7 ms·
This presentation misses a more fundamental point. It's not about the notation at all, it's about understanding that EXPT, SQRT and LOG are functions with a pa
by lisper 10y ago
This presentation misses a more fundamental point. It's not about the notation at all, it's about understanding that EXPT, SQRT and LOG are functions with a particular relationship to each other. That relationship can be expressed using a two-dimensional spatial notation, but that doesn't really help you understand the concept at all because there are a lot of different relationships that are naturally described by putting three things in a triangle.
What you really want students to understand is that expt, log, and nth-root are functions that are related in the following way:
expt(b, n) = x
log-x-base-b(x, b) = n
nth-root(x, n) = b
It's really that simple. No fancy notation needed. In fact, fancy notation always gets in the way of understanding because people naturally think in words, not in spatial relationships. Mathematical notation was invented not because it aids understanding, but because when you're writing math with pen and ink it's faster and uses less paper to use Greek letters and spatial relationships than full words. But when you're on a computer, it's easier to write out the names of functions, and that is actually a better impedance match to people's natural mental processes, which involve language.
[UPDATE] I would like to revise this: not everyone thinks in language. But everyone communicates in language. For communicating mathematical concepts, language is the best tool we have. There's a reason that the symbology in math papers is invariably wrapped in natural language. It's the same reason that the video has a narration. It wouldn't make any sense otherwise.
- zeven7 10y ago> fancy notation always gets in the way of understanding because people naturally think in words, not in spatial relationships. I'm pretty sure this is false for me. I think thinking in spacial relationships comes much more naturally to me than words. Words immediately start making my brain hurt. The notation you wrote is incredibly more painful for me to look at and understand than the triangles in the video.
- lisper 10y agoLet me rephrase that: people naturally communicate using language. In your head you may think in symbols and spatial relationships, but if you want to get a concept out of your head and into someone else's head you have to use language. There's a reason that the symbology in mathematical papers is invariably wrapped in natural language.
- lasfter 10y agoI still disagree. I wouldn't have understood half of my abstract algebra classes if the profs had only used words to explain the concepts. When you are first exposed to the First Isomorphism Theorem for Rings, a thousand words can't do what that simple triangle diagram can.
- jacobolus 10y agoThis is entirely backwards. Mathematics is the study of patterns. Humans have amazing powerful visual and spatial reasoning centers in the brain which can process huge amounts of semi-structured information. Writing words down instead forces everything through low-bandwidth serialized language processing apparatus instead. Mathematical notation (and computer code, and music notation, and ...) benefit tremendously from even slightly exploiting spatial reasoning skills. But better is some kind of diagram, interactive simulation, or similar. The fastest mathematical explanation is direct tutorial, person-to-person, where the amount of symbolic formalism can be reduced to a minimum, and hand gestures, chalk drawings, colorful verbal analogies, etc. can convey most of the message. When limited to pure symbolic formalism in a scholarly paper, mathematics teaching and learning is a much harder slog. The reason formal mathematics uses symbolic formal language as a canonical way of recording results is that it’s easier to figure out how to verify it step-by-step and make sure that the logic is correct. * * * I’ll give you an example, from a paragraph a friend of mine wrote several years ago in a blog diary: (I posit that you could decipher and understand this paragraph at least an order of magnitude faster if I drew a 30 second napkin sketch.) > The tea room I went to is an “eight tatami design”, a large square space. Each side is two tatami lengths (four widths, two widths and a length) long. The eight tatami are arranged in the following way: from the entrance—which is in a corner, second forward on the left—two tatami extend into the room to meet the opposite wall on their short sides; the tatami touching the opposite wall is met on its right long side by a third tatami’s short side. This third tatami’s short side in turn meets a fourth tatami’s long side, whose two short sides meet the opposite wall and a fifth tatami’s short side. The fifth tatami’s second short side meets the room’s the fourth corner and its long side meets the sixth tatami’s short side. The sixth tatami’s second short side meets the first tatami’s long side. These six tatami form a square with an square empty middle. The empty middle’s sides’ dimensions are all one tatami length long. The middle, then, is filled by two tatami whose orientation is like that of tatami one, two, four and five—short sides to the opposite wall and the wall with the entrance. I tried out alternative arrangements and I might be wrong but I think that this solution (or a rotation of it) is the only possible tatami arrangement for the room’s dimensions that fulfills the rule “four corners must never converge”. Going in a circle around the room, starting at the door and following the direction in the description there, we can number the outer tatami one through six and the two inner tatami seven (left from the entrance) and eight (right from the entrance).
- monk_e_boy 10y agoI didn't even know that powers, logs and roots were that related. My math is bad :( I struggled through some of the Khan Academy but I find it really hard to remember all the rules. The triangles really helped me. But maybe the video was overly simplistic? These triangles (visual items) can be placed in the mind palace. I can picture them now and could probably figure out where the log2(x) fits in.
- Practicality 10y ago"is actually a better impedance match to people's natural mental processes, which involve language" This is false when applied to all people. And this is the reason you disagree with the demonstration. Not all people think in language. I would wager that only half the population thinks in language. I think visually. It's work for me to translate my thoughts into words. I have to do a translation process to write this comment. It's easy work, but my natural thoughts are pictures of concepts. Richard Feynmann liked to talk about this a lot, but the internal mechanisms of thought vary drastically from person to person. Ironically, it seems common for people who think in words to suppose everyone else is that way. I am not sure why.
- lisper 10y ago> Not all people think in language Yes, you're right. But everyone communicates in language. I've updated the original comment.
- jordigh 10y ago> I think visually. I'm pretty sure everyone thinks visually or geometrically or spatially or something like that. Most certainly visually if you're not blind. Few people would find this to be an unsatisfactory proof that the nth triangular number is equal to the total number of pairings of n+1 objects: http://i.imgur.com/HCfGOYp.gif http://i.imgur.com/HCfGOYp.gif Better notation is certainly not worthless, and having a certain degree of symmetry or geometry to our notation is a good thing. I insist, nevertheless, that notation is not the biggest impedance towards conveying ideas.
- yorwba 10y ago> Few people would find this to be an unsatisfactory proof that the nth triangular number is equal to the total number of pairings of n+1 objects: I accept it as a proof for the specific case, but it took me quite a while to understand what was going on. I definitely can't tell whether it generalizes to arbitrary sizes this way. Maybe if I had a look at all frames at once I could notice a pattern, but the constant movement is really distracting.
- 10y ago
- Practicality 10y agoIn response to your update, I believe that visual methods of communicating are superior to words. Ever hear how a picture says 1000 words? Is a description of a triangle really superior at communicating the concept when compared to a picture of one? All that said the understanding of functions you point is helpful. Especially for someone from a computer science background.
- jewbacca 10y agoCounterexample: > In theoretical physics, Feynman diagrams are pictorial representations of the mathematical expressions describing the behavior of subatomic particles. [...] The interaction of sub-atomic particles can be complex and difficult to understand intuitively. Feynman diagrams give a simple visualization of what would otherwise be a rather arcane and abstract formula. As David Kaiser writes, "since the middle of the 20th century, theoretical physicists have increasingly turned to this tool to help them undertake critical calculations", and as such "Feynman diagrams have revolutionized nearly every aspect of theoretical physics". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feynman_diagram https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feynman_diagram ---- This is the first example that came to mind, but there are certainly very many others. Because the idea that written flat text is inherently a global maximum for representing/communicating/working with all concepts is absolutely absurd. This is immediately self-evident if you've ever tried to teach anything complex to anyone who wasn't already a domain expert in an immediately adjacent area.
- arcanus 10y ago> This is immediately self-evident if you've ever tried to teach anything complex to anyone who wasn't already a domain expert in an immediately adjacent area. I am a practising computational scientist, and I work in an interdisciplinary field. I work with the sort of folks you mentioned above daily. And while I often do not start with an equation, that does not mean they are not useful. I don't think anyone is suggesting that to a non-specialist they are. Typically, I start with thought experiments or plots. People are often visual learners. However, that does not mean that mathematical notation is a problem. Mathematics is a language, and like any language one must spend years (or in my case, decades) learning how to 'speak' it. While I would not suggest it is inherently a global maximum, I'm skeptical it is not at least a pretty good local max.
- posterboy 10y agoCould this be because as you go, you introduce more dimensions, degrees of freedom into your mental model. To accommodate for this, the brain needs to make room, and time and time again needs to reshuffle to make space for more connections or to eventually collapse them into multiple different models of a lesser degree. I just read that second order logic can represent all higher order logics. The degree of the logic means the degree of nesting of sets into sets, that are quantified over by the logic expression. If sets of sets of values are all it takes, a two dimensional spatial representation should be enough. So far so good? The problem with text is that it is largely sequential, i.e. one dimension, left to right. > I am a practising computational scientist only practice makes perfect (notice the 2nd C ;-)
- mjfl 10y agoThis would have made self learning much easier for me. I remember when I was in high school I tried reading "The Road to Reality" by Roger Penrose and the gradient symbol seemed like some magical incantation only sorcerers could understand. If I had been told it was just a simple symbolic manipulation, I probably could have gotten through that section (now I would probably just Google it). I bet if Professor Penrose rewrote his book in code-language it would be much easier to learn, at least for software engineers!
- tnecniv 10y ago"By relieving the brain of all unnecessary work, a good notation sets it free to concentrate on more advanced problems, and, in effect, increases the mental power of the race" -- Whitehead
- jxy 10y ago> not everyone thinks in language. But everyone communicates > in language. For communicating mathematical concepts, > language is the best tool we have. You definition of language is really narrow. Perhaps you really want to say that people are only comfortable in their native tongue? Do you consider 'expt' is a language? Actually I have no idea what "expt" is, which means we are not using the same language. I guess that was pow(3) or b*n The inverse function 'log-x-base-b' also confuses me, is it b⍟x or x⍟b By the way, I'm speaking in unix man and a programming language there. People need to understand notation is a language. In you three lines of functions, you've used (),= four notational symbols, without which your statement would be uselessly long. People do communicate in languages. Math notations happen to be the native tongue of people using math (they were taught at first in schools). For people speaking in that different language, the following are the same: bⁿ=x b^n=x pow(b,n)==x b*n=x Edit: reformat because HN eats my power function.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mcphage 10y ago> It's not about the notation at all, it's about understanding that EXPT, SQRT and LOG are functions with a particular relationship to each other. The notation being proposed is for those three specific functions. It's just replacing the existing notations for those functions with a new notation for those functions. Specifically, the author claims that this notation will make the relationship between those functions clearer. > because there are a lot of different relationships that are naturally described by putting three things in a triangle. He's not proposing this as a generic functional notation, but rather as a notation for these three specific functions. So yes, many other functions might benefit from a similar sort of notation, but this proposal isn't for any of them. > But everyone communicates in language. For communicating mathematical concepts, language is the best tool we have. When teaching math, teachers use a combination of natural language, formulae, tables, and diagrams. Teaching math without words would be (as you point out) nonsensical; but teaching math only using words would be incredibly hard to understand & follow.
- nnq 10y agoNope... The triangle notation is actually awesome because it does NOT put all the focus on the fact that EXP, SQRT an LOG are functions, and it actually promotes thinking at a higher level than first order functions: it's about an expression than can generate multiple functions or a higher order function. Let me explain: Let we define EX(b, e, x) := { pow(b, e) == x } And then the notational rule saying that "substitution a parameter for a star/asterix in an expression is defined as the value obtained by solving that expression for the substituted parameter", so now we have: EX(b, e, *) == pow(b, e) EX(a, *, b) == log(a, b) EX(*, e, x) == root(e, x) # or sqrt(x) if e == 2 And here you go: "triangles notation" in "words" :) And from this on you can go much easier to much deeper questions than the ones you get from staring at the graphs of 3 different functions that don't seem to relate much to each other. Classic mathematical notation is great for doing very basic physics and engineering... but horrible for anything deeper. Only thing is that people doing anything deeper are smart enough to be able to tolerate a few horrible notations and probably even like them because they scare the "peasants" away :) But we should be prioritising what's best for education, not for the macho-ism of uber-physicists or uber-mathematicians, so go triangles go!
- Chinjut 10y agoYup. Frequently, in mathematics, we have some ternary relation r(a, b, c) such that fixing values for any two arguments uniquely determines a corresponding value for the third. This encapsulates not only the relationship between a^b = c, log_a(c) = b, and b-th root of c = a, but also the relationship between a + b = c, c - a = b, and c - b = a, the relationship between a * b = c, c/a = b, and c/b = a (as well as the non-commutative version of this where we have separate notions of left- and right-division), and myriad other such ternary relations. In all of these cases, a triangular notation is apt for expressing and emphasizing the structure that any two arguments fix the third. That having been said, that is all the triangular notation does; it does not help with any further structure that may be around for that particular relation (e.g., rules like a^(b * c) = (a^b)^c, which the triangular notation does little to simplify, though perhaps further notational choices could make these also immediate and clear). Still, when that ternary structure is what one cares to emphasize (and why shouldn't it often be of interest?), one should go ahead and emphasize it.
- posterboy 10y ago> people naturally think in words, not in spatial relationships Not at all. There was a prior post titled "The link between language and cognition is a red herring" (https://aeon.co/ideas/the-link-between-language-and-cognition-is-a-red-herring https://aeon.co/ideas/the-link-between-language-and-cognitio...). The brain follows a spatial layout that, as a graph, is at least three-dimesional. I'd guess that language can be encoded in higher dimensions, too, but I assume that the sequential nature of words in a sentence would require an ordering in a zero order logic to be logically complete. As I've learned from the RegEx discussion about the stackoverflow bug today, backreferences don't have to be done with recursion and that recursion and backtracking have suboptimal space and time complexity (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12131909 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12131909) (or sumsuch, I'm sure I misunderstood some). it's easy to transform your examples into one line, in some sort of differential equation. At least representing log and root as inverse(exp(x, n)) for bound x or n.
- omaranto 10y agoAs Gauss wrote: "In our opinion, however, such truths should be extracted from notions rather than from notations." (Nowadays most technical math is written in English, but back in Gauss's time people used Latin. He really wrote: "At nostro quidem iudicio huiusmodi veritates ex notionibus potius quam es notationibus hauriri debebant.")
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- johnbm 10y agoEveryone communicates in language, but not all language is made out of words and symbols written linearly on paper.
- sullyj3 10y ago"people naturally think in words, not in spatial relationships" I think you may be committing the typical mind fallacy. I often find I have to consciously shove words out of my phonological loop so that I can focus on visualizing a concept in order to understand it.