6 ms·
My points of skepticism: 1. Semis. A typical long haul semi gets well under 10MPG. In some cases not much more than half that. They are heavy and need a lot of
by ams6110 10y ago
My points of skepticism:
1. Semis. A typical long haul semi gets well under 10MPG. In some cases not much more than half that. They are heavy and need a lot of energy to move. A Tesla Model S weighs 4650 lbs and has a range of a couple of hundred miles. A semi truck can weigh up to 80,000 lbs. That is a lot of weight to get rolling and a lot to pull up a grade. Semis spend a large part of their time driving at highway speeds where air resistance is at a maximum. To achieve useful performance an electric semi will need a lot of batteries which will reduce its cargo capacity (Federal law regulates the maximum gross weight), which reduces its value to freight companies.
2. Autonomy. I think this will take a lot longer to achieve than planned, both technically and socially.
3. Enable your car to make money for you. I don't want anyone using my car. Legal liability is one reason. As owner of the car, I am liable for damage it causes. So legal liability laws will have to change. If I need to go somewhere, and my car is not here, I don't want to wait for another one. I don't want to get my car back from another user and find food wrappers strewn about and used condoms under the seat. I feel that my car is an extension of my home. It's personal space that I don't want to share with random strangers.
YMMV.
- chinhodado 10y agoAgree with part 3. I fail to see why anyone who is willing to pay a premium for a Tesla car would be willing to let random strangers into their (new) car, unless the benefits far outweighs the cost/risks, but in that case, if the other car user has to pay a high price to use a Tesla for his commute, why not just use Uber instead? This can probably only work when the car is old such that its value has already been depreciated significantly.
- arcticfox 10y agoThat's the point: it's for people that want to own a Tesla but can't afford it. Not for people that can afford to own a Tesla and have it sit idle waiting for them 90% of the time (like all of today's owners).
- mjevans 10y agoFor those that can afford it, they can send the car back for family to use.
- sjtgraham 10y ago> Semis spend a large part of their time driving at highway speeds where air resistance is at a maximum. Why would a self-driving cargo vehicle drive at highway speeds? A human truck driver can only drive 11 hours/day, an autonomous vehicle can be on the move 24/7 and so could travel at slower, more efficient speeds while completing trips on similar time scales. > To achieve useful performance an electric semi will need a lot of batteries which will reduce its cargo capacity (Federal law regulates the maximum gross weight), which reduces its value to freight companies. Don't forget about the solar roof unit. There is a lot of surface area on a trailer. This could offset some of the energy requirements along with other technology such as regenerative breaking. Also consider that a supercharger network might be constructed. > Autonomy. I think this will take a lot longer to achieve than planned, both technically and socially. I disagree. The evidence is to the contrary technically speaking. The matter is more subjective on the social front, but we've seen how popular attitudes change to technology. It might be a fatuous example but consider how it was once uncool to be online and then MySpace happened, and consider how it was anathema to be anywhere near online dating, the archetypal hallmark of a loser, then Tinder happened and now it's almost de rigueur in the mainstream. > Enable your car to make money for you. I don't want anyone using my car. Legal liability is one reason. As owner of the car, I am liable for damage it causes. Insurance (including public liability insurance) is already a thing. Insurance is priced according to risk, so when autonomous vehicles are here and much safer than human drivers the insurance will be priced as such. > If I need to go somewhere, and my car is not here, I don't want to wait for another one. The post alluded to making your car available when you're at work etc. I expect the intention is ensure it has returned to you by the time you want to go home. > I don't want to get my car back from another user and find food wrappers strewn about and used condoms under the seat. These are valid concerns I share too.
- Vik1ng 10y agoA semi travelling a very slow speeds would need his own lane or it would significantly increase the risk of accidents (unless every car on the road is autonomous). Solar on the roof is most likely rather insignificant and will also just add weight.
- 10y ago
- nkw 10y ago> Legal liability is one reason. As owner of the car, I am liable for damage it causes. So legal liability laws will have to change. This, at least in most of the United States, is not a correct statement of the law. Absent something like Negligent Entrustment[1] or Vicarious Liability[2], one's ownership of a vehicle does not determine if one is liable if damage is caused while another is operating the vehicle. Some might be under this impression because we tend to purchase insurance "for a vehicle", however liability is placed upon a negligent driver (not owner). Somewhat of a discussion of this is found here: http://www.claimsjournal.com/news/national/2014/06/05/249762.htm http://www.claimsjournal.com/news/national/2014/06/05/249762... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Negligent_entrustment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Negligent_entrustment [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vicarious_liability https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vicarious_liability
- ams6110 10y agoI can't speak for everywhere, I'll admit. Where I live, the owner is responsible, as I have learned firsthand by involvement in several accident scenarios where the vehicle owner was not driving at the time. You must purchase insurance for each vehicle you own, and if you allow another person to drive your vehicle you retain the liability. I'm sure there are some exceptions e.g. if your vehicle is stolen, or in cases of a clear contract such as a vehicle lease or rental. Subject to the foregoing, it seems entirely reasonable that if I allow a random stranger to use my car while I'm at work, that is my decision and my responsibility. And I would not do it.
- Cthulhu_ 10y agoHow is the liability with rental or lease cars though? I think that's the legal structure in which the Tesla car pool would operate in. If Tesla would lease out their own cars instead of sell them, they could make a lot of money too, plus lower the bar for a lot of people to drive it.
- tim333 10y agoI presume with a shared Teslas there would be a specific shared Tesla insurance policy to sort stuff.
- nommm-nommm 10y ago>Legal liability is one reason. As owner of the car, I am liable for damage it causes. Ummm... Where the hell do you live where this is the case?
- ams6110 10y agoWhere do you live that this is not the case? I know some states have (or had) a "no-fault" approach to automobile liability claims but I thought it was a minority and perhaps had been mostly abandonded? Who else would be responsible, if not the owner?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- whatusername 10y agoThe driver?
- yladiz 10y agoThat makes obvious sense, but then the question becomes who has to have insurance on the car that's being driven: the owner/primary user, or the current driver? Generally I can drive my parent's or friend's car without an issue even if I'm not the person insuring the car, because the car is insured, but if I get into an accident the person responsible is not necessarily the driver, it's the insurance holder. Would we require every driver to have insurance for the car they're driving (and if we did, laws would have to chance because you can't currently have insurance "per hour").
- beambot 10y agoAutonomy is a big win for semis -- even just platooning (drafting) is a huge win. Two startups in this space: Otto & Peloton. As for power density... going to a turbine engine feeding electric power systems is a sufficiently big win compared to straight-up diesel ICE. There's a big industry group looking into this: http://corporate.walmart.com/_news_/news-archive/2014/03/26/walmart-debuts-futuristic-truck http://corporate.walmart.com/_news_/news-archive/2014/03/26/...
- dave1619 10y agoYour point #3 sounds a like lot homeowners, before AirBnb figured out a way to address most of their concerns.
- aerovistae 10y ago1. They'll be able to line the entire trailer with batteries. Elon's pretty good at physics and engineering: if he says this can be done better than existing gas-powered semis, you're not going to be able to prove him wrong with some back-of-the-envelope arithmetic, as if he hadn't considered this. Obviously he has and knows it will work. Tesla didn't get this far on vague conjecture. 2. Maybe so, but it will happen, and the delay won't really hinder Tesla. They're not dependent on it. It's not like they can't sell cars without it. It's just another tier of advancement to be reached in time. 3. Maybe you don't want anyone using your car (nor would I), but that's why it's optional. A lot of people will love this. Owning a car of that level of quality for a greatly reduced price thanks to earned revenue. I assume the app will let you monitor its location, and you can anticipate when you'll need it back again and call it back before that time arrives. Or....just take someone else's car if you're in such a rush :) Sharing is caring.
- dingaling 10y ago> 1. They'll be able to line the entire trailer with batteries But that's an enormous inversion of expense that falls on the trailer owners. The tractor-trailer model works so well because it concentrates complexity and cost in the tractor. At present trailers are mechanically fairly simple and require only routine servicing with a basic toolkit. They draw power from their tractor. An owner can maintain a fleet of trailers to match their peak demand and are immediately available. Just charter a tractor and away they go. Battery-equipped trailers will be much more complex, heavy and maintenance-intensive. More expensive but with a smaller payload and prolonged periods of unavailability whilst charging. The cost of haulage charters will have to reduce by magnitudes to make that an attractive preposition.
- pfranz 10y agoSemis sound like a better market for hot-swapping and renting your battery compared to consumers. The rollout is a bit more straightforward since the travel routes are more obvious (weigh stations or truck stops).
- 10y ago
- dredmorbius 10y agoA future for semis which have a 4-8 km off-grid range, and operate largely as self-assembling intermodal train rigs for long-distance transport, either on existing railcars or with a streamlined wheelset mechanism, might work. I agree that the power densities for long-haul, BEV trucking simply don't make sense, even with platooning technologies. Intermittent fast-charge stations plus catenaries, with off-grid battery capabilities, would be a possibility however. Another option would be for always (or nearly-always) tracked operation, with what's effectively a cargo-streetcar function within cities and suburbs, and traditional rail off. Functions such as field-to-depot transport would almost certainly still require fueled vehicles.
- jpalomaki 10y agoMaybe one way on trucking side would be do to things a bit differently. Instead of one tractor pulling the cargo from start to finish, use electric/autonomous vehicles on those parts of journey where they are the most efficient choice and leave the rest to diesel/humans. Like things are done in container world, where the same container can travel via different modes of transportation during its journey.
- nickez 10y ago> 1. Semis I think that highways in the future will become electrified and then teslas semis will be able to charge as they go on the highways. http://www.bbc.com/news/technology-23603751 http://www.bbc.com/news/technology-23603751 https://www.scania.com/group/en/worlds-first-electric-road-opens-in-sweden/ https://www.scania.com/group/en/worlds-first-electric-road-o...
- jest3r1 10y agohttps://nikolamotor.com/one https://nikolamotor.com/one
- barumrho 10y agoIf you assume that trucks can be fully autonomous, then cost efficiency may be achieved by more trucks carrying less weight since driver wage is no longer a part of the equation.
- decisiveness 10y ago3. Seems like the biggest issue to me. If you're an Uber/taxi driver you have the ability to stop the car and kick people out. Your presence is what mostly deters the riders from doing untoward shit. Just think about everything drunk people would do if a driver was absent. Whatever counter Tesla might have in store to prevent this, it would have to involve them analyzing/monitoring/recording the behavior of people in the vehicle, which would be a huge privacy nightmare that nobody wants to be a party to.
- tim333 10y agoOperations like http://www.zipcar.co.uk/ http://www.zipcar.co.uk/ could have the same issue and seem to do ok.