11 ms·
WeWork evicted a startup after it published a negative blog post about it
- minimaxir 10y agoThe referenced blog post was submitted to HN (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12124731 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12124731) and I asked where OP got the data. OP dodged the question.
- zzleeper 10y agoEven if you got the data legally, you might not want to disclose it, because i) It makes it seem more boring ("oh we just made an api call") ii) It opens the door to the other party saying that you violated the TOS (although they would still have done it; after all they are a 16bn firm that wants to defend itself)
- mrgoldenbrown 10y agoThey already admitted to using an undocumented WeWork API without asking permission, but simultaneously maintain that they somehow collected all the stats without spidering, scraping, or doing anything else that violated the ToS. (from the reuters article - "Zhen said he does not believe he violated the terms of his WeWork membership when he used an application programming interface, or API, that he and his Thinknum colleagues found on the WeWork network to locate and analyze WeWork membership data."
- marcoperaza 10y agoOnce potential legal wrongdoing is in the picture, and especially after accusations have been thrown around, everyone is in CYA-mode (cover your ass). Playing dumb is a great strategy. My favorite example is when Hillary was repeatedly asked by reporters about wiping her email servers (implying she destroyed evidence). She responded: "Like with a cloth or something?"
- leesalminen 10y agoI actually fell off the chair in laughter when I saw her say that.
- trhway 10y ago>"Like with a cloth or something?" 10 Tesla ferromagnetic cloth may just do it.
- drunken-serval 10y agoAnd this is news because...? If I wrote bad things about my landlord, there's a good chance I'm going to be kicked out as quickly as legally allowed. (Sooner, if the landlord doesn't care about legality.)
- delinka 10y agoWell, they also contend that the "lease" was violated. So there's that. If you continually poke about in doors around the apartment building that the landlord says you're not allowed to, there'a also a good chance you'll be asked to leave the premises.
- tptacek 10y agoWhat "lease"? WeWork is month-to-month.
- peterbonney 10y agoThe claim is that the tenant violated the WeWork terms of service (very much akin to a lease, albeit a short-term one) by scraping member data through the WeWork API.
- tptacek 10y agoYes, I understand that. I'm going further and saying that anyone working here should expect to lose their spot for any reason or no reason on a monthly --- meaning, effectively, instantaneous --- basis. I have a lot of negative things to say about WeWork as a business, and some netting-out-positive things to say about the particular West Loop WeWork space I'm working out of right now. But most of all: I'm here with my eyes open. There's also the concern of "is WeWork even going to exist in 6 months"?
- peterbonney 10y agoGot it - apologies for misunderstanding you. I thought you were suggesting the opposite (I.e. that there is nothing to violate because of the lack of a long-term lease). :)
- Disruptive_Dave 10y agoI'm in NYC and we negotiated a ridiculously low monthly rate as an introductory offer into one of their newer buildings (I'm talking more than half off what their initial offer was). It certainly made us question how well they are doing, particularly as they expand so rapidly. I'm also assuming they gave similar breaks to get other folks in the door, which I can only imagine increases churn when that initial 3-6 month deal concludes.
- Animats 10y agoUntil WeWork pulled this, few people knew WeWork was in trouble. Now everyone on HN does, which includes many WeWork investors and customers. Expect press coverage in a few days. Streisand effect, people. The coverup is worse than the problem.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- danpalmer 10y agoAre they definitely in trouble? There seems to be a lot of bias on both sides, and no clear indication either way?
- erlehmann_ 10y agoThey probably assume they are in trouble: “To launch a taboo, a group has to be poised halfway between weakness and power. A confident group doesn't need taboos to protect it.” http://www.paulgraham.com/say.html http://www.paulgraham.com/say.html
- Animats 10y agoLooks like it.[1] "An example The Information gives is that of a 20-year lease signed in New York’s financial district, on which WeWork got over a year of free rent. This free rent, however, was not spread out over the length of the lease, as is usually standard accounting practice. Instead, it was plugged straight into the current numbers, increasing near-term profits." WeWork leases real estate on long term leases and subleases it on short-term ones. If occupancy drops, they're in big trouble, caught between declining revenue and fixed lease costs. [1] http://www.businessinsider.com/weworks-financial-projections-may-be-hard-to-meet-2015-8 http://www.businessinsider.com/weworks-financial-projections...
- deedub 10y agoI haven't dug through their data or financials, but I work across the street from a wework and occasionally I go over and play some ping pong with friends. Their rent seems a little pricey, but it is ALWAYS packed with people in offices and at tables. I have multiple friends (3 or 4 different companies) that are all happily renting there. If other cities are anything like Portland I don't see how they are in trouble at all. Im actually glad wework has terms of service like this and gave them an 30 minute eviction notice.
- kitanata 10y agoYep. I was blacklisted from several tech events, for writing a mildly negative Facebook post about a local consulting company. This is becoming a real problem. Companies in the tech space are using blacklisting to silence any kind criticism or critique.
- B1FF_PSUVM 10y agoNo, no, everything is fine, it's not the gummint, so your getting squashed like a bug is perfectly alright. It's just consequences, man up, they even have a xkcd comic to back it up. Really. (Unless the shoe is on the other foot. Then it's completely different, and something must be done.)
- Twirrim 10y agoIt's completely their prerogative to do so.
- happyslobro 10y agoIt is harmful for any stakeholders but the target to tolerate this behaviour. Outing the coverup on HN is entirely appropriate, imo.
- unethical_ban 10y agoAnd as usual, that doesn't make it right. - x is doing something bad - x is allowed to do that - that doesn't make it right The HN comment circle of life
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- wpietri 10y agoAgreed. This patterns makes me crazy. If I say, "This use of power is immoral," I read the response of "but they have that power" one of two ways: Obvious tautology, and therefore useless. Or contradiction of my claim of immorality, which basically is an assertion that might makes right.
- japaw 10y agoTo be fear, they did not just publish a negative blog post about WeWork as the title may suggest, but somehow obtained proprietary data WeWork probably sees as a trade secret. Many companies will revoke your access then.
- michaelbuckbee 10y agoIt's still proprietary, but if you publish the data via your API is it reasonable to expect people to not chart it and draw conclusions? Where's the line between "scraping" (prohibited) and reading (allowed) of the API data?
- japaw 10y agoAs I understand it is currently unknown where the author got the data. If WeWorks published this in a publicly available API it is of course reasonable to chart it, but if the author somehow misuses the access he got as a tenant there, this is not (in my view) just an issue about the author publishing a negative blog post as the title indicates.
- pm90 10y agoIANAL but you can be in trouble even if the data is openly available but the party managing the data deems it restricted in any way. I believe this is the reason security researchers get in trouble: they access data that is considered restricted and get prosecuted for "stealing" it. I think the logic to that is something akin to: its illegal for you to take my car even if I leave it unlocked with the keys in it.
- nostrademons 10y agoThe company has to communicate that the data is restricted, they can't just deem it restricted after the fact. Usually when companies or individuals (eg. 3Taps & Aaron Swartz) have gotten in trouble under the CFAA, it's been because they've been served a C&D or IP-blocked and then persist in accessing the data, which the courts have upheld as "knowingly and intentionally accessing a computer without authorization". In this case, WeWork is within their rights to terminate ThinkNum's membership for the ToS violation, but there's no legal case unless ThinkNum persists in scraping WeWork's data after the termination, or there's evidence that ThinkNum knew that the API was restricted at the time they accessed it. Hence the founder's repeated insistences that he did nothing wrong, and coyness in discussing the source of the data.
- brianbreslin 10y agoI am not sure how good they are at scouting locations or predicting market demand. The one I'm in on Miami Beach (why they picked this location to start is beyond my imagination) is maybe 50% full, and 2 more locations are either just opened or coming open soon as well.
- skyrw 10y agoPart of what they are doing is using their funding and power to make a massive real estate land grab at very low rates for long lease terms. I believe they are gambling that in 5-10 years the market demand will swell to accommodate some of their lower value areas.
- Yhippa 10y agoI'm not a startup founder but my take is that companies will grow to a certain size as they progress from (hopefully) smaller space to bigger space at a co-lo space. Once they hit a certain size they either fold or end up moving to a bigger space as it no longer makes sense to pay the high price of co-lo spaces if you are in high growth mode. Am I way off the mark?
- swingbridge 10y agoClassic Streisand effect. It also wasn't terribly smart to take "proprietary" customer data and make it available to others via an API. If you say everything is sugar and roses but your own published data says there's trouble brewing, don't be surprised if people call you out!
- phonon 10y agoUmmm... "30 minutes to vacate"? Are they crazy? That's a 100% illegal eviction. RPAPL § 853 -- treble damages NYCAC § 26-521 - 529 -- misdemeanor, civil penalties
- tptacek 10y agoThat's housing law. These aren't standard residential leases. They're very clear about this when you sign up.
- phonon 10y agoThey might be very clear about it, but it doesn't mean anything. Just because you call a lease a "member agreement" or somesuch, doesn't mean it supersedes state and local laws meant to protect tenants.
- jacalata 10y agoIt doesn't supersede anything, it should be completely unrelated. Do you have any evidence that residential tenancy law applies to office leases or co-worker spaces?
- phonon 10y agoRPAPL § 853 Commercial Lease "Having thus substantiated that the value of its discarded records and personal property is $145,695.20 and that these records and property were discarded pursuant to a wrongful eviction as established by the complaint and, moreover, admitted by defendants according to the uncontroverted proof, plaintiff is entitled to recover treble damages of $437,085.60 under RPAPL § 853." http://law.justia.com/cases/federal/district-courts/FSupp/943/328/2376045/ http://law.justia.com/cases/federal/district-courts/FSupp/94... I was wrong about NYCAC § 26-521 - 529, that's only for dwellings.
- phonon 10y agoEven if the courts determine it's a license, and not a lease (I don't think WeWork has been tested yet), RPAPL § 853 applies, and now RPAPL § 713 (7) would as well. (10 days notice) https://commercialobserver.com/2013/11/the-dirt-dictionary-l-is-for-lease-or-maybe-its-a-license/ https://commercialobserver.com/2013/11/the-dirt-dictionary-l... Note WeWork usually gives you a designated, numbered, suite, which might confirm that it's a lease. In the above-- "One last “don’t” for a licensor looking to remain one in the eyes of the law: don’t designate a particular space for licensee’s exclusive use. "
- troncheadle 10y agoThe only thing I take away from this is that now this asshole who gained unauthorized access to an API to get an incomplete set of data to use as a basis for publishing slander is getting all this free marketing from his 'content marketing strategy' aka dumb personal blog. The Trump effect at it's finest.
- deedub 10y agoBAM. +1
- zekevermillion 10y agoEven if the post is totally accurate, a 6 % churn would not be that bad compared with corporate suites. The wework social network app is not that great either, so I don't think it is representative of anything if you have no followers there. Some people are social and make friends with their ww neighbors, some don't. More about personality. If ww wanted to they could introduce locations with different features or lower price to reduce churn at any time. They can basically dial-a-churn rate in this market.
- aurizon 10y agoCorrected 6% per year = a bit bigger than avaeage
- plorkyeran 10y agoThe article says 6% per year, not per month.
- aurizon 10y agoI corrected it
- walrus01 10y agoIf you're on a month to month lease and do anything to piss off your landlord (commercial real estate, not residential) they have no obligation to continue accepting your money. I don't see why they're surprised.
- birdmanjeremy 10y agoThey got evicted "effective immediately", not at the end of their 1 month term. This is not a refusal to renew, which I expect requires some amount of notice greater than 30 minutes.
- rhizome 10y agoIt's not a generic landlord-tenant relationship, and the "eviction," such as it is, is not based on tenant law.
- walrus01 10y agoWhat does a template wework lease look like?
- dragonwriter 10y ago> It's not a generic landlord-tenant relationship, and the "eviction," such as it is, is not based on tenant law. Generally, protections in law regarding tenancy in real property apply irrespective of the basis of the eviction (with specific exceptions written into the tenancy law.) While housing is more protected, generally, most jurisdictions have significant protections for commercial tenancy as well (because lacking such protections creates a poor environment for business.)
- jgalt212 10y agoIf Regus did this, they'd have zero total tenants. And I'm only kidding a little.
- us0r 10y agoHere is the post: https://medium.com/@justin.zhen/deep-dive-into-weworks-user-base-as-hundreds-of-members-cancel-6b17d3be1d8b#.v1coy1bo9 https://medium.com/@justin.zhen/deep-dive-into-weworks-user-... http://archive.is/ou72L http://archive.is/ou72L Don't forget they are also suing an employee for talking to reporters: http://www.businessinsider.com/wework-is-suing-an-ex-employee-for-talking-to-reporters-2016-7 http://www.businessinsider.com/wework-is-suing-an-ex-employe... I'd say this is a pretty clear case of where there's smoke.....
- jasonlotito 10y agoWhere do they provide a way to replicate their findings?
- eridius 10y agoIt's not suing an employee for talking to reporters. That doesn't make sense. It's suing an employee for stealing confidential information.
- mikeryan 10y agoIt's not suing an employee for talking to reporters. That doesn't make sense. Most company exits include an NDA clause which would prevent talking to reporters so the statement does make sense. Except you're totally right thats not what she's really being sued for.
- aurizon 10y agoThey are hypersesensitive because the churns rate is up. As it sits, the current churn rate is higher than the new intake rate = decline is in progress. To stop it = lower rents and or sales commissions but their rents are already high, how high are their commissions to space sellers (if any??) In any event, the Streisand effect is now well in force, as Animats suggested.
- nxc18 10y agoThere's a really disturbing trend/pattern in the hacking/tech community here that's worth pointing out: people are way too interested in laws and policies and testing the limits of each. Laws and policies don't define your success in interacting with others - people do. Laws and policies are just a guide to limit (not allow for) other people's reactions to you being a nuisance. You have no right claiming to be a victim if your only justification for what you've done is that it technically wasn't illegal and it was sort of allowed under policy that you've taken a very (conveniently) narrow interpretation of. Here's a simple test for whether you should post something online: * Does it enrich the world that I share (gasp) with other people? * Does it enrich or at least have a neutral effect on my 'business' partners (including business, government, the mail man, and every other person who can make my life painful)? * Does it enrich me enough to be worth my time? If the answer to any one of those things is 'no', step away from the keyboard and don't post. There are rare exceptions, but if you take the time to reflect and observe, you'll notice that a) the happy, successful people around you follow this rule and b) the dramatic, moody, perpetual victims of the world don't. Make your choice.
- erlehmann_ 10y agoWhy not try to be a nuisance? “News is something somebody doesn't want printed; all else is advertising.” - William Randolph Hearst
- nxc18 10y agoNuisance for societal gain can certainly be respectable and arguably an overall good; look at Edward Snowden for example. But that also supports the original point: he was a nuisance to the US government and they are doing everything they can within the limit of the law (and politics) to get their hands on him. Lucky for him Russia is going through an angsty phase and is granting him asylum for the moment. In this particular case of scraping and publishing the churn rate, no one really benefits. It was just one person/startup who felt like starting drama and didn't bother thinking about the consequences. Leave the drama to the TV networks and tabloids.
- 10y ago
- davebowker 10y agoThere's offices on Bishopsgate in London. I walk past there every now and again and it's been getting emptier and emptier.
- ddddbbbb 10y agoHave you ever known thinknum? Do you know how they treat employees? like wework treats them
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- paulsutter 10y agoMisleading title: these guys weren't kicked out for publishing a negative blog post, they were kicked out for sharing WeWork internal data publicly, which violates the terms under which they got the data. Here's the blog post: https://medium.com/@justin.zhen/deep-dive-into-weworks-user-base-as-hundreds-of-members-cancel-6b17d3be1d8b#.3xlld2phy https://medium.com/@justin.zhen/deep-dive-into-weworks-user-... (I flagged the article because the title is a lie at present)
- minimaxir 10y agoThe article title itself was very recently edited to include this information. (I cannot edit the HN title)
- hkmurakami 10y agoIt's particularly nauseating to take a screen short of their "internal proprietary social network". A sense of trust is one of the most difficult things to build within a gathering of peer companies like WeWork has tried to do, and one bad actor poisons the whole well.
- pm90 10y agoArchived version [0] as it seems like it was taken down. [0]: https://web.archive.org/web/20160722222224/https://medium.com/@justin.zhen/deep-dive-into-weworks-user-base-as-hundreds-of-members-cancel-6b17d3be1d8b https://web.archive.org/web/20160722222224/https://medium.co...
- cmdrfred 10y agoLoads briefly and then redirects to medium.com for me.
- joshstrange 10y agoYeah, medium posts do that when using the wayback machine. I normally just hit the browser stop button as soon as the text loads. You miss out on images but you can still read it.
- cocktailpeanuts 10y agoIt's sad that nowadays people do whatever they can to get attention and one of the best ways is to capitalize on other people's misfortunes. I just read through the original Medium post, and I can't really sympathize with any of you guys in this thread saying WeWork is the evil. This guy hacked into their private API (legal or not doesn't matter), and used that information to write a blog post, and at the bottom writes: "About Thinknum Thinknum indexes alternative web data for thousands of companies, capturing relevant information for financial analysts to use in their investment process. Thinknum has hundreds of institutional clients across hedge funds, investment banks and corporations." Basically here's how I see it: this guy wanted attention, so betrayed their business partner (WeWork) and used the private information to get traffic to his product. I can't imagine myself ever doing something like this. What did WeWork do to this guy that harmed him? Every company has difficult times. I'm sure WeWork guys wanted nothing more than to build an organization that helps these little guys, but if I were in their position I would feel extremely sad. They don't deserve to be thrown under the bus by someone they're in partnership with, whom they did nothing bad to.
- angryasian 10y ago> hacked into their private API an unpublished api is not the same thing. I think there needs to be more clarification on this, but if its just an unpublished api they've done nothing wrong.
- minimaxir 10y ago> its just an unpublished api they've done nothing wrong. Not correct. A published, documented API comes with instructions on how the API can use used, and how the data can be used. Do not assume that an unpublished/undocumented API is the same, especially when republishing the data.
- angryasian 10y ago>A published, documented API comes with instructions on how the API Agree and since it was undocumented there more than likely were no terms as to how it should be used.
- brooklyndude 10y agoWeWork was "Ok." Have moved on. Staff seems to turn over lots. Had some dealings with them over a deposit, thought it could have gone much better. Had a hard time finding basic account info. They just did not seem like a "mature" organization. But that was a year ago. Maybe things have changed. Overall, give them a "B." Now in a Non Profit space, WOW, totally different vibe for sure. A+ here. :-)