4 ms·
>Similarly for the more rigorous checks of people coming from countries having known radical islamist ties I'm not going to touch the rest of your nonsense, bu
by foldr 10y ago
>Similarly for the more rigorous checks of people coming from countries having known radical islamist ties
I'm not going to touch the rest of your nonsense, but this is an utterly shameless attempt to rewrite history. You know perfectly well that Trump called on several occasions for a ban on all Muslims entering the US, regardless of origin. That is indefensible bigotry. I think you must know that it is indefensible because you tried to gloss over it.
- jazzyk 10y agoYou (and many other people) tend to omit one very important detail: he called for a temporary ban, "until we figure out what the hell is going on". This was said in context of the refugee crisis in Europe.
- foldr 10y agoSo temporary bigotry is ok then? If he'd really wanted a temporary ban (which would still, obviously, be indefensible), he'd have set out clear criteria for when it would end. Someone who casually throws out insane and bigoted policy proposals, without showing any evidence whatsoever of having seriously thought them through, is not fit to be President. I don't have much time for people who act as apologists for this kind of behavior and help to maintain the illusion that what Trump says is anywhere in the ballpark of actual political discourse. This is a crisis. Every time someone makes bogus arguments for taking Trump seriously as a political figure, we're edging closer to a disaster that could take decades to recover from. It's not fun and games at this point. History will judge us. And your pro-Trump comments will be on record forever.
- jazzyk 10y ago>It's not fun and games at this point. History will judge us. And your pro-Trump comments will be on record forever Wow. Take a deep breath and tone down your hysteria a bit: 1. How does adding context to a comment taken out of context makes me "pro-Trump"? 2. How is properly vetting immigrants, in particular from high-risk countries, bigotry?
- foldr 10y ago> How does adding context to a comment taken out of context makes me "pro-Trump"? Because you're apologising for his bigotry. The fact that the ban is (allegedly) temporary makes it no less bigoted and no more defensible. This is probably going to be quite a close election. Everyone should be speaking out against Trump, not trying to help him weasel out of taking responsibility for the awful things he's said. >How is properly vetting immigrants, in particular from high-risk countries, bigotry? What a disingenuous comment. I made it perfectly clear that I was talking about his proposal to ban all Muslims from entering the US. You and the OP would love to pretend that he never made that proposal, but he did.
- jazzyk 10y ago>"his proposal to ban all Muslims from entering the US" He asked that immigration from certain countries be temporarily halted, to introduce a proper vetting process. Your highly emotional reasoning (I am "apologising for his bigotry"?) makes me rest my case.
- foldr 10y agoI’m surprised that you’re making such a brazen attempt to rewrite history. He was recorded calling for a complete ban on all Muslims entering the US. Were you really not aware of this? You quoted his "what the hell is going on" words from this video clip, so I think you must have seen it, and I think you must have been aware of what he actually said. https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/video/2015/dec/08/donald-trump-calls-for-complete-ban-on-muslims-entering-the-us-video https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/video/2015/dec/08/donald...
- dang 10y agoWhen you find yourself impelled to enter a thread like this: > I'm not going to touch the rest of your nonsense, but this is an utterly shameless ... please don't. Nothing good can come of a discussion that begins by breaking the site guidelines outright. This is true regardless of how important the issue is or how right you are, indeed gets truer as those things are more the case, because you discredit your position by behaving this way. If it's correct, you ought to be able to show that without fulminating. We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12142296 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12142296 and marked it off-topic.
- foldr 10y agodang: If it is your policy to selectively tone police people who disagree with Donald Trump, then you have the right to do that as a moderator of this web site. But you should not pretend that you are doing something else.
- dang 10y agoThat's precisely what I'm not doing. You don't get to break the rules here just because you're anti-X, even when X is Trump. Following the site guidelines means posting civilly and substantively, or not at all. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html
- foldr 10y agoIf that's how you feel about it, I really think you should just enforce a blanket ban on political discussion on HN. My understanding was that political topics typically aren't permitted, and I suppose it's only because of Thiel that this one got to the front page. The reason I say this is that political discussion has a moral urgency that technical and philosophical discussion typically lack. Civility in a political context implicitly says "I disagree with your view but it's one that should be taken seriously". I won't stir the pot by mentioning any extreme examples, but there are some political ideologies that do not deserve that level of respect. Of course, one may agree or disagree that this principle applies in the case of Trump -- I don't expect HN to take a position. But asking for maximal civility in this context is making a demand that's far less reasonable than it is outside a political context. Someone who sincerely believes that Trump is a dangerous bigot can't be expected to talk about him as if he's a serious candidate. And yet to refrain from commenting would leave his bigotry unchallenged. So I'd say relax the interpretation of the rule slightly (it's not as if I was going completely off the rails), or make a firm decision about whether or not politics is off topic on HN. As it is, you're tending to give too much space to polite racist nonsense.