5 ms·
The Mandlebrot Monk
- maxdemarzi 17y agoWow...Now that is crazy. Add another to the list of where we could have be if religion and science could have co-existed peacefully.
- forinti 17y agoOops, that got posted a few days too early...
- RevRal 17y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Udo_of_Aachen http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Udo_of_Aachen Have a very happy un-April Fool's day.
- GFischer 17y agoI fell for it... :) By the way, over here in Spanish-speaking countries the equivalent to "April Fool's" is in December ("Día de los Inocentes" - see the "Other Prank days in the World" section http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/April_Fools%27_Day http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/April_Fools%27_Day ). That has caused me problems in the past :P (I totally believed and acted upon a prank, since I didn't expect April 1st to have any significance back then)
- camccann 17y agoPerhaps it is bad form to pick nits in an amusing bit of April Foolery, but as an interesting aside, with a better technique it would take nowhere near nine years to produce manually a 70 iteration 120x120 rendering of the M-set--by avoiding explicit calculation entirely! A geometric interpretation of the path taken by each point gives a simple, easily mechanized transformation, that could be implemented with a system of gears, levers, and other basic mechanisms, plausibly reducing the time necessary to a few seconds per iteration.
- jey 17y ago[citation needed] Er, I mean: [algorithm/schematic needed]
- camccann 17y agoApologies, don't have time to do a proper job of it right now, so here's a quick summary: Complex addition is basic Cartesian vector addition in the complex plane; complex multiplication is combined polar-coordinate rotation/scaling, by adding the two angles and multiplying the magnitudes. The Mandelbrot iteration formula is Z*Z+C, so there are only three transformations: double the angle, apply the scaling factor, and move the point by a fixed offset. For each point in the graph, fix the distance between it and the origin: that's C. Center a wheel of some sort at the origin, find the angular distance from the point to the positive real line, then rotate the wheel by that amount. The magnitude scaling is the trickiest part, since you're moving it either toward or away from the origin depending on whether it's greater or less than one, and the scaling factor is proportional to the magnitude itself; but I'm pretty sure there's some sort of multiplicative transformation that could be done with an appropriately-placed lever. So, take the aforementioned contraption, rotate the wheel, adjust the distance, then shift the point by the original offset. Repeat 70 times, or until the distance exceeds the machine's maximum. Mark the point appropriately, and pick a new one. The accuracy would be dubious near the boundary, of course, but it beats doing arithmetic... Maybe one of these days I'll draw up usable schematics for how it would work. Mechanical computation has a certain charm to it.
- pvg 17y ago
- arethuza 17y agoAnyone else think of Anathem when they read this? Although avout would probably calculate fractals by singing...
- Vivtek 17y agoMy hand's up, yes.
- viraptor 17y agoFor an April fools joke, it really seems interesting. It was a good read, even if not true. Reminds me of "the real rocket car" story - so full of really convincing details you start wondering if it is true or not.
- lukev 17y agoYou know those things that you just want to be true, because they would make the world so much more interesting? This is one of those things.
- lincolnq 17y agoThis is what tipped me off (due to its attractiveness -- making me think "wow, this fits TOO well"): Initially, Udo's aim was to devise a method for determining who would reach heaven. He assumed each person's soul was composed of independent parts he called "profanus" (profane) and "animi" (spiritual), and represented these parts by a pair of numbers. Then he devised rules for drawing and manipulating these number pairs. In effect, he devised the rules for complex arithmetic, the spiritual and profane parts corresponding to the real and imaginary numbers of modern mathematics.
- cjauvin 17y agoI would say reading this article was a good exercise in testing my critical thinking, because I could feel all the warning red lights flashing one by one while reading it: even though it would have been a marvelous discovery, I was really not ready to accept it without questioning it a bit further. An interesting hoax idea nevertheless!
- BearOfNH 17y agoFiction: stranger than truth.