5 ms·
> The mistake was ever allowing that kind of freedom in the first place, because people developed an expectation that it would persist. Sure, and then we would
by mindslight 10y ago
> The mistake was ever allowing that kind of freedom in the first place, because people developed an expectation that it would persist.
Sure, and then we wouldn't be talking about reddit but rather whatever site was actually free at the time.
The only reason web forums exist is because people are lazy about adopting decentralized Free software. Yet the owners of these centralized services, as well as paternalistic spectators, end up deluded that the communities they serve are "theirs" to mold and control. In reality these sites' power is but an epsilon, and they should be thankful they can at least exercise it to generate revenue by surveilling users who are too lazy to protect themselves.
- eropple 10y ago> The only reason web forums exist is because people are lazy about adopting decentralized Free software Or because that open-source software is user-hostile and has no serious argument for its use for 99% of people. When users don't do something you like, in almost every instance it's your failing rather than theirs.
- Practicality 10y agoProbably because it's free software. "Beggars can't be choosers" There are very few open software engineers who like improving UX. Since it's free you have to like it to do it, so I don't know if this will ever change.
- eropple 10y agoI fully agree with you. Damning the plebs for not being enlightened enough to use stuff that, if we're being real here, is worse by the metrics actual people use to decide what they're gonna use--that way leads to a really gross, insular mindset that doesn't help anybody.
- apatters 10y agoIs it really that they don't like improving UX, or is it that they don't know how, or don't respect people who understand UX? I like improving UX but when I look at many open source projects from the outside they are run by cranky ubernerds who triumph technical merits above everything else and I can't imagine them being very cooperative with someone whose specialty was "UX."
- jcbrand 10y ago> I can't imagine them being very cooperative with someone whose specialty was "UX." Sounds like you've never actually tried. I maintain an open source project (https://conversejs.org https://conversejs.org) that could benefit greatly from the expertise of a UX pro. However, to date no-one has approached me to help with this (specifically regarding UX). If you or any other UX people here are interested in helping out, hit me up at https://opkode.com/contact.html https://opkode.com/contact.html I definitely don't have a lack of respect for UX people, having been fortunate enough to work with someone whom I consider to be a brilliant UX designer.
- dbg31415 10y agoWe can all have different experiences. Good software takes strategy, UX, visual design, solution architecture, software development, QA, DevOps, post-launch support, KPI monitoring & analysis, marketing... and probably a few other skill sets to really have it thrive. The trouble with many open source projects is that they are one-man endeavors, and the person who started it cares more about control than quality outcome. "This is MY pet project..." is a horrible mentality to take when shopping for a partner. The moment the dev thinks, "Gosh, I'd rather spend my free time watching a baseball game than making those 50 changes the UX guy asked me to make... especially since all I really wanted from him was a color pallet..." that's about when the partnership dissolves. (Misunderstanding about the different areas of expertise intentionally included.) One person can't think time is worth more than a teammate's. Good software requires compromise and horse trading and a lot of planning. You typically need money to keep everyone interested.
- mindslight 10y agoFree software is merely user-unfriendly (presently). Webapps are user-hostile - overtly functioning as agents of third parties rather than their users. Blame isn't singular - describing users as lazy, including ourselves for using this website, both encourages individuals to exert more effort adopting better solutions and just plainly characterizes the problem. I do agree that the most productive way forward is for Free software to accept this facet for what it is, and to step up its quality.
- maratd 10y ago> Webapps are user-hostile What? What if I wrote it for my own use? What if it's among the thousands of web apps meant to be installed on a server you control? There's nothing inherent about the technology that requires third party control.
- CaptSpify 10y agoI'm not who you were replying to but... I think web-apps are generally user-hostile. You are correct that there is nothing inherent about it though. I think the same could be said for FOSS: There's nothing inherently user-unfriendly about it, it just has a tendency to go that direction.
- mindslight 10y ago"Webapp" generally implies something administered by a third party. The extra overhead of (dedicated server, network setup, redundancy, each user requiring connectivity) only pays off when it's amortized over many users who do not have to set things up. Sure, some of these release their code as "open source" and you can setup your own copy. But I've never heard of one where the majority of users actually do so [0]. There are some locally-hosted applications that are intended to make themselves available on :::80 that use a browser as a UI toolkit, similar to how we can have a native app that links a browser as a library. But such things generally aren't referred to as webapps. The network transit seems integral to this term. [0] Well there's probably some developer-focused tools where this could be the case because said developers already have to deal with "web stuff" and so the additional overhead isn't as high. But this doesn't generalize to all users.
- reptation 10y agoHave you tried using federated sites like quitter.no? It's pretty much the same UI as Twitter.
- JabavuAdams 10y agoMarketing fail. The name of a site actually matters. Who wants to be a quitter?
- Karunamon 10y agoYou find that power dynamic a lot in linked-community sites like Reddit and image boards. I find that the most enjoyable communities to be in are the ones where the site staff wield their power to make the user experience more enjoyable, rather than treating their users as cattle to be corralled. Acting like they provide a service rather than allowing you in their garden, in other words. A few Reddit communities sprung up that track content deletions, like /r/undelete, and the sheer amount of stuff that winds up disappeared on arbitrary whims, rather than violation of a stated objective rule, is huge. Coincidentally, when the moderators of those places show up, the attitudes on display are the worst kind of toxic.
- lrem 10y agoI'm wondering what kind of revenue can actually be generated by surveiling users. Any numbers?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- AJ007 10y agoTo be fair, a lot of web forums have run on free software. Centralization was what happened when usenet was over run with spam. Laziness is a poor explanation given one alternative exists and requires no maintenance, and the other takes a great deal of time, effort, and especially in the past, a lot of money to run.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> The only reason web forums exist is because people are lazy about adopting decentralized Free software. Well, other than the fact that a whole lot of the software involved in using web forums, on both the server and client end, is "decentralized free software". And the fact that other software (much, but not all, of it free) was adopted for discussions before web forums got popular. Web forums got popular because -- on both server and client end -- most people are going to have the tools anyway, so adopting a whole new software (free or otherwise) stack for discussions is unattractive.
- mindslight 10y agoIt ceases to be free software when it is adopted by many people beyond the administrator, as they lack the freedom to study and modify it. And it's certainly not decentralized - each instance of the software is its own walled garden. I can't install my own instance of say phpbb and use it to communicate with an existing forum.