26 ms·
I agree my friend’s description is not the best. He was trying to make it clear and unambiguous, and he’s a smart guy, but he hadn’t practiced this before and I
by jacobolus 10y ago
I agree my friend’s description is not the best. He was trying to make it clear and unambiguous, and he’s a smart guy, but he hadn’t practiced this before and I’m sure he didn’t think all that deeply about it. It’s just not a priori obvious how to make a clear verbal description of a spatial relationship. A diagram of the same thing takes much less effort to construct.
I don’t think it’s possible to construct a textual description or mathematical formula of a collection of tatami patterns which takes less than 40–60 seconds per pattern to unpack into a clear mental image.
If I spend about 5–10 seconds looking at each of the 14 tatami mat diagrams in your picture, I’m confident I could reconstruct the patterns from memory a few minutes later. I can’t imagine doing the same without spending a significant amount of time on a textual explanation. Additionally, after examining an image with a bunch of tatami patterns for a couple minutes, I could probably tell you whether additional patterns satisfy the criteria to be acceptable or not, without doing any explicit analysis of those criteria. I’d have to think a lot harder if presented only with prose or formula descriptions.
- dredmorbius 10y agoMy point wasn't that images or a symbolic (non-language) expression cannot be clearer and more accessible than text. It was that the example text you'd presented was exceptionally bad. Yes, often a picture is the clearest way to express something -- I'd be better off showing you a blurry potato of the Mona Lisa than trying to describe it to you. At the same time, there are circumstances in which images aren't available. When two people are conversing without having a visual medium -- in the dark, one is blind, over a radio or phone. When the text itself is all you have: in an anthropological or forensic context. And in such cases, with effort and refinement, that text can often be quite clear. Which gets to the point: a diagram or symbolic notation is the result of effort and refinement. It's a reduction of a situation to its essential parts. It's also possible for such diagrams to be far other than clear or accurate. Look to ancient maps or images of animals or digrams of equipment or mechanisms, or even of the old-school maths notations that current notations have replaced. Albrecht Durer's illustration of a rhinoceros looks very little like a rhinoceros (though he was working from second-hand reports). It is a poor representation. An overly ornate diagram, chart, or illustration communicates poorly often because it seems to have little idea of what it wants to communciate. If you've ever read or heard Edward Tufte's exposition of visual presentation, he offers many examples, some old, some new, of both good and bad graphics. His own designs are so excellent because they reduce the topic to its very essence. To draw on a reasonably contemporary example, his comparison of what NASA had used to portray O-ring erosion, prior to the Challenger shuttle disaster, and what a simple plot of erosion depth vs. temperature offered. Which still leaves us with the question of whether or not any textual description of your tatami problem would be clearer than an image. I'm suspecting that one could get quite close.
- jacobolus 10y agoAt the point you’re citing Tufte, I’m pretty sure we essentially agree. Note, this is what I was responding to: “[...] people naturally communicate using language. In your head you may think in symbols and spatial relationships, but if you want to get a concept out of your head and into someone else's head you have to use language.”