6 ms·
My theory: Black holes don't exist (time dilation prevents them from forming in a finite time). Dark matter is gravitational potential energy. (i.e. the poten
by ars 10y ago
My theory:
Black holes don't exist (time dilation prevents them from forming in a finite time).
Dark matter is gravitational potential energy. (i.e. the potential energy of every star in a solar system falling into every other star, plus the energy of every galaxy falling into every other galaxy.)
Cosmological redshift is actually gravitational redshift. (So dark energy is not necessary as a concept.) There is a lot more gravity out there in my theory. Don't forget that the relative motion of galaxies is inferred from redshift - if the cause of the redshift is not velocity then galaxies are not moving in the way we currently think they are.
I wish I had the math to flesh these ideas out to see if they hold water.
- stouset 10y agoWhat leads you to believe that no experienced astrophysicists have serious considered any of these "obvious" theories? Because that's basically what you're suggesting.
- guard-of-terra 10y agoMaybe they did? I've asked a question like this and was confirmed that we can't observe black hole formation, only "collapsars", which are almost like black holes but without matter crossing event horizon. Looks like astrophysicists assume one thing and cosmologists another thing.
- InclinedPlane 10y agoI can tell you right now, they don't hold water. They do not fit observations, even a little.
- ars 10y agoCan you elaborate? People are downmodding me for having an idea and putting it out there for comment (is that really so bad?) But I really do just want to know if my ideas hold water or not, and if not why not. For example the time dilation on black holes fits every description of black holes I've ever seen. Gravitational potential energy of stars being significant makes sense to me - after all the farther from the center, the higher the "apparent" mass of the star (as seen in its orbit), which matches well with the potential energy also being higher when it's farther. Is it not enough maybe?
- InclinedPlane 10y agoOK, so, go read the wikipedia article on dark matter in its entirety (it's not that long) then come back. One of the reasons you're being downvoted is because it's fairly obvious you haven't done much due diligence. And just throwing out half-baked ideas may seem fun, but it's not particularly helpful. The biggest problem with your ideas is that we already have numerous lines of evidence that dark matter and regular matter can become separated, and that would seem to be something that directly challenges your hypothesis.
- kirrent 10y agoAn alternative criticism to the other comment. I actually don't really know what your sentences are trying to say. When you say, 'Black holes don't exist (time dilation prevents them from forming in a finite time)'. Do you mean that you think a singularity would form asymptotically slowly from an outside frame of reference as gravitational time dilation increased? That's the most generous construction I can give your statement and it's still ridiculous because the event horizon would exist anyway so the effect will be the same. I think the majority of people try to be generous and give the benefit of the doubt, but I'm a physics grad and even after a lot of thought I'm not sure what you're saying. It's hard to give informed criticism in that case but easy to downvote and move on.
- ars 10y ago> Do you mean that you think a singularity would form asymptotically slowly from an outside frame of reference as gravitational time dilation increased? Yes. > it's still ridiculous because the event horizon would exist anyway so the effect will be the same. How would exist? It would only form after infinite time - time dilates as a function of how close it is to a black hole (i.e. you don't have to already be a black hole to dilate time), reaching infinity as it forms the event horizon. > I think the majority of people try to be generous and give the benefit of the doubt, but I'm a physics grad and even after a lot of thought I'm not sure what you're saying. It's hard to give informed criticism in that case but easy to downvote and move on. Thanks for the reply. If I gain nothing else except an understanding of how a black hole can ever form the downvotes would be well worth it. As best as I can understand it can't form, yet everyone just seems to implicitly believe it can. The rest I just kind of threw out there to see what criticism I would get (none as of this writing, just some insults), but the black hole one really bothers me because that one is grounded in ordinary, orthodox, descriptions of black holes. Every description describes them as matter caught falling in infinitely slowly, yet simultaneously say matter actually falls in and somehow forms a black hole. It's a contradiction - I can't be the only person in the entire world to see that.
- vecter 10y agoI don't mean to be rude (so please don't be offended if my tone sounds overly negative online), but are you aware that your theories are incredibly crackpot in nature? I'm asking a sincere question, not trying to insult you. It's clear you have very little understanding of physics. That's totally fine and cool. The vast majority of people don't know anything meaningful about physics. You just make very bold claims that go against standard theoretical and experimental knowledge in the field. If I knew very little knowledge about a topic, be it physics or cooking or dog breeding, I would at least be very aware of that fact and probably not make claims on topics I'm uneducated about. Again, I'm not trying to be rude, just trying to understand how you feel comfortable making these bold claims when I believe you're aware that you know almost nothing about the topic.
- ars 10y ago> but are you aware that your theories are incredibly crackpot in nature? Yup. The difference is I'm looking for info, not assuming I'm right. > It's clear you have very little understanding of physics. Now, that, is an insult considering how long I studied it. I wish I did more, but my math wasn't good enough - to my constant sorrow. > make claims .. bold claims No claims! It's bad you read it that way. Rather unorthodox ideas, and looking for confirmations or refutations based on explanation, not appeal to authority. For example: How much energy does the gravitational potential energy of all the stars in a galaxy embody? A calculation of that would confirm of deny me easily. But I don't know how to do it. I was hoping to get a reply from someone who did.
- vecter 10y ago> Yup. The difference is I'm looking for info, not assuming I'm right. I can respect that.
- vixen99 10y agoBut certainly belittling. Why not just respond to the points made? Doubtless readers can draw their own conclusions as to the possible crackpot coefficient on a scale of 0 to 10.
- runeks 10y agoWhile we're throwing around ideas, how about this: Black holes do exist. They are simply the beginning of the inverse of what we call the "Big Bang". The Big Bang was space and matter appearing from nothingness. A black hole is space and matter disappearing back into nothingness, where it came from. At the current time in our universe, black holes exist only locally, dispersed thinly throughout space. As time progresses (billions of years), distinct black holes will merge, forming larger black holes, eventually usurping all space and matter in existence, leaving behind nothing. And then, a new Big Bang, followed by its inverse, can occur again. The only somewhat confusing part is that, while the universe may have expanded from a single point (the Big Bang), it will not contract into a single point before disappearing. I'm not entirely sure why, but this is exactly the same we see with all extinct life forms: evolving from a single point/origin, but disappearing as a multitude of separate things spread out over their habitat. Or perhaps it's simpler to just say: from the perspective of the universe space doesn't exist. The universe comprises space. It doesn't move in space, it is space (and all that it contains).
- snarfy 10y agoMight as well throw my own ideas out: 1. Near the surface of a black hole, spacial dimensions become time-like, and the time dimension becomes space-like. If our universe started as a singularity, then our time dimension may be the squashed higher spacial dimension of some higher order universe. 2. Black holes supposedly can have electric charge. If the space around a black hole is distorted as described in 1., the electric charge would appear to the rest of the universe as a magnetic monopole. Black holes are magnetic monopoles.
- drdeca 10y agoErr, a black hole having an electric charge and spinning would, I think, produce a magnetic field, but it would m not be a monopole. It would be a magnetic dipole, like an electron.
- snarfy 10y agoThis is the accepted belief. I'm considering a more basic model of a static, non spinning but electrically charged black hole. It's really an electromagnetic field not two separate fields, and it seems the gravity would warp the electromagnetic field back around so that from our reference frame we see a magnetic not electric charge aka monopole.
- millstone 10y agoOk, let me try to address these: > Black holes don't exist (time dilation prevents them from forming in a finite time) It's true that distant observers cannot observe anything past the event horizon. But if you doubt that a black hole exists, you can always dive into it; the black hole will then certainly exist for you, and in a finite time. > Dark matter is gravitational potential energy Consider the Bullet Cluster, which is two colliding galactic clusters. The gravitational center of mass is offset from the visible center of mass. This offset cannot be explained as potential energy of visible matter. There must be something else, invisible and massive, i.e. dark matter. > Cosmological redshift is actually gravitational redshift We see cosmological redshift in all directions. If this redshift were gravitational, it would imply that our galaxy is at the top of a gravitational potential hill. This means that our place in the universe is very privileged, which is unlikely.
- justifier 10y ago> Consider the Bullet Cluster, which is two colliding galactic clusters. The gravitational center of mass is offset from the visible center of mass. This offset cannot be explained as potential energy of visible matter. There must be something else, invisible and massive, i.e. dark matter. i'd argue another possible explanation to add to your i.e. was addressed by the gp gp> then galaxies are not moving in the way we currently think they are. the movement of gyroscopes can alter a system's center of mass https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n_6p-1J551Y https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n_6p-1J551Y
- dhimes 10y agoThe rotation is the gyroscope. And the meaning of your last statement (the movement of gyroscopes) is unclear. The video is cool, but well understood by the same physics that is being applied to the understanding of the galaxies.
- justifier 10y agoexactly, but the gp threw in the caveat gp> then galaxies are not moving in the way we currently think they are. so if our calculations already take into account the gyroscopic movement of the bodies within the system, still the gp's thought experiment accounted for this by saying the real nature of the motion of the bodies is different than the motion that we are currently using in our calculations just saying dark matter ignores the potential for other valid explanation for the phenomena instead of there being dm offsetting the center of mass the gyroscopic motion of the bodies within the system also could explain the offset 'not moving in the way we currently think' is a vague statement and could be a direction of rigor for the gp if thae wished to pursue the idea some underlying questions that need to be answered by anyone that suggests our current understanding is incorrect in this regard would need to address: how are they moving differently? how could we detect the difference? how can our incorrect perception be explained? my> the movement of gyroscopes can alter a system's center of mass the cube video was intended to show that yes, this is well understood, and exhibit how changing the nature of the rotation of the gyros: location, direction, speed; in the cube you could move the center of mass to wherever you'd like add another dimension allowing the gyros to move freely stead being fixed within a cube and even more freedom to alter the center of mass could be achieved https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UnpLEnIqj_A https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UnpLEnIqj_A i agree it is well understood.. that is why i was using it as naive evidence to defend the gp's thought experiment from being dismissed poorly
- RaitoBezarius 10y agoThis is really interesting, and I believe you should be right to share ideas even if you don't really know if they hold water or not. > Black holes don't exist (time dilation prevents them from forming in a finite time). This is recalling me of a hypothesis called Cosmological censorship: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cosmic_censorship_hypothesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cosmic_censorship_hypothesis Basically, the universe is not allowing black holes to be directly observed, which does not mean they don't exist, but as I understand it: it means that we are not allowed to consider they exist. Because black holes are kind of an absurdity (well, we accept their existence, but… there is so many mysteries around them.) > I wish I had the math to flesh these ideas out to see if they hold water. You should not limit or censor yourself because you don't have the maths knowledge to test it and verify it. I believe that you can teach you enough maths if you are passioned enough. There are a lot of MOOCs out there, materials, papers, conferences, trainings to learn you more about what you need.
- lostmsu 10y agoMatter does not have to cross existing horizon for horizon to grow. Imagine a horizon radius R for a mass M (R=horizon(M)). Despite no matter would be seen touching that, time in sphere between R and R+dR ticks slowly even for external observers. So matter can get into this thin sphere in finite time. As soon as dM of matter gets into this sphere so that horizon(M+dm) > R+dR, the black hole now has increased radius and mass. Everything that was frozen on the surface of BH is now inside the BH.