4 ms·
And this is what exponents replaced. I think mathematical notation is like vim, it's easy to use but hard to learn. For example, I cannot imagine having to expr
by noobermin 10y ago
And this is what exponents replaced. I think mathematical notation is like vim, it's easy to use but hard to learn. For example, I cannot imagine having to express perturbative series in this notation or any serious physical model with the "wordy" descriptions from history.
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoAnd yet James Clark Maxwell expressed EM Theory without vector calculus! I guess they had more time back then, without TV or iPhones to soak up their day.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 10y agoYeah but: Maxwell's original was an absolute mess.
- noobermin 10y agoRight. Now what was "deep math" in 1860 is learned by every physics undergrad the world over. I would count vector calculus notation as helpful in that regard in the same way that gamma matrix technology helps graduate students grasp spin-1/2 transition amplitudes. Imagine doing these writing out the explicit matrices!
- andrepd 10y agoScientists today are inventing things 1000x more difficult, and any undergrad understands Maxwell's equations better than he did. That ridiculous quip is moot.
- pavlov 10y agoVim and mathematical notation are efficient for a power user, but I'm not convinced that "easy to use" and "efficient to use" are the same thing.
- kbenson 10y agoFor any notation, there are trade offs between ease of learning and power after learning. This is the same for mathematical notations as it is for programming languages. If you can effectively subsidize a complex notation/language such that everyone knows it (for example, through primary education), it pays dividends in many locations. There's a reason we use '+' for addition in many programming languages, and it's because it's familiar to everyone. Why is that? Because we all learned it long ago and have been using it ever since.
- noobermin 10y agoPerhaps "efficient to use" was the more correct phrase for me to use. As a physicist, I can definitely tell you it's easier than zenzizenzizenzic.
- ClashTheBunny 10y agoThis is the difference between easy and simple. Easy to use is often hard to learn. This is simple. Many of the best tools are this way. Violins are another great example. I like clojure for a similar reason: Rich Hickey explaining the difference at rails conf: http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=rI8tNMsozo0 http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=rI8tNMsozo0
- jandrese 10y agoI look at it kind of like Perl. You can express ideas in very compact and powerful ways, but the more clever you get the harder it is for other people to read what you've written. Eventually people start to complain that you're working in some sort of write only language that looks like gibberish to all but a small handful of experts.
- kej 10y agoThings like this, or the advantages of Arabic numerals instead of Roman, make me wonder what sort of mathematical insights we're missing out on today due to our current notation.
- mturmon 10y agoBy the way, this system of naming exponents looks a lot like Roman numerals to me. Pre-pending a name = raise to higher powers. It's a bit more ad hoc, because pre-pending a name multiplies the exponent (rather than adding, as Roman numerals do) -- making primes impossible to express. So they need the notion of a "sursolid" to express exponents (like 5 or 7) that do not factor into twos and threes. So, amazingly, he was able to create a system more ad hoc than Roman numerals.
- noobermin 10y agoSure. Any choice might have some downside. One thing very interesting I always think about is, as I hinted at in my post, is the concept of series. Consider this example 1 + c_1 a^2 + c_2 a^3 + ... Common syntax makes multiplication between factors implicit, basically grouping factors together in a compact form. The exponents further compactify the visual presentation. This, in a way, makes each term in the series stand alone and appear as a unit. It seems then no coincidence that in physics and math we often consider partial sums as approximations, and concentrate on particular terms seperately. In physics for example, people think of "order \alpha^2 terms" or "higher order corrections" or physical quantities which are often taylor series cut off at some order, of course, assuming the quantity. A very familiar example of this are Feynman diagrams which are fancy taylor series in powers of force coupling constants. One wonders which came first. It may be that the notation followed this focus on individual terms, but it is interesting that no one considers "expanding" transition amplitudes in infinite products or continued fractions. Also, there certainly exists much more knowledge (theorems, technology) around series than products AFAIK. Again, I don't know which came first because I don't know too much about math history, but it seems reasonable that the causation may be reversed.
- thaumasiotes 10y ago
- gerbilly 10y agoI'm always in awe of what the ancient Greeks managed to figure out with nearly no mathematical notation at all. Or Calculus in Newton's book. The techniques were sound, but you'd have to be a superman to work the way he did. Mathematical notation allows for better "chunking" and reduces cognitive load. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chunking_(psychology) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chunking_(psychology)
- jordigh 10y agoWhich book, the Principia Mathematica Philosophiae Naturalis? The thing is, he worked really hard to avoid calculus because it was too new and not widely accepted. Whenever he could give an argument without calculus, he would. It is hard to read but because he's trying to write calculus in the style of Euclid. So most proofs that would involve limits or derivatives would be written in a really roundabout way in terms more familiar to people at the time used to Euclid's geometry. This style of argument survives today in relics such as the geometric proof that lim sin(x)/x = 1 as x -> 0: http://math.stackexchange.com/a/75151 http://math.stackexchange.com/a/75151 Not only supermen were able to read the Principia, as obviously it was read and its ideas spread far and wide, but perhaps modern supermen would be required in order to see the actual calculus behind the veil of Euclid that Newton had to cast it at the time. I actually do read an English translation of the Principia from time to time for bedtime reading, and it's not that impenetrable.