough revives can pretty much clean house. Holding the gyms is the hard part I think.
- Rayearth 10y agoWhen I first heard that multiple players can fight in the same gym battle instance, I got excited with the hope that there might be the conventional raid versus boss combat mechanics present - a main tank, positioning being important, taunts and so on. Of course gym battles are a lot more simple and fixing the many issues both combat-wise and in general take priority compared to adding such mechanics in.
- btown 10y agoIt's also very difficult to design for mobile devices - not due to processor or screen size, but due to unavoidable latency spikes on LTE. You'd essentially need an in-universe explanation to reconcile conflict resolution with user expectation. "But my move registered and I stunned that guy, but he still killed me!"
- fabrika 10y agoAn author of another real-world game, Cheapshot here. It's not an issue, LTE is fast enough. For multiplayer we take into account every bullet and sync dozens of players in real time.
- lnanek2 10y agoThat's strange. I'm not that player level and I still easily take down the highest gyms I've seen, which are level 6-7. As long as you can beat the weakest monster in the gym you can attack over and over until the prestige is low enough that there is only one monster in the gym. At that point it is easy to defeat even a 2,500CP Dragonite with 6 crappy Gobats since you have 6 shots to wear him down. The only limiting factor for taking down gyms for me is the number of potions I have. I usually only fight with half dead monsters so I can use revives instead, then I use potions for the one that I put in as a defender to conserve potions.
- jhchen 10y agoI think what the OP means by winning is keeping control of the gym, to your point exactly. I am also at level 23 and can take out pretty much any gym. But right when I walk out of range, someone half my level using either a full six roster or type advantage or both will boot me out. When the game came out I could maybe stay in control of a gym for a day but now it has not exceeded half an hour so I no longer try.
- jfoutz 10y agoThere is no keeping gyms. The game is seeing how many you can grab before you cash in your rewards. I think this is a nice change from ingress, where there was very little a low level player could do about a high level portal.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoIndeed. Few days ago I took over a gym on my way to work. I thought, hey, there's another gym right next to the office. I'm not going to be greedy, I'll just take that other one and cash in. I don't think I made it to the tram stop 5 minutes down the road before someone took that previous gym back...
- Keyframe 10y agoLevel 23? How many hours did you put in that?
- jfoutz 10y agoIn the city, it's not hard to find a spot with 2 lures going, and i'm sure you can find places with 3. Lucky eggs double the xp for any action. evolving nets 500, with the egg, 1000. You get a few lucky eggs as awards as you level. You can get around 60 evolutions while the lucky egg is active. Level 20 is sort of the "soft max". beyond that it's very expensive to progress further. It's 210,000 total XP for level 20. 435,000 total for level 23. Realistically, say 4 hours of catching at those lured sites buys you enough for the 60 evolutions, 60,000 xp. Let's go with 5 hours total. Perfect conditions, i think that comes out to 35 hours. I'd say double or perhaps triple that realistically. You have to go gather loot and stuff, which still grants XP, just at a slower rate. If the OP felt like it, running the whole time with lucky eggs would cut that down quite a bit, maybe half, and cost perhaps $20. I'm guessing around 80 hours without buying anything. A single person who's interested in it can pretty easily come up with 3 hours a day, and quite a few hours on the weekend. 30 hours seems pretty accessible. it's been out for 2 weeks or so now, so the OP is only a little on the high side. Perhaps not at all if they'd spent money on eggs. Of course, different people have different commitments. In a rural area, this would be impossible. Family, hobbies, a long commute would drastically reduce the time available. But if your hobby is video games, it's pretty easy to swap one for another with little effort.
- losteric 10y agoI took maybe a week to get to level 10 just casually playing walking to and from work... jumped the last 10 by grinding for one day and learning how to use the lucky eggs.
- TeMPOraL 10y ago> I realized Pokemon Go was just a "background activity" for hanging out with friends... and I'd rather focus on the people. There's something to that. I pass many players daily on my way to work, and I see them more often in groups (usually friends, sometimes couples) than alone. I've read somewhere recently that it's also turning into a way to ask someone out / handle a date, and personally I know one girl I could easily ask out by suggesting we go Pokemon hunting...
- gregpilling 10y agoI have heard that is a thing from a couple people now.
- antisthenes 10y agoIt is frankly, a bad game that doesn't have much going for it outside the "It's Pokemon" and giving you a reason to go outside. It is completely devoid of skill and rewards only having a higher level. The game isn't even pay-to-win or skill-to-win. It's win-to-win-to-win. If a person knows anything about the mechanics of the game they know casual players (and most adults) are simply not able to compete with lvl 25 school kids who can devote 6+ hrs a day to this game. I'd rather play games where I can beat opponents with skill, not grinding.
- danielvinson 10y agoThe grind honestly ends at about level 20 right now. Once you get a few good attackers, you will always be able to take any gym you want. The problem now is that holding gyms is impossible. I can never have more than 1 because the time it takes to drive to the nearest gym and capture it is less than the time it takes for somebody else to retake a gym.
- tl 10y agoGeography bias is a real problem. Some areas have several gyms in walking distance, others have miles in-between gyms.
- morganvachon 10y agoThat's basically how it is with the game's predecessor, Ingress. I'm lucky to live in an area dense with portals within a short drive. Some areas we've played in were so sparse there was no point in trying to capture, link, and field it.
- flatline 10y agoAlthough, length of link and area of field got you more points, so there was some inducement to find open or poorly defended portals that are off the beaten path, in hopes of holding a large field. Portals at mountain summits and the like are often hotly contested. Of course you still have to be in the general area, but there is absolutely no point to venturing to out of the way gyms in POGo.
- andrewfong 10y ago> I realized Pokemon Go was just a "background activity" for hanging out with friends... and I'd rather focus on the people. I wouldn't underestimate the value of a game mechanic for getting people to hang out. Many board games are basically just background activities, but there an excuse to get together. That said, if it is a background activity, it should be a background-able app -- i.e. notify me when certain Pokemon are close but otherwise leave me alone. I find it much less exhausting to have an app that requires my attention for only 15 minutes a day.
- derefr 10y agoAs far as I know, you can't access the GPS from an unfocused app on either iOS or Android. You can ask the OS to set up a geofence and then get called back when the user enters it, but if what you care about isn't so much where the user is as the fact that they're moving around, the OS doesn't have anything to offer you.
- eonwe 10y agoI would think that to be false based n sports trackers. Or do they work in some different manner that's not suitable here?
- christocracy 10y agoOn iOS, when location updates are engaged via CLLocationManager#startUpdatingLocation (assuming all required permissions are in-place, eg NSLocationAlwaysAuthorization, UIBackgroundModes), an iOS app will remain running in background indefinitely until #stopUpdatingLocation is executed, when iOS will immediately put the app to sleep.
- dmoy 10y agoI don't know if this is true, because my android phone helpfully pops up my grocery rewards card in a notification while I'm walking through the store with my phone locked and 0 apps open.
- gcb0 10y agowelcome to the pay to win era. also i bet most of what everyone read about this game at first was paid for; people downloaded based on those initial false articles, see the bugs, uninstall, or even play like you did and gave up when you notice the pay to win scheme. but regardless, the app already made it to the download top lists and now they're even getting real news coverage everywhere. this has nothing to do with people wanting Nintendo games on mobile. it's just a forced marketing fad like any other we always had since the 80s.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ben_jones 10y agoDo non-tech demographics delete unused apps or just let them pile up on their phone? It seems to me the biggest barrier to entry is getting people to go to an app store and make the initial download, in which case getting them to come back wouldn't be all that hard with a well marketed upgrade assuming the app is still there.
- kbenson 10y ago> It's a LOT harder to pull users back onto the platform once they've left than it is to keep them enticed while they're already on. Then again, I imagine it's a lot easier to pull prior users back than it is to find new ones, so in that respect, they're already ahead of everyone.
- serge2k 10y ago> Maybe some compelling new features will be added to keep players from getting bored? Direct peer to peer battles and possibly trading for example. You mean actually make it a pokemon game? That's crazy talk. (and I want to train up my team too)
- rjvir 10y agoPokemon Go has shattered every record (downloads, engagement, revenue, etc). It's not just downloads.
- mrb 10y ago"there isn't much to do once you've caught them all" This an extremely short-sighted comment. The developers created a digital world they can modify at will. They can add any number of items to collect, add mini games within the game, create new quests, etc. The possibilities are literally endless.
- bbctol 10y agoThey better add those things really, really soon, before the userbase gets bored. Because right now, there isn't much to do once you've caught them all.
- xigency 10y agoAnyone who quits after playing through the entire game in a week will be immediately crawling back as soon as the next new feature is released.
- Bjartr 10y agoYou've just described a decade of dead in the water MMOs. Which isn't to say you're wrong, just that very few manage to capitalize on the opportunity.
- Yhippa 10y agoHappened to me with Final Fantasy XIV. 2.0 was great but since 3.0 came out there really hasn't been much content to keep me hanging around. I let my sub lapse and have no real desire to get back in until I can log in for a few months and play a nice burst of content.
- markcerqueira 10y ago"Short-sighted" if you're describing a product as what it is today and not what it can be in the future? Having the ability to do something and doing it right now are two different things. As things stand, the statement "there isn't much to do once you've caught them all" is pretty on point, not short-sighted.
- 10y ago
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- hnal943 10y agoYou see this effect on Kickstarter also. The people who stand the best chance of funding large projects on kickstarter are people who have already proven their abilities outside of that format.
- stcredzero 10y agoPokémon Go is real genius in its combination of 3 elements that make it like lazing a stick of dynamite. 1) You can walk around in immersive play 2) There's opportunity for face to face interaction. 3) It's IP that a large part of the public cares about. Of these, it's #1 that's the most critical. It's like the world is the world of Pokemon and you're a character in it like Ash.
- bllguo 10y agoI disagree. The most critical part is #3. Were this not Pokemon hardly anyone would care. Don't know much about Ingress but didn't it have #1 and #2 already..?
- BryantD 10y agoYes, it did. The classic problem for geographically-based mobile games is critical mass. Ingress barely reaches the necessary threshold. Pokemon IP was critical here.
- TrevorJ 10y agoI don't know, ingress seems to be pretty active at least where I live.
- killerdhmo 10y agois it "most downloaded app in the first week" active? Definitely 3 IMHO
- BryantD 10y agoIt's active enough, but if you watch trends even one or two additional players in a big city is enough to make a significant difference in the overall team battles. Similarly, I used to live in San Francisco and my team recently hit 54 winning septicycles in a row -- that's over a year of weekly victories. While we're good players, we're not that good. It's problematic if one team can establish that degree of dominance in one of the most tech-oriented cities in the world. (Brooklyn had a similar streak the other way.) And since Ingress never monetized in the top couple of hundred apps, there's no way it is/was profitable.
- Al-Khwarizmi 10y agothere isn't much to do once you've caught them all True, but how long does it take to actually catch'em all? Because I've been playing for 10 days, at maybe 1-2 hours per day on average, I've caught 46 out of 151 pokémon, and it gradually gets harder and harder to catch new ones due to their different rarities. This means that it might take (me) 100-200 hours to catch'em all, which is not bad for a game and especially for a mobile game. And then, they have 5 more generations of Pokémon that they can add, to a total of 746. Plus trading, direct PvP, etc. The challenge is to fix the server issues, crashes and problems like the 3-step bug before too many users get annoyed and leave. But if they do that, I think their playerbase can last quite long.
- jandrese 10y agoYou probably won't catch about 1/4 of the pokemon, you'll evolve them. This is where hatching eggs is really important, because each egg gives you a lot more candy than catching wild versions of the same monsters, and you need a decent amount of candy to evolve the higher level ones. If they ever get trading working it would be a lot easier to fill out the last few holes in the roster.
- BryantD 10y agoAlthough the hugely successful casual mobile games are, in fact, extremely grindy. Candy Crush Saga is nothing but a grind at high levels, with minimally complex gameplay. The question isn't whether Pokemon Go will keep my interest. I'm not a typical mobile game consumer, and most of us here probably aren't. I think the core compulsion loop is a little bit thin without quite enough variety or randomness, but I'm not confident enough to make predictions.
- TrevorJ 10y agoThe Achilles heel (if there is one) is that the game is not something you can pick up and play whenever you happen to have a free moment. You have to be able to get up and go for a walk. Candy crush et al. can be played on the bus, in the restroom, in a meeting, on the couch, etc.
- jpindar 10y agoThat must depend on where you live. I've caught quite a few Pokemon from my couch.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoIn particular, it depends on your GPS quality and signal-proofness of your walls. From my home, I get weak enough reception that my character often runs circles around the neighbouring blocks, sometimes even getting close to the Pokéstop down the street... Also, bus is a perfect venue to play the game. Personally, half of my game activity is logged on a tram.
- thevibesman 10y ago> Also, bus is a perfect venue to play the game. When I accidentally get stuck on a bus in rush our, Pokémon Go makes that much more tolerable---if the servers aren't having rush hour trouble.
- BryantD 10y ago
- jedberg 10y agoThey need to add some aspect to the game that is playable at home. An 11 year old kid can't go out at night and catch Pokemon on their own, but they sure as heck can sit at home playing games. I'm an old man but I do most of my game playing from bed at night and in the morning (terrible habit I know) and so does my wife. I'd love to be able to add Pokemon to my daily games rotation but right now I can't.
- soneil 10y agoI think I’d disagree. There’s no shortage of games you can play at home; with or without friends, online or off. And it’ll have a much more difficult time competing with them, because it’s a surprisingly shallow game. But getting the same 11yo to spend his weekends in the park instead of on the couch .. that’s a turning point we’ve been missing for years.
- justinator 10y agoIs this the children's fault, or adult's? What I mean is, do children play ball sports, or skateboard, or just generally hang out on playscapes anymore? I remember fondly of just messing around in wooded areas and stinking like high heaven like pond scum upon my return.
- soneil 10y agoI suspect I'm the wrong person to answer that, having very little exposure to today's children. Over the span of my youth (I'm 34, so consider this 80s-90s) I lived the transition from building forts in the woods and rafts on the rivers (never went well, never stopped us trying) to arguing over who's turn it was on the playstation. Now I read articles about "free-range children" and parents getting in trouble for even letting them walk to school, and .. I realise I'm biased by my inputs (no-one writes articles saying "hey, nothing's changed"), but it seems like this is a different era. And damnit, I'm not old enough to call things eras yet. But it does seem the 'mobile' has been missing in 'mobile gaming'. We've built an entire industry on "always available gaming" or "something to stare at on the subway gaming", but it's taken 34yo men playing what's basically an easter-egg hunt, to remind us what 'mobile' actually means.
- tammer 10y agoDie-hard gamers will burn out quick but the minor attention investment required combined with the game-ification of recreational walking will keep games like this one popular for a very long time. We're not dealing with people sitting and staring at a screen anymore. The game changes with the weather.
- Mahn 10y ago> Shows you just how much pent up demand there was for Nintendo to release games on mobile. Does it? My impression is that there's a lot more people playing Pokemon Go than there are Pokemon fans. The IP no doubt helped, but I don't think that you can just release any Nintendo IP on mobile and instantly have the massive virality success of Pokemon Go. There's something more to it than that.
- dmoy 10y agoYea, count me as one. I have literally never played any Pokemon game before, and half-caught maybe one episode of some TV show featuring some comical evil cat villain thing. But, I'm catching pokemon on my walk to/from work (makes it less boring, and doesn't make it take any longer). My wife is now dragging me to the park every other day to run around in circles catching pokemon. I'd be interested to see some survey results on what percentage of people playing this are actually pokemon fans.
- stepanhruda 10y ago1. We know pokemon is a powerful phenomenon people get hooked onto. 2. You were previously not a fan of that phenomenon. 3. You now started liking that phenomenon. 4. The survey would show how many people started playing because they were hooked onto the phenomenon already.
- egypturnash 10y agoI'm not a fan of Pokemon but I'm playing it now and then just to see what this thing everyone's fascinated by is.
- Angostura 10y agoSame here. Early 50s - played a bit - find the whole thing quite interesting.
- furyofantares 10y agoI believe the high viral factor comes from going outside and seeing tons of people playing it and talking to strangers about it. That vitality has nothing to do with Pokemon specifically, but it's a factor that doesn't kick unless the game gets really big really quickly. And I think that initially enormous reception has to be largely credited to the IP.
- ben_jones 10y agoPokemon emulators have been available on mobile for a very long time. While I agree with most of what you're saying I think the phenomenon is more complex then just throwing something on the app store finally.
- ajmurmann 10y agoYes, especially since MiiTomo is out since months and nobody cared.
- Fiahil 10y agoBillions? Certainly not. The game's fad will be over at the end of summer. Nobody is going to stay outside in parks by -10C. Plus, the game is constantly crashing, draining battery, crashing again when the network goes down. It's been almost 3 weeks and they don't have fixed a single bug, and it's not like they're hard to reproduce or complex to understand where they come from. They literally didn't test their code before pushing it to the outside. It's not "Hard to scale" when you don't do things like "no caching client side", "mutate states concurrently without write ack". Come on, man.
- Noted 10y agoYou're definitely mistaken that they haven't fixed a single bug. Server stability has greatly improved and the number of times the game freezes while trying to catch pokemon has dropped significantly.
- downandout 10y agoYeah, no startup could ever duplicate this success. For HN purposes the fact that it's the most downloaded app in a week is sort of a meaningless data point. There's nothing instructive here that any other company on earth could use to have similar success.
- ajmurmann 10y agoThe fact that nobody here had even mentioned MiiTomo which came out on iOS months ago says a lot. It's not that just any Nintendo franchise is desired it's this particular game and franchise.