5 ms·
Who pays for those people to remain unemployed? They still have food, shelter, utilities...
by vkou 10y ago
Who pays for those people to remain unemployed? They still have food, shelter, utilities...
- welanes 10y agoI don't think anybody pays them "to remain unemployed". But in most countries they receive social welfare while out of work. You could have them go break large rocks into smaller rocks if you have an ideological bent against people being unemployed but unless those rocks can be sold to somebody for more than what unemployment benefit is there's no incentive. Edit: Agree with the comments below. Rather than being idle there's many ways society could harness the skills and manpower of the unemployed for socially value adding, but perhaps not financially profitable, ventures.
- dkarapetyan 10y agoOP's point was they can do useful work but that useful work is not deemed worthy by the cult of the green pyramid with the eye so non-cult members pay the bill.
- foota 10y agoI think the point is that it's inefficient to pay people to do nothing when we could be paying them to do something.
- yummyfajitas 10y agoBut not the money to pay for these jobs....But in most countries they receive social welfare while out of work. See the contradiction here? We could put these people to work engaging in labor that is valuable, but not as valuable as the cost of their welfare. I.e. pay them $7.25/hour to do $5/hour worth of labor (net cost to society = $2.25/hour). Yet we don't. Instead we pay them to play video games (net cost to society $7.25/hour). https://bfi.uchicago.edu/news/scholar-profile/faculty-spotlight-erik-hurst https://bfi.uchicago.edu/news/scholar-profile/faculty-spotli...
- douche 10y agoBring back the CCC https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civilian_Conservation_Corps https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civilian_Conservation_Corps
- elihu 10y agoI would like to see something like that. Not as a replacement for welfare or unemployment compensation, but as a program where anyone who needs a job right now for whatever reason can get one easily. In the Portland area we have a large park (many square miles) that's being over-run by English ivy, and that's not going to be fixed without a lot of people going out and pulling it up by hand. If the city were to pay a bunch of workers with nothing better to do minimum wage it might be a lot cheaper than paying a team of regular permanent employees, and it could address part of the unemployment (and possibly some of the homelessness) problem.
- lastyearman 10y agoSo you would like government to compete in private markets with tax payers money?
- vkou 10y agoCommon infrastructure is typically not considered to be a private market.
- lastyearman 10y agoDon't know the details about US but around here government uses private contractors to build infrastructure. Using the unemployed would be competing against said contractors and make their employees unemployed instead.
- yummyfajitas 10y agoNo, I'd like the government to stop paying people to do nothing, and instead pay them to provide government services. Rebuild our crumbling infrastructure, provide child care to working women, left wing types have a huge laundry list of things they'd like the government to do more of. I'd also like to replace as many (currently overpaid) government workers with welfare types as possible. Why pay $50k/year to a unionized govt janitor when you can just order someone currently on welfare to do the same job for no extra money?
- mjevans 10y agoSomeone has to, otherwise you pay for more people to house people in jail... (one way or another; retrain the poor for jobs that exist, enact a Basic Income Guarantee, make being poor a crime, or try to starve the poor which will drive them to crime).