3 ms·
Not an economist but my thoughts on the topic are that society can make changes to accommodate this. This isn't a catastrophe, we just need to prepare. I think
by adamnemecek 10y ago
Not an economist but my thoughts on the topic are that society can make changes to accommodate this. This isn't a catastrophe, we just need to prepare. I think this needs to/will happen:
* labour will change from people having only one main skill to having multiple skills ("jack of all trades, master of none" will become "jack of all trades, master of fewer")
* this will be made possible by the fact that technology makes is easier to (re)educate yourself and also to tailor education exactly for your needs (c.f. university course unbundling, what if you could take different courses at different school based on which fits your needs (kinda like, mooc, yeah, I know mooc aren't the runaway success we'd hope for but give it time))
* we probably will not get rid of the issue that you have to pick a skill(s) when you are fairly young and you don't know if those skill will still be useful when you have to leave the workforce
* basically, people will have to learn a couple of skills pretty well and hope that the future jobs will require a particular combination of your skills (and if you are lacking some skills, you should be able to pick up new skills easily)
* it will become standard for people to keep learning
* i also think that the "default" unemployment rate might rise but unemployment will be more temporary for the single unemployed people
My view as someone who strongly believes in technological progress, I would guess I would summarize my advice as "you have to know how to leverage technology not to be outpaced by technology" but this isn't exactly anything novel.
- bduerst 10y agoThe trend here is that humans will become ubiquitous learning machines, valued for their ability to fulfill variable demand. Automation works well through economies of scale to fulfill large, steady amounts of demand. A.I. works well when there is a lot of existing data or logged activity to train on. For new, variable, or niche demand markets, Humans will be unique in that they can fill the demand faster than A.I. or robotics.
- adamnemecek 10y agoYeah, and your argument is a lot more concise. Have you read anything on the topic?
- bduerst 10y agoNo. I've worked some people to try and come up with product ideas to fit this type of future, but it's at least 5-10 years off, and dependent on factors like the current title-based education system being replaced by something more skills-based.
- adamnemecek 10y agoWho are the people working on this?
- bduerst 10y agoIt was just with some colleagues.
- gnaritas 10y ago> * it will become standard for people to keep learning That won't happen, humans don't work that way and it ignores the reality that many people will simply be incapable of learning enough to be more valuable than a machine. Machines will put a floor on value and people who can't exceed that floor (which will be most of society at some future point) won't have jobs they can do.
- adamnemecek 10y ago> humans don't work that way This is fundamentally an issue with the educational system. Change the system the rest will follow. Saying that humans don't work this way is like saying that nothing heavier than air will ever fly. > incapable of learning enough to be more valuable than a machine I don't think that AI and human intelligence will ever completely converge. > Machines will put a floor on value and people who can't exceed that floor (which will be most of society at some future point) won't have jobs they can do. I think that this breaks down to your interpretation of the world. I think that the world is a "fractal". Like notice how much specialization is going on.
- dredmorbius 10y agoI'm largely disagreeing with you here. There is, I think, ultimately a problem with having to unlearn old skills which is difficult. If nothing else, you end up with a workforce in a particular area, say, if retrained, who bring in very widely divergent backgrounds on how to do something. This might not be all bad if your goal is to mix and match methods and come up with something better. But that's rarely a firm's primary goal. Rather it's to have a uniform workforce, performing a uniform process, producing a uniform product. As you climb up through the complexity of tools, tasks, products, and processes, this seems to increase. I suspect it hits the tech world rather hard (it may be a reason for the intense battles over editors, languages, frameworks, operating systems, revision control, etc., etc.). That is: the problem isn't the educational system, it's us. (There are other reasons to believe that education isn't a driver of economic growth, including the rather inconvenient fact that education seems to trail economic growth rather than lead it.) I'm of several minds on AI, but a thought intruding increasingly on my awareness is that it's quite likely that programming will be among the first-affected employments. The training set is intrinsically amenable. Wether this proves an augmentation or a replacement remains to be seen.